3 ms·
I have trouble taking such studies seriously. I have a life-threatening medical condition which typically causes people to be underweight and I was quite thin
by Mz 16y ago
I have trouble taking such studies seriously. I have a life-threatening medical condition which typically causes people to be underweight and I was quite thin as a child but put on a lot of weight as an adult (probably in part due to being prescribed steroids for my health issues). After finally getting an appropriate diagnosis late in life, I did some research and changed my diet to address my health issues. I have lost several dress sizes, even though that was not my goal. I was getting plenty of positive male attention when I was a size 24-26 and my doctor was telling me to work on my health issues and not worry about my weight (because people like me are typically underweight, which is more immediately life-threatening than being overweight), so I had no goal of losing weight. I was just trying to get healthier because I was so sick, on a lot of medication and miserable.
My experience tends to fly in the face of the pronouncements such studies make, so I just have a really hard time taking it seriously that you can come up with a generic suggestion for diet that will work equally well for 6 billion people.
- niels_olson 16y agoI applaud you for staying strong throughout your struggle. However, your exception proves the rule: people who don't have a reason shouldn't be overweight. Or underweight. Fight the good fight.
- Mz 16y agoI don't see how it proves that at all. Presumably everyone who is overweight (or underweight) is so for a reason. Given how many people wish they weighed less and can't seem to make it happen, often in spite of dieting, exercising, etc, I think something more complicated is going on than these studies assume.