3 ms·
A pacemaker has objective improvements over the alternative, namely, death. So if a pacemaker has a bug, it's still overwhelmingly better than the baseline sce
by gamblor956 8y ago
A pacemaker has objective improvements over the alternative, namely, death. So if a pacemaker has a bug, it's still overwhelmingly better than the baseline scenario of "no pacemakers."
A self-driving Tesla is not objectively better than a regular, human-driven car. The jury's still out on whether any self-driving car is even as good as the average human driver, so if one of them has a bug that causes serious accidents in reproducible situations, that's not better than the baseline situation it's being compared to.
- jimktrains2 8y ago> So if a pacemaker has a bug, it's still overwhelmingly better than the baseline scenario of "no pacemakers." Unless it goes of when it's not needed and kills you.
- yellowapple 8y agoRight, but the probability of you dying because you do have a pacemaker is (in the situations for which a pacemaker is prescribed) far less than the probability of you dying because you don't have a pacemaker. The same cannot yet be said about "self-driving" cars.
- jimktrains2 8y ago> Right, but the probability of you dying because you do have a pacemaker is (in the situations for which a pacemaker is prescribed) far less than the probability of you dying because you don't have a pacemaker. That assumes the pacemaker works more often than it doesn't. (Which is the case now.) It's an unstated assumption that doesn't always apply when generalizing your example.
- kilotaras 8y agoNo it doesn't assume that. We don't install pacemakers to everyone at birth. Even if pacemaker fails 90% of the time 90% chance of death is better than a 100% without it.
- jimktrains2 8y agoYou're assuming "fails" only accounts for false negatives. False positives are a thing. If there was a 90% chance of a pacemaker going off when it wasn't needed, they wouldn't be used as it'd cause nearly as meany deaths as it prevents, assuming no false negatives.