2 ms·
>What we do know about actual evolution seems to support Gall's Law. But human design is not evolution. That Gall's law, which is a form of incrementalism, rin
by Barrin92 8y ago
>What we do know about actual evolution seems to support Gall's Law.
But human design is not evolution. That Gall's law, which is a form of incrementalism, rings true for a system without a designer appears to be almost true by definition, but it is far from obvious for human design.
We have many examples of human architecture that went from "0 to 1". The von Neumann architecture. The first spaceships, new breakthrough theories in mathematics or physics. While you can debate whether those systems were built literally from scratch or not, they sure made qualitative jumps not comparable to evolution.
And also I would point out that there is a strong survivorship bias in Gall's law. All sustainable complex systems built up incrementally that are still around are by definition an example of success. But we don't actively see the resource cost of incrementalist dead-ends, or the limitations. ("You don't get to the moon by climbing up trees"), whereas every failure in ambitious design is actively debated, or even derided.
- wallace_f 8y agoVon Neumann, seems to me, brilliant and his contributions vastly underappreciated. But isn't any architecture, by definition, also the creation of a complex system from simple systems?
- Majromax 8y ago> And also I would point out that there is a strong survivorship bias in Gall's law. All sustainable complex systems built up incrementally that are still around are by definition an example of success. But we don't actively see the resource cost of incrementalist dead-ends, or the limitations. I don't see this as a problem. As expressed, Gall's Law describes necessary conditions for success, not sufficient conditions. Not all evolutions of simple systems will work, but according to the law not starting with a simple system will always result in failure. There's still undoubtedly plenty to criticize, and I'm sure there's a law somewhere saying that all simple laws are wrong, but this law does express a coherent logical proposition.
- infinity0 8y ago> The von Neumann architecture How do you get that? There was decades of prior experience both in computer science theory as well as practice, especially from the code breakers in WW2.
- daniel-cussen 8y agoDecade of experience at best. An example from 1945 and also from von Neumann is Mergesort, the first O(n logn) sorting algorithm, and still in use to this day. Von Neumann was known for inventing things from absolute scratch.
- cageface 8y agoThe fascinating and sometimes exasperating thing about software development is that there are no absolutes. You can find exceptions to any “rule” you care to name. That said, I’ve found that in the vast majority of cases you’re better off starting with a simple prototype and iteratively adding new features and refactoring than you are trying to build a complex system from scratch.
- aplummer 8y agoIn no way did spaceships go from 0 to 1. Rocketry and flight, combustion, the list goes on and on.