7 ms·
California Restaurants Are Dying Due to High Labor Costs
- eesmith 8y agoHow is it that countries with both high restaurant wages and no tipping (eg, $20/hour for McD's in Denmark) still have restaurants? Given that, I can't help but think there's something wrong with the analysis. I have no domain expertise to tell what it might be.
- PhoenixReborn 8y agoThey have socialized health care and better support systems in the form of basic income/welfare. Also, value added taxes exist in many EU nations which fund these programs. The cost of goods is also higher, which generally funds the wages of the employees. But in this case, the author is complaining about the tax law associated with tipping and not with the minimum wage hike in itself. Doing away with tipping will be great on a societal level but reforming the tax law will do a lot to keep restaurants from shutting down in the short term.
- eesmith 8y agoBut aren't there a large set of interdependent factors? Like, if everyone knows that the wait staff gets paid $15/hour then wouldn't there be less pressure to tip, say, 20% on meals? If all wait staff received at least $40/hour then I'm sure that most people simply wouldn't tip. And how would this change, to include tips as part of wages, help the "near-poverty cooks and dishwashers"? Are the businesses on the knife-edge of solvency that they simply can't afford to pay the back-end staff more? It seems more likely that the savings will go to the restaurant owners? You mentioned socialized health care. Doesn't that also affect the labor costs? That is, the US government already pays more per capital on health care than just about every other country - then there are private health care plans on top of that blowing the costs sky-high. By switching to socialized health care, it should lower the overall healthcare costs, so make it cheaper to employ people ... unless of course the restaurants currently don't provide reasonable healthcare coverage to their employees.
- bko 8y agoEverything is on the margin. A high cost of labor won't mean that you'll have no McD's. Some locations are very profitable and those will continue to operate. Others are less so, so on the margin many won't make the cut. If you look at number of McD's by country, Denmark has 1 location per 64k people while US has 1 per 23k [0]. Also some of that is preference. I'm not also not sure where you got the $20/hour wage for Denmark: Denmark Minimum Wage: None; instead, negotiated between unions and employer associations; the average minimum wage for all private and public sector collective bargaining agreements was approximately DKK 110 (nominally $16) per hour, exclusive of pension benefits [1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_with_McDonald%27s_restaurants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_with_McDonal... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_by_count...
- eesmith 8y agoThe $20/hr at McD's in Denmark comes from my memory of previous discussion on this topic. For examples, https://www.businessinsider.com/denmark-mcdonalds-pays-20-hourly-wages-2014-10?r=US&IR=T&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/denmark-mcdonalds-pays-20-ho... , "Fast food workers make a minimum of $20 hourly in Denmark, while in the US, their average hourly wage is $8.90, according to the Times report." and from https://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/03/other-98/can-you-make-45000year-mcdonalds-denmark/ https://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/03... : > Statistics Denmark is the government agency that tracks labor information. For the category of food service counter attendants, the annual pay in 2012 was over $41,000. That is for all companies, not just McDonald’s. On an hourly basis, that translates to about $20 an hour.
- jgowdy 8y agoIf you're going to compare wage numbers between nations, why are we comparing gross pay? If you're taxed drastically more, the pay difference isn't very relevant. Obviously you get social benefits, which become much harder to compare. But comparing someone taxed at 39% to someone taxed far far less by comparing gross wages is nonsensical to me. When you look at the tax rate, the difference in pay is far less severe.
- bookmarkacc 8y agoI feel like the restaurant where a server makes $44 ans these struggling restaurants are not the same. Feels unfair to make it seem like the greedy server is gouging the poor mom and pop when they already made $44.
- Mikeb85 8y agoRestaurateurs need to think harder. All restaurateurs in a single city and state are faced with the same labour laws, minimum wage and all restaurateurs in a single area are faced with the same cost of real estate and living for their employees. It's a fair playing field. If they can't find employees, they need to pay more. And if they pay them more, they raise prices. And consumers will have to pay them if they want to eat out. And they do. It just takes some actual balls to raise prices. When you hear all the complaining, it's always shit restaurateurs that can't compete on quality or service, so they screw over as many people as they can to attempt to compete on price. At the end of the day, it's a competitive industry and people will find a way to make money.
- navane 8y agoThe server should pay tax on the tip. If I understand correctly, tips now go to the server, but the restaurant owes tax on the tip. So the more the server makes in tips, the more the restaurant owes in tax. Therefore the server should deduct the tax from the tip before they take it home, and leave that deduction to the restaurant, who can then give it to the tax authority.
- mcv 8y agoI really hope that's not how it works. It would mean that a restaurant would get punished instead of rewarded for getting a big tip. There's basically two options: either the tip belongs to the restaurant and they can use the tip to pay for any taxes over the tip, and possible spread it out among their employees, or the tip goes directly from the customer to the server and the restaurant has nothing to do with it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kayfox 8y agoUh, the server pays income tax and social security withholding on the tip, as long as tips are reported properly.
- aestetix 8y agoThis "solution" will result in tip money being taken from servers who work hard and being given the servers who don't work as hard, which in turn will reduce incentive to work hard across the board, and lead to a worse dining experience for customers.
- llampx 8y agoYou can still fire the waiters who aren't up to your standards. I believe that the restaurant management culture is responsible for good service. I've had bad service at tipping restaurants and good service at non-tipping restaurants. To me it's not an indicator either way.
- Mc_Big_G 8y agoIt's the business owner's responsibility to manage their employees. Your work isn't acceptable? Fired or no raise. Your work is exemplary? Promoted or raise. Pretty simple.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> one of his servers made $70,000 four years ago, working 30 hours a week. That is $44.87/hour. Come 2022, that server would be making nearly $50/hour. According to http://www.in2013dollars.com/2015-dollars-in-2018?amount=70000 http://www.in2013dollars.com/2015-dollars-in-2018?amount=700..., that 2015 $70k ($44.87/h) would become 2018 $74k ($47.54/h). If he's getting $50/h in 2022, wouldn't that be a net drop in his wages anyway? Edit: barring a deflationary period, I suppose.
- pizzazzaro 8y agoIn the San Francisco real estate market? Dont be surprised when some of those workers start going homeless.
- foxyv 8y agoMy economics professor called it grandma inflation. Grandma hears that the busboy is making $70000 and freaks not realizing that it's close to $30000 in 1985 dollars. She still thinks that $70000 is a lot of money...
- chrisbennet 8y agoA study of San Fransico restaurant found the opposite. https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Bay-Area-minimum-wage-rise-hasn-t-meant-13210666.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Bay-Area-minimu...
- Simulacra 8y agoTipping is an anachronism from slavery and should be banned. I think tipping is a sham that businesses use to keep labor costs down at the expense of the worker. Banning it is the only way we're going to get rid of it, and force restaurants and other businesses to pay a fair wage. As for what that fair wage is, I don't know, because that depends really on the area; i.e. $10/hr is great for Elizabethtown Kentucky but would be poverty for San Diego. Tipping is the issue here, not minimum wage, and that's what we should really be targeting.
- Amezarak 8y agoAs someone who worked in a restaurant for six years, I strongly disagree. Working for tips is great. Taking away tips will mean a net reduction in wages. Your "fair wage" will almost always be less than I would have made in tips, even at a cheap buffet-type joint. Whether or not tipping is an 'anachronism from slavery' or not, it doesn't feel that way. It feels like I'm actually getting paid for my work. That said, losing restaurants is perfectly fine with me. People are too obsessed with eating out. More people need to prepare their own food more often.
- justin66 8y ago> Taking away tips will mean a net reduction in wages. Your "fair wage" will almost always be less than I would have made in tips, even at a cheap buffet-type joint. What evidence is there that this is true? The truth of it seems to depend entirely on what the hypothetical minimum wage for those workers is set at.
- nate_meurer 8y agoMichael Lynn, a professor of food and beverage management at Cornell, looked at this recently [1], and the study's conclusions seem to support @Amezarak's comment. Here's a quote: .[...]tipping is a form of price-partitioning that reduces perceptions of expensiveness even when it does not affect the actual total costs of eating out, so replacing tipping with service inclusive pricing may decrease consumers’ perceptions of value." Some pretty big names in the business have tried banning tips in the past few years, and it's been largely unsuccessful -- in some cases disastrous -- and the restaurants have almost all had to return to tipping to save their businesses. A few brave souls persist, but it's safe to say the anti-tipping movement in the U.S. has kind of petered out for now [2]. I suspect that if an entire city were to ban tipping, it would be much more successful since individual restaurants would not be at a comparative disadvantage due to whacky price perception. I personally hate trying to figure out tips. I cope by just adding 20% by default in every case, unless the service is truly awful. 1 - https://static.secure.website/wscfus/5261551/7004898/ijhm-tip-policy-effects-final.pdf https://static.secure.website/wscfus/5261551/7004898/ijhm-ti... 2 - https://www.newyorker.com/culture/annals-of-gastronomy/the-limitations-of-american-restaurants-no-tipping-experiment https://www.newyorker.com/culture/annals-of-gastronomy/the-l...
- dmode 8y agoI don't get it. Why not just stop accepting tips and pay the fair wage ? That's what the rest of the world does
- idDriven 8y agoI recently read this article and was surprised that services like Grubhub and Seamless are not only charging the user a service fee, and using tips to pay less of a guaranteed hourly wage to workers, but also charging a 10% -30% fee to the restaurant owners for result placement. This article compares this to mafia tactics. Also considering most restaurants don't have that high a margin traditionally even 10% is often all of the profits. source: https://newfoodeconomy.org/restaurants-eaters-please-love-god-stop-using-seamless/ https://newfoodeconomy.org/restaurants-eaters-please-love-go... Just blaming a living wage seems like a gross oversimplification. Also landlords and exploding rents were not factored into this article.
- raubtier 8y agoIf it moves, tax it. If it still move, regulate it. If it stop moving, subsidize it. I'll guarantee, you'll soon see taxpayers money going in to the resturant business.
- who-knows95 8y ago"THE SOLUTION: Let restaurant owners and employees agree on a fair, livable wage. Ensure they make that wage, every single shift. Just count tips as part of that." where in logic does counting tips as wage make any sense? pay your workers a living wage, tips are a gift of good service, not a vital part of someones living wage." i guess this comes from a UK perspective, but being paid a salary, and then earning tips with good service. made those tips even sweeter.
- drugme 8y agoThe title says "because higher wages", which of course touches all kinds of buttons. But if you read a couple of lines down, it's because of the broken taxation system: There are many reasons restaurants close. But one reason comes up again and again—California is raising minimum wage without letting restaurant owners count tips as wages, and yet still taxing restaurateurs on those tips. It’s a financial double-whammy they can’t recover from.
- yongjik 8y agoIf this leads Californian restaurants to declare "We don't take tips because we pay our staff livable wages (and also we pay less tax that way)", then I am one hundred percent behind this particular taxation system.
- olliej 8y agoTips aren’t counted as wages because federal minimum wage is lower for service. Many restaurants are switching to just charging true price and removing tips, which clearly solves this problem. At issue is that there are businesses that don’t want to pay market rates for labor but also don’t want to list the actual cost of the meal.
- CarlSchmitt 8y ago"California Restaurants Are Dying Due to Restaurant Owner Greed and High California Taxes, Fees, and Regulations"
- jgowdy 8y agoFor rough comparisons in these threads: The tax rate for someone making $20 USD per hour in the United States is: Gross pay: $41,600 Tax due: $6,157 Net pay: $35,083 The same wage through Denmark's tax rates: Gross pay: $41,600 Tax due: $23,212 Net pay: $18,388 Now in the United States, add unreported tips to that already colossal difference in net pay. Add reported tips to the gross pay side of the equation. That gives the American $20/hr wage earner an additional $16,695 plus tips to attempt to secure health care coverage compared to an equivalently paid Danish citizen. Effectively $1,391 a month to pay for health care coverage. You're also able to be on your parents health care plan until age 26.