4 ms·
I am still working on my philosophy around this but 1. The idea of a split between platform provider (ie hosting) and doscovery (ie promotion) is an important
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
I am still working on my philosophy around this but
1. The idea of a split between platform provider (ie hosting) and doscovery (ie promotion) is an important one
2. Google's PageRank assigns "juice" to a trusted domain - but youtube and facebook break that concept and so google (or all search engines) need to have clearer ways to define "publisher responsible for content that gets some recommendation juice"
2.a. By splitting the hosting and recommendation we can start to see different curation approaches - this dark maze of youtube recommendations (all I get is more Marvel) could be repacked with different curation algorithms - and the more data different AI has to share the clearer the dark / light patches can be seen by researchers.
3. Paid ad disclosure is a simple one to solve - we do it on TV all the time. Quirky home videos are great - but once you have ten million followers you are a business and can afford the regulation
4. Yes paedophiles do spend a lot of time watching kids videos online. We can use unusual watch time patterns to spot this, and that's good - but really paedophilia has been a problem for 10,000 years and we as society need to find wider bigger ways to tackle this - along with medicine this will be a huge win for social ROI
5. In short regulation is coming to all these platforms - but agreeing international rules for same platforms is going to involve amazing new levels of international co-operation and questions of sovereignty- let's try not to Brexit the lot up.
- ASalazarMX 8y ago> 2. Google's PageRank assigns "juice" to a trusted domain I am unreasonably disappointed about not seeing actual infancy metaphors in your comment.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoI don't understand your comment - who is being infantile?
- d1zzy 8y ago> 4. Yes paedophiles do spend a lot of time watching kids videos online. We can use unusual watch time patterns to spot this, and that's good - but really paedophilia has been a problem for 10,000 years and we as society need to find wider bigger ways to tackle this - along with medicine this will be a huge win for social ROI What is the law that is being broken here? Why is it a problem that someone (pedophile or not) is watching a lot of legal content (that happens to feature kids)?
- ceejayoz 8y agoWhat in the quoted sentence claims a law is being broken?
- simmanian 8y agoIt doesn't. And GP is pretty obviously asking why we should punish pedophiles for watching kids videos on YT.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoActually I am quite happy for paedophilia to be punished (or rather child abuse / rape in case there is some distinction between fantasy and acting upon it) but the main point I am making is that these platforms all have significant pressure to "tackle paedophilia" - and while they do offer a novel approach (there was a reference recently in wired showing tracking the time spent watching family videos by people wildly outside of the family network (ie usually a video of a kid dancing in a tutu is seen by 30/50 people. When views hit 10,000 there is something to investigate) But in the end "tackling paedophilia" is not something we can offload to the AI in youtube - it's a massive social cost and so a massive social investment.