4 ms·
Although my failure to see an elephant on the table does not rule out completely that there could be an elephant there, it does limit the possible size of the e
by whatshisface 8y ago
Although my failure to see an elephant on the table does not rule out completely that there could be an elephant there, it does limit the possible size of the elephant to a few micrometers. Failure to reject the null hypothesis does in fact provide evidence against the other possibilities, so long as "other possibilities" are understood to mean "other possibilities with big effects."
I don't see why a scientist at a conference who's saying that two groups are the same has to be heard as claiming, "we have measured every electron in their bodies and found that they have the same mass, forget about six sigma, we did it to infinity." Instead they could simply be understood to be saying that the two groups must be similar enough to not have ruled out the null hypothesis in their study.
- mjburgess 8y agoIt doesn't limit the size of the elephant. Any observation is consistent with an infinite number of models. Eg., your sight is defective, ie., in many cases: your sample is biased, not big enough, etc. And that A correlates with B, or fails to, to "some significance" is consistent with any causal relationship between A and B. > Surveys of hundreds of articles have found that statistically non-significant results are interpreted as indicating ‘no difference’ or ‘no effect’ in around half (see ‘Wrong interpretations’ and Supplementary Information).
- whatshisface 8y ago>Eg., your sight is defective, ie., in many cases: your sample is biased, not big enough, etc. You can't expect a statistical test to comb through your experimental procedure to check whether or not you did it right. (Least of all, to comb through your personal medical history. ;) ) >Any observation is consistent with an infinite number of models. I'm afraid that slips below the "get out of bed in the morning" pragmatism bar. Although it's a provocative idea, concluding that conclusions are impossible because you could be making a mistake or hallucinating would lead to, literally, not getting out of bed in the morning, if you took it seriously. At the end of the day you just have to hope that the human beings reading your paper will be able to tell whether or not you did the experiment right. Any statistical test just walls off one way (or a few ways) in which you could fool yourself. >Surveys of hundreds of articles have found that statistically non-significant results are interpreted as indicating ‘no difference’ or ‘no effect’ in around half (see ‘Wrong interpretations’ and Supplementary Information). What we really want to avoid here is requiring every paper to have a twelve paragraph Sophist disclaimer about how knowledge is impossible. ;) Just because the text doesn't say "oh and by the way there could be gnomes in the LHC that are fooling us to entertain themselves," doesn't mean that the author wouldn't begrudgingly acknowledge it as an epistemic risk.
- mjburgess 8y agoWell your "pragmatism bar" is higher that all future science. It isnt a trivial sceptical point. Does CO2 cause climate change, or climate change cause C02, or are they both caused by a hidden factor (one of many) or do they co-vary accidentally (ie., no joint cause)? No "statistical significance" of any kind can decide between them, yet this is how it is used. There is no way to do so with statistics; it requires repeated experimentation and refutation of all plausible causal models until the one remains stands as "the most plausible". "Statistics" is being used in place of the scientific method which it cannot replace. Covariation is not causation: the covarying of any number of variables is consistent with any number of causal models. No "test" decides.
- whatshisface 8y agoThe evidence for anthropogenic climate change involves a lot more than correlation, so maybe that isn't the best example. In any case, even if everyone on Earth is misinterpreting p-values, that's not a problem with p-values.
- mch82 8y agoThe point of statistics isn’t to attain absolute certainty or for the statistical test to make a decision. The point is for people to make a decision using probability as one available decision aid, and then deciding whether to place a bet.
- pmoriarty 8y ago"concluding that conclusions are impossible because you could be making a mistake or hallucinating would lead to, literally, not getting out of bed in the morning, if you took it seriously." Not if you don't have free will, which is apparently the conclusion that a lot of scientists seem to be coming to recently.
- whatshisface 8y agoHaha, then allow me to rephrase. A brain whose molecules react that conclusions are impossible will no longer chemically get out of bed in the morning.
- EpiMath 8y agoThis is why we report statistical power. It does in fact put probabalistic limits on the size of the elephant. In effect, we can make a statement like "at least 90% of studies like ours will detect an elephant larger than 20 microns if it is actually there on the table". It's not reasonable to interpret the results of a single study without consideration of power.
- blotter_paper 8y ago> It does in fact put probabalistic limits on the size of the elephant. Emphasis added (obviously). This word was missing from the analysis of whatshisface (GGP). While all of our models are probabilistic, and it would be silly to constantly describe everything this way in normal parlance, a discussion of how we want to go about building and interpreting models of the world is exactly the domain where this needs to be explicitly stated. You're not wrong here, but neither is GP. GGP is wrong, though not provably so (again, obviously). > In effect, we can make a statement like "at least 90% of studies like ours will detect an elephant larger than 20 microns if it is actually there on the table". The "in effect" disclaimer makes this statement arguable, but fundamentally we still can't say that. We can only say whether or not an elephant was detected, since detection (in this sense) is subjective. We can't say whether elephants actually exist or not. Perhaps all tables have invisible elephants on them, or perhaps all elephants are hallucinations shared by multiple humans through crazy coincidence. If 50% of elephants that actually exist on tables are invisible, and 10% of visible elephants are not detected due to error, then only 45% of studies will detect an elephant even though it will still seem like 90% to best of our knowledge. Since we don't know what percentage of elephants are currently detectable we need to be even more ridiculous and say something like "we guesstimate that there is a 99ish% chance that at least 90% of studies like ours will detect an elephant larger than 20 microns if it is actually there on the table". Edit: s/whathisface/whatshisface
- EpiMath 8y agoYes, okay. There are implicit assumptions in scientific studies ( e.g.: there are no invisible elephants, or the study we are doing is actually related to the question we are investigating! ). Power calculations refer to the model and not to whether it is the correct model. To some extent we routinely worry about certain types of "hidden from observation" problems: we have zero-inflated poisson models, or we worry about what happens if there is a limited susceptible subpopulation ( that could deplete over time differentially depending on treatment, etc ). But it is not correct to suggest that if a study of whatever power does not find an effect, then a huge effect and no effect are equally plausible. I have seen outrageous examples of "accepting the null hypothesis" many times, but many negative result studies have great value and even a single negative study can provide evidence against a very large effect.
- rfeather 8y agoThat's the thing. P values don't prove that anything must be. They simply say that if rerunning the experiment again, it would be surprising to get a different result. Conversely, if you don't find "statistical significance" it definitely doesn't mean there isn't a difference. In practice, it might (often) mean the study didn't have enough samples to find a relatively small effect, but the layperson making decisions (do I allow right turn on red or is that dangerous?) may not get that nuance. A book that really helped clarify my thinking on this is _Statistics Done Wrong_ by Alex Reinhart. Edit: remove "interpret" from last sentence to clarify
- bunderbunder 8y ago> They simply say that if rerunning the experiment again, it would be surprising to get a different result. That interpretation subtly suggests that the P-value gives an estimate of the likelihood of the alternative hypothesis being true.
- Alex3917 8y ago> They simply say that if rerunning the experiment again, it would be surprising to get a different result. P values don't tell you the chances of getting the same result, only with the chances of getting the same result by chance.
- penagwin 8y agoThat's not what OP is saying though. Let's say p=.001 - That means we're confident the results are not due to chance. If we repeat the experiment and get a different result, then we need to be looking into confounding variables and testing methodology. Just because the P-value is low doesn't mean there's no fundamental flaw in the experiment used to find the p-value.
- platz 8y agoP values don't talk about the result, they only talk about the probably of the null hypothesis being correct. You're only allowed to say either nothing happened or it's unlikely nothing happened, but it doesn't say what the "unlikely nothing happened" means.
- BenoitEssiambre 8y ago>They could simply be understood to be saying that the two groups must be similar enough to not have ruled out the null hypothesis in their study The groups need not be similar to fail to rule out the null. It can also be that the measurements are too noisy and too few. Also on the flip side, if you do reject the null, it doesn't mean the the groups are different. It could also be that you have so many measurements that you are picking up tiny biases in your experiment or instruments. Null hypothesis testing is almost always too weak of a test to be useful.
- BenoitEssiambre 8y agoTo add to this, the main problem with null hypothesis testing IMO is that mathematically you are comparing a infinitesimally small hypothesis: effect exactly equals 0.000000000000... to an infinitely large one: effect is somewhere between 0.00000...00001 and infinity. A tiny effect is very easy to reject (p<0.0000...000001). I can tell you before running the experiment that any two objects close enough for long enough to be in each other's light cone have at least a tiny effect on each other. The null hypothesis is hereby rejected for most anything relevant to humans. No need to calculate p-values. Just reference this comment.
- ummonk 8y agoStatistical significance doesn't communicate expected bounds on possible effect size though. If the two sigma bounds are hundreds of meters, the failure to see an elephant in the table is completely meaningless. On the other hand, if it's a few micrometers, that tells you a lot.
- mch82 8y agoMethods like gauge R&R can be used to help decide if the measurement system being used in an experiment is sensitive enough to detect an elephant of a given size. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ANOVA_gauge_R%26R https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ANOVA_gauge_R%26R
- skybrian 8y agoYes, failure to rule out an elephant means you probably didn't look hard enough (collect enough data). But successfully ruling out an elephant is uninteresting if you didn't expect an elephant. The problem is that "statistically significant" sounds impressive, but we shouldn't be impressed. I guess we need a less impressive term for this? Maybe something like "may have avoided statistical blindness."
- abecedarius 8y agoI've been suggesting "null-improbable". I'd be happier still if people stopped dichotomizing on this concept, though.
- rwj 8y agoThis thread is a prime example of the danger of p-values, which measure the likelihood of the data if you assume the null hypothesis. This is very different than the probability that the hypothesis is true.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 8y agoSorta, but people have taken that reasoning and (by this analogy) begun looking for elephants with their eyes closed. In that case, the failure to see an elephant doesn't actually tell you much of anything.