4 ms·
Isn't Gall's Law a tautology? Simplicity and Complexity is a catch up game. Thesis, antithesis and synthesis: Hegel's trascendence concept. First, let state th
by tautology12 8y ago
Isn't Gall's Law a tautology? Simplicity and Complexity is a catch up game. Thesis, antithesis and synthesis: Hegel's trascendence concept.
First, let state the following Axiom or mechanism for explanation: To explain something you have to reduce it to simpler terms. This mechanism stems from how we use our language: something is complex when one is able to compared it with a simpler system that is functionally related. So the use of the word complexity requires a hierarchy, a ladder that connects simplicity with complexity.
An artificial mind could conceive and use a different concept of complexity for constructing an artificial language. For instance, multiplying two 64 bits integers is a simple instruction for a computer. In the analogy of the mind as a neural network we know that some problems cannot be solved with perceptrons. Who devises the divide line between a simple and a complex system? Our minds compose the graph of concepts and relations looking for a decomposition from simple to complex. But the definition of something simple is completely relate to the context in which one poses the problem. Building a computer, as the one I am typing on, was a infinite complex endevour a century ago, today that endevour is a solved problem.
Finally, in maths simplicity is rescaled: Once you solve a problem and find a method to solve related problems, then the initial problem becomes trivial and the pursue of complexity is restarted. The ontology graph in our minds is always evolving with new methods, concepts and intuitions, and the simplicity complexity scale measured by the distance in that graph is dynamically adjusted.
So I believe Gall's Law is a consequence of how we use the word complexity.
Edited: Grammar, spelling, and excuse me for my poor use of English.