3 ms·
> Remember the Gall-Mann amnesia effect: expert believing news articles on topics outside of their field of expertise even after acknowledging that articles wri
by dragontamer 8y ago
> Remember the Gall-Mann amnesia effect: expert believing news articles on topics outside of their field of expertise even after acknowledging that articles written in the same publication that are within the expert's field of expertise are error-ridden and full of misunderstanding
This trope is tired and very annoying each time I see it come up.
I'm an expert in Programming Computers (at least, that's my job, so I assume I'm an expert). So I laugh at WashPo or New York Times, or Bloomberg whenever they make simple computer-related errors in their article.
But guess what? I'm not paying Wash Po for my computer news. I'm paying ACM or IEEE actually for computer news. But ACM / IEEE have no news on financial markets. (Bloomberg is an expert newspaper in the realm of finance).
ACM / IEEE don't have many articles on politics. Washington Post is far better at describing the daily political issues in the capital.
Al Jazeera gets American news incredibly wrong sometimes. But I'll trust Al Jazeera on middle-eastern news over almost any American-based paper (aside from Wash. Po, which has a solid foreign politics / world politics section).
Throw in a few "Conservative" newspapers for the conservative slant on issues, and you can get a decent balance of news from a variety of sources.
I don't expect general Newspapers to be an expert in my field. I read newspapers to learn about things OUTSIDE of my realm of expertise. Believe it or not, newspapers have "specialties", and they're quite good if you read them based on what they're actually an expert in.
-------
Honestly, I don't read too much NY Times, so I dunno what they're an expert in. Financial news is definitely a Bloomberg thing IMO.
- pmart123 8y agoBloomberg, FT, institutional investor, CFA, abnormalreturns.com does a decent job of aggregating. Sometimes Barron’s is ok. Blogs and podcasts can be better. It’s always good in finance to think “does this guy have an agenda or bias to push?” when a famous investor is being interviewed.
- dragontamer 8y agoIndividual blogs are good if you know the individual author and trust them well. Basically, a blog is great to follow a specific person you trust. But individuals still only have expertise in a narrow field. I'm not going to be reading Herb Sutter's blog for Java-programming news, or "The Old New Thing" (Windows-blog) for even Linux-ARM news. I read Herb Sutter for C++, Old New Thing for Windows-specific stuff. To get more information from a wider variety of sources, you end up reading Newspapers. You learn to trust the editor, a non-expert but someone who tries to promise quality of their writers follows a certain code. Even within a newspaper, different editors handle different sections (the OpEd section of WashPo is less factual than other sections) As long as you understand the trust model of various sites or newspapers, things are good. Some amateurs on "Seeking Alpha" or "Medium" are pretty darn good with their analysis, you just gotta learn their names and follow them specifically.
- pmart123 8y agoThat’s a good point. Without expertise, it’s much harder to filter good independent sources versus crap.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoBloomberg hasn't retracted their false Supermicro claims. They use their position to move markets first. Journalistic integrity takes a back seat.
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoI guess one problem is, if you rely on other people for money, they might believe you incorrect information and discount your opinion because you're not published in WSJ et al.