4 ms·
Speaking of parking, I think a lot of the need for street parking would go away if underground parking became more ubiquitous (and less expensive relative to st
by yellowapple 8y ago
Speaking of parking, I think a lot of the need for street parking would go away if underground parking became more ubiquitous (and less expensive relative to street parking). Make street parking (if it exists at all) for loading/unloading only (maybe max 5 minutes), and basically build the city atop a bunch of underground parking structures.
Obviously this wouldn't be easy to pull off for existing buildings, but for new construction it'd make life a lot easier for everyone (drivers have an easier time parking, pedestrians/cyclists have more room for dedicated sidewalks and bicycle lanes, etc.).
- ghaff 8y agoUnderground parking is sometimes put in as a requirement for new development. But even with new construction where you start by digging a hole in the ground, it's relatively expensive. It's sometimes a necessity when there simply isn't room in the area for e.g. commuters driving in to park, but it doesn't come cheap.
- bluGill 8y agoUnderground parking will always be expensive. It is expensive to build and engineers need to check on it once in a while. (walls aren't collapsing, water isn't filling it up, there is enough ventilation). While it can work, it isn't cheap. A parking lot is as cheap as you can get parking (just parking cost, ignoring externals) The trick is to avoid the need for parking in the first place. A small town can get by with on street parking. As the town grows it can get by with one parking lot on the edge of town if the growth goes up as well as out. Allow tearing down old historic buildings for something more modern. Allow houses to turn into duplex to turn into 5 floor apartments. (I stopped at 5 floors for a reason: for engineering reasons more than 5 tends to not be cost effective though in some locations the rich may be say who cares about cost and build higher anyway) More radically allow someone to turn their first floor into a shop and live upstairs. All of this allows people to live, work, and shop withing walking distance. Once you actually walk most places not having a car is something to think about. When you have to drive to work like most people do (because there are zero houses/apartments within walking distance of the office park their job is in) buying a car is the most cost effective way to have a car and then the incremental cost of using the car for other things is nearly zero.
- nine_k 8y agoI don't see.why above-ground parking is not considered. 5-7 levels of parking are about as many times as dense as a one-level traditional parking lot. It must cost much cheaper to build, though, especially if you can't dig a lot, due to financial or environmental constraints.
- yellowapple 8y agoAbove-ground parking would be okay, too, but those tend to be dedicated buildings specifically for parking, whereas I'm advocating more for building everything on top of the parking. I suppose it'd be possible to do that even with above-ground parking, though. First level would be storefronts + the garage entrance, second through Nth levels would be parking, then (N+1)th through (N+M)th levels would be offices and/or residential and/or more retail and/or whatever else.
- mc32 8y agoIIRC a city of two in the Emirate states (Masdar?) are /we’re going to be like this. Most parking is underground or at perimeter (though given the climate, unless they ventilate or condition it must be like an oven).