3 ms·
>At which point you can be happy that the rich person is voluntarily paying the 3 cent fine instead of the 1 cent parking fee. No, because the issue here is no
by andrepd 8y ago
>At which point you can be happy that the rich person is voluntarily paying the 3 cent fine instead of the 1 cent parking fee.
No, because the issue here is not like a fee, it's about breaking the law and how you should be punished for it in order for it to deter you. A more apt comparison would be "you can be happy that the a rich person is voluntarily paying 500$ to park on top of a crosswalk. In this case you want to deter the person from doing something that harms others, not just to make them pay for it, which in this case means either a fine indexed to income or jail time, so it hurts you even if you are a billionaire.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoNope, deterrence is still only required proportionally. If someone parks on a crosswalk and the cost of that to society is $200 and the fine is $500 then the fact that they're paying $500 means you're still coming out ahead. And if the cost to society is more than $500 then you've set the fine wrong regardless of who is paying it.
- rhizome 8y agoNope, deterrence is still only required proportionally Cite?
- mfoy_ 8y agoBut the point isn't to turn something bad into a valid transaction that is simply unfavourable. The point is to deter the behaviour in the first place, regardless of how much you're willing to pay to do it.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoBut why would you want to do that? Why would you prefer no-transaction over one that generates a $300 profit?