3 ms·
Are the logs you're referencing a public resource? Would be interesting to look at. >This implies it took almost three minutes for the previous crew to figure
by jcims 8y ago
Are the logs you're referencing a public resource? Would be interesting to look at.
>This implies it took almost three minutes for the previous crew to figure out the STAB TRIM needed to be CUT OUT after finding the trim is so wrong that they can’t hold the stick back.
I've seen a number of references to difficulty that pilots encounter managing forces of the flight controls in airliners. It seems strange to me that modern aircraft of that size would be designed in a way that aerodynamic forces on control surfaces would be allowed to translate back to control inputs in a manner that could overpower a pilot. I would think there would be some kind of scaled assist mechanism (ala power steering) in scenarios where there is a mechanical/hydraulic link. I'm guessing fly by wire scenarios wouldn't have this problem?
- bdamm 8y agoThe scaled assistance you're referring to is the hydraulic system. Airplanes are supposed to be light-touch because you need very fine movement control to balance the aircraft while landing. Think of the work required to move a pencil. That's about the level of effort a plane is supposed to require. But with the trim working against the pilot, the control required could be more like lifting a 50lb sack. Yes, most pilots can lift a 50lb sack. Can you lift and hold a 50lb sack for, say, an hour? Not many people can. (Without hydraulics, the forces would simply toss the pilot's body around. No possibility of control.)
- VBprogrammer 8y agoAlso worth noting that the reason we don't simply scale the forces down to the point a pilot could easily handle them is that above manouvering speed an aircraft can be damaged by full control deflection.
- bdamm 8y agoGood point. This is something I bet most non-pilots don't know. A pilot can actually damage or destroy an airplane through control inputs alone. In fact there was a case of a pilot intentionally destroying his airliner by rapidly slamming the rudder back and forth, but I can't find the flight reference now. And there are other examples, such as AA flight 587 where the large control inputs were causal in the crash that killed all aboard.