5 ms·
You're not expected to keep them that long, it's targeted to people who buy the new generations pretty much as soon as they are released. Who's going to pay 30
by lm28469 8y ago
You're not expected to keep them that long, it's targeted to people who buy the new generations pretty much as soon as they are released.
Who's going to pay 30%-50% of a new version to replace his airpods or apple watch battery ? [0]
It's the same with all these hi tech gadgets relying on tiny glued/soldered batteries. You can't replace them yourself because it's either proprietary hardware or you need to literally break the product to get to the battery. And companies either don't offer replacements or charge insane amount of money for them.
Apple can boast all day long about ecology and using 100% recycled aluminium, at the end of the day they're shipping unfixable gadgets. [1][2] But it's thin and slick looking so I guess most people don't give a damn.
The first time I saw a bose QC25 with AA batteries I almost burst out laughing but it's actually much more convenient than proprietary battery packs. Compare that to the new QC35: > As you were correctly advised, battery replacement is not a service that is offered. [3]
We'll drown in these gadgets way before we drown due to the sea level rising.
[0] > Run through your battery, and it’ll likely cost you $138 to replace both year-old batteries, which is nearly the cost of a new pair.
https://www.inverse.com/article/49363-airpods-battery-warrantly https://www.inverse.com/article/49363-airpods-battery-warran...
[1] https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Apple+Watch+Battery+Replacement/41080 https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Apple+Watch+Battery+Replacement...
[2] https://ifixit.org/blog/8690/airpods-are-disposable/ https://ifixit.org/blog/8690/airpods-are-disposable/
[3] https://community.bose.com/t5/Headphones-Archive/Bose-Quietcomfort-35-battery-question-for-prospective-buyer/td-p/32431 https://community.bose.com/t5/Headphones-Archive/Bose-Quietc...
- Angostura 8y ago> You're not expected to keep them that long, it's targeted to people who buy the new generations pretty much as soon as they are released. I really don't think that's the case. I was really quite tempted by them, but was put off by the lifespan.
- jakemoshenko 8y agoI think that's literally the point they were trying to make. You're not the target market so you didn't buy them.
- Phlarp 8y agoI absolutely agree with everything in this post, but the newest model of QC35s has like 15 hours of battery life. Even if it degrades 50% over 3 years they will be perfectly usable. Airpods don't have enough physical size to overprovision battery that much. Unserviceable laptop and cellphone batteries are terrible and apple is by far the biggest offender. disclaimer: typed from a macbook :(
- lambda_lover 8y agoThe QC35s also only need the battery for wireless use/active noise cancelling, so even if your battery dies on you you can still use them with a wire and a standard 3.5 mm jack. That is, assuming you still have a 3.5mm port to plug that jack into :)
- Phlarp 8y agoIt's also a lot harder to crucify the QC35s on their cost when comparing to airpods, which don't seem to have comparable noise cancelling. If you are going to shell out for a premium product at least make sure you get a premium product.
- alias_neo 8y agoI have a pair of Sony over-ear Bluetooth headphones, with NFC, about 7 years old now, MDR-1RBT. I have used them 5 days a week, for ~2 hours a day for almost the entirety of those 7 years, I charge them approximately once per month. They cost £400 at the time and have been by far the best consumer electronic investment I have ever made. When the battery becomes unusable I'll find a replacement and fit it my self, but I have no plans to replace them until they are deader than dead. I don't care much for "fashion" and they already have more features than I need (I use the physical switch to toggle off the NFC because I never need to use it), they do high enough quality audio (AAC/AptX) for streaming 320/16/44.1 and the battery life is better than any other battery powered device I own (barring the TV remote) even after all this time.
- Phlarp 8y ago
- rconti 8y agoYou're not wrong, but I have no noticeable issues with my QC35 or AirPods after 2 years. the battery life on the QC35 is simply astounding. I once wore them on a transatlantic flight including lounge stays. Got to my destination after 16+ hours of them being on the entire time, save 60mins during a nap. Some noise cancelling, lots of podcasts and music... Battery was at 60% still.
- userbinator 8y agoI often hear people saying that making such things repairable would entail massive increases in complexity and less thinness/etc., but in this case it's relatively easy to imagine how Apple could have made the batteries in each AirPod replaceable (as for the charging case, that one is pretty trivial...) while maintaining the dimensions and weight: https://photos5.appleinsider.com/gallery/30055-49077-999-AirPods-battery-(iFixit)-l.jpg https://photos5.appleinsider.com/gallery/30055-49077-999-Air... This is a metal-cased cell, like an AAA battery, only smaller. They could simply make the "stem" of the AirPod unscrew from the top to access the battery. They came up with an unserviceable design because they didn't want to, not because they couldn't. Think of things like quartz watches too --- they have just as small if not smaller dimensions, and yet you can still replace the batteries in them. (And if you think threads of that size are impossible for Apple... look at the few screws that hold iPhones together.)