11 ms·
Western society has a serious issue with nuance. No, we should not throw people in jail and ruin their lives for smoking cannabis. Yes, cannabis has some health
by keiferski 8y ago
Western society has a serious issue with nuance. No, we should not throw people in jail and ruin their lives for smoking cannabis. Yes, cannabis has some health benefits for specific people in specific circumstances. No, that doesn't mean that cannabis is somehow "good for you" in the standard sense of the the term.
This is why the "health benefits" arguments for legalization of drugs are generally a bad route to take. It would be far more fruitful to argue for legalization based on individual responsibility, personal choice, and related themes.
- eponeponepon 8y agoIt's not just Western society, it's humans in general. The rest of the world might not get so wound up about narcotics as the West does, but there are plenty of other things that the mob makes unhelpful binary judgments about.
- dalbasal 8y agoIn practical political terms (western and otherwise), "because freedom" is rarely a winning political tact. The legalization of cannabis was driven by cannabis being normalized. The news presenter and your daughter smoke grass. It was similar with gay right. Marriage rights, parental rights and such were driven first by "born this way," argueing that sexuality is unchangeable. Then, it came via normalisation as people came out and your friend end turned out to be gay. Eventually people concluded that homosexuality is fine, not a vice. "I think it's wrong, but freedom" only plays a role after the gay rights side wins. The dissenters can console themselves with it and put the issue to bed. That doesn't mean no one actually idealises freedom, but it rarely adds up to political change.
- nukeop 8y agoAny social sentiment can change with a persistent media campaign lasting 10-15 years, people are impressionable and don't form their own opinions.
- dalbasal 8y agoPeople are social animals. Our opinions on norms (homosexuality, cannabis, murder, monogamy..) are are generated socially. Individuals forming their own opinions, sharing them, dissenting and such is what social norms are made from... Individuals are drawing from the herd brain and contributing to it. No one's opinions are their own. If you grew up in a different time and place, your opinions would be different.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> In practical political terms (western and otherwise), "because freedom" is rarely a winning political tact. Isn't it? It seems to me that Brexit in particular happened because the people who voted for it embraced a message of "taking back control", and similar arguments about political freedom from the EU that was portrayed as oppressive and undemocratic, etc. (Though it's hard to know- I think a much more accurate model of the Brexit vote was that the country flipped a coin).
- dalbasal 8y agoThis is freedom in a rhetorical sense, and a national sense. The argument is/was that the UK isn't free because of europe, not that individuals aren't free. This is a lot different then the personal freedom I refer to, IMO. You could also argue that remain is the "liberty side," freedom of movement, capital & goods. Being rhetorical and abstract, it just begets abstract questions like "what is freedom?" or "what's a nation?" Cannabis & gay rights are personal, so less abstract. There's no sane way to argue that freedom to be smoke pot (also crack, cyanide) is not a freedom. In any case, no brexiter argues that europe works great, but we need out because freedom. That'd be the test, IMO. I think cannabis, homosexuality or whatever is bad, but it should be legal because freedom. My point/argument is that this doesn't work politically. People may justify the (new or old) status quo with because freedom, but it doesn't drive change. Cannabis & homosexuality laws change because people stop considering it a terrible vice, generally.
- zkms 8y ago> This is why the "health benefits" arguments for legalization of drugs are generally a bad route to take. It would be far more fruitful to argue for legalization based on individual responsibility, personal choice, and related themes. There's the second-order phenomenon sometimes called the "iron law of prohibition" at work as well -- legal regimes of prohibition tend to incentivize optimizing potency per unit volume above everything else (including safety). Since THC is the chemical in marijuana that, to first approximation, gets you high; prohibition (through that "iron law") has engineered a prevalence of high-THC marijuana strains. These strains tend have lower amounts of other, less/non-psychoactive cannabinoids such as CBD. Notably, there is research showing that CBD has anti-psychotic properties, which likely counteract the deleterious effects of THC that are mentioned in the article. For the record, I'm not a marijuana user (the smell alone disgusts me), I don't subscribe to the "weed is a harmless drug"/"weed is good for you" meme-theories, and I don't wish to promote irresponsible drug use -- I'm just pointing out that the set of incentives that prohibition creates are very strongly responsible for making drug use needlessly dangerous (for users and society at large alike). It's not about the health benefits of the drugs, it's about the health benefits (or the lack thereof) of prohibiting the drugs. And yes, prohibition is definitely still the law of the land, regardless of state/local-level "legalization" initiatives that withhold punishment for small "personal use" amounts or the like. People _still get_ searched/arrested/convicted/jailed for marijuana-related crimes, and as long as that is the case, the "iron law of prohibition" will keep doing its hideous work.
- mirimir 8y agoRight. Prohibition favored distilled spirits over beer and wine. The Drug War has favored cocaine over marijuana. Crack over cocaine HCl. Potent hybrid marijuana over traditional strains.
- vixen99 8y agoAnd is that decision based on a genuinely objective far-ranging cost-benefit analysis of the likely effects of legalization? I mean a report produced in the style of the green warriors who want us to recognize the true cost of industrial and consumer products to everyone on this planet. I'd like the see the score card for the pros and cons.
- Al-Khwarizmi 8y agoTo me, the best argument (not only for cannabis, but for stronger drugs too) is that illegalization has been tried for a long time and it just doesn't work in practice. I don't consume any drugs other than alcohol and don't have any interest in doing so, but if I did, it would be trivial to obtain them in my (smallish) city. Everyone knows where to go. So illegalization doesn't meet its purpose (making drugs difficult to get) and yet it does have negative effects (the drugs sold have no quality control at all -which often causes deaths-, pay no taxes, are sold without any legal warranty, etc.) I'd rather they were sold in pharmacies, being dispensed together with reliable information (like tobacco), forbidden to minors (which could actually work reasonably well, because no one would go to the trouble of setting a black market exclusively to sell to minors) and paying taxes that could be used to fix the problems they cause. To me, this is enough grounds for legalization, regardless of the exact health effects of drugs.
- n0mad01 8y agoyou seem to be right, prohibition does not have the effect it was meant to have. but too many people have a job through this regulation as is (police can easily improve quotas, prosecutors/legal advice etc., in my country there are medical staff in state institutions doing nothing else but testing people if they used cannabis/again ...), so the resistance is great to change anything.
- yogthos 8y agoI'm pretty sure prohibition had the exact effect it was actually intended to have. There's a reason US prisons are a big business now and US has the highest incarceration rate in the world.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThis is not true. Most people do not know how to get hard drugs. If hard drugs were legal, they'd be in soda, candy, food, cigarettes - it would be sold literally on every street corner and grocery store. So the contrast between 'arms reach' and 'most people do not know how to get opium' is quite high. For weed, it's a different story, but for pretty much all other drugs, prohibition has a pretty dramatic effect on supply and demand.
- thatoneuser 8y agoI mean compare chronic use with any other common drug. Say ibuprofen. You're gonna have adverse affects in both groups. It would be retarded to say that because of this well make it illegal and take away the benefit of people.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rv-de 8y agoI'm also sceptical of the "cannabis is harmless" argument popular among advocates of legalization. no psychoactive substance is harmless or good for you generally speaking. having said that the most powerful organization in Germany fighting for legalization is the Hanfverband around Georg Wurth and they do avoid this simplistic stance. my position is that people should only be held accountable for harming others or risking doing so. for example by driving while intoxicated with whatever drug. but every adult should have the right to do with themselves whatever he or she pleases. from that perspective the question of whether weed is harmful becomes secondary and reduces to harm reduction and medical assistance.
- notacoward 8y ago> Western society has a serious issue with nuance Why present this as a "western" thing? Where exactly is there more nuance? More willingness to admit exceptions to a general rule, law, or social norm? It rather seems that people have a serious issue with nuance. A tendency to see (or portray) everything in terms of pure black or white is one of the most universal of human traits.