4 ms·
Former real estate agent, now software engineer. Doing a FSBO (for sale by owner) is as old as time. There's nothing wrong with this approach, but you are limit
by chrisco255 8y ago
Former real estate agent, now software engineer. Doing a FSBO (for sale by owner) is as old as time. There's nothing wrong with this approach, but you are limiting your market (and you might therefore be selling at a lower price anyways) and it's highly dependent on your: patience, financial situation, free time, marketing skills, general sales skills, local housing market, tricky property situations, ability to assist buyers with locating financing, handling any objections or mortgage exceptions that come up (including zoning and inspections requirements), etc.
Buyer's agents deserve their 3% perhaps even more than listing agents and it's unfortunate you screwed this agent out of that. It's sort of like stiffing a server on a tip. Buyers are fickle, time consuming, and sometimes demanding. It can take many showings and offers to find a good fit for someone. Sometimes I would work with a client for weeks or months. Many clients would fall through and you'd get $0 for those clients. So you have to average out your earnings with the successes.
There's other things you have to do, too sometimes. Like once I had an FHA financed client and there were certain restrictions about the distance a well could be from the septic tank at the Federal level but they didn't match the requirements at the county level (which were looser). So I had to coordinate with local zoning and the FHA to get an exception for this loan. That was a bigger ordeal than I can explain here.
These online MLS listing services have been around since 2004-2005. They're nothing new. Are there crappy agents? Yeah. Just like any profession. But the profession itself is not going anywhere.
- brightball 8y agoYea, I find the fees for buyers agents to be entirely worth it just based on the time investment in showings with no promise of sale. Listings themselves...not so much. But fee wise, those are always negotiable.
- jacquesm 8y ago> Buyer's agents deserve their 3% perhaps even more than listing agents and it's unfortunate you screwed this agent out of that. 3% of the value of a house is hardly 'a tip', a common fee in Europe for selling a house is around 1.5 to 2%, a typical buyer will not use a realtor at all. Oh, and it is illegal here for a realtor to charge both the buyer and the seller because there is a clear conflict of interest there, you can only work for one party. The real estate market in North America is ridiculous.
- mattmanser 8y agoIt's funny to watch American films and TV shows where everyone seems to be a realtor on the side, or getting a realtors licence.
- azhenley 8y agoIt isn't just on TV. A considerable portion of my friends on FB are or have been realtors.
- chrisco255 8y agoNot that hard to get. A lot harder to make a career out of it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ethbro 8y ago> Oh, and it is illegal here for a realtor to charge both the buyer and the seller because there is a clear conflict of interest there, you can only work for one party. Technically, in the US, the buyer's agent is only working for the buyer. They're just paid by the seller (traditionally and stupidly).
- speedplane 8y ago> in the US, the buyer's agent is only working for the buyer. They're just paid by the seller (traditionally and stupidly). I just went through this process. While the buyer's agent ostensibly works for the buyer, their main incentive is to get you to close. It doesn't matter if it's a good deal, a bad deal, or whatever. They take 3% so if you overpay or underpay by 10% of the appropriate value of the house that's only +/- 0.3% to them. They are much more interested in closing the deal quickly and moving on to the next than making sure you get what you want.
- makeset 8y agoNot to defend the system, the incentives are clearly not well-aligned, but I also just went through this process had an unexpectedly great experience with my buyer's agent, whom I found through a referral. He was professional, ethical, and actually took his fiduciary duty seriously. He didn't claim to find listings that I wouldn't have myself, but guided my search a bit based on my criteria, gave candid feedback on them and what to look for, and bargained on the price with the seller harder than I would have, saving me more than his commission. When I discovered a potential issue with the property and had second thoughts pre-close, he didn't try to discourage me one bit from letting a done deal fall through, and was ready to support my decision. And he set up the many appointments with the seller's agents, handled the literal ream of closing paperwork, dotted the i's and crossed the t's, and made this whole convoluted process go smoothly. From my end, he more than deserved his commission he got out of the deal, and he will certainly have my future business buying or selling.
- jseliger 8y agoBuyer's agents deserve their 3% perhaps even more than listing agents and it's unfortunate you screwed this agent out of that. It's sort of like stiffing a server on a tip A tip might be $20, not $10,000. The two are nothing alike.
- Youden 8y ago> and it's unfortunate you screwed this agent out of that. This makes absolutely no sense to me. Why on earth would I be obligated to pay the buyer's agent? What has the agent done for me? When did I establish a relationship with this person and agree to pay them anything? I would feel absolutely fine paying this person zero. If they want to get paid, they should take it up with the buyer because the buyer is the one who engaged their services. Note: I am not American.
- chrisco255 8y agoThey brought you a buyer. The buyer pays for everything in both cases. If you sell your house for $100K - 3% it's the same as selling your house FSBO for $97K.
- gibybo 8y agoHe sold his as FSBO. It's highly unlikely the real estate agent brought the buyer since they hate FSBOs. It's much more likely the buyer found the house himself/herself.
- Gibbon1 8y agoMy experience with a buyers agent was no offense but they were pretty much worthless when selecting which houses to make offers on. On the pro side the sellers agent was also worthless.