4 ms·
> a technical term making it illegal to share, possess or distribute. This crosses a line between discouraging horrific material being easily available by pres
by roenxi 8y ago
> a technical term making it illegal to share, possess or distribute.
This crosses a line between discouraging horrific material being easily available by pressuring Facebook, which practically speaking makes sense because people who wouldn't want to see it might see it, and a ban on facts. If they can ban this video, could they also ban videos of police or military abuses of power produced by a private citizen?
It isn't even an obviously good idea socially, that video (which I have not seen) is presumably one of the most pro-Muslim and pro-gun-control pieces of propaganda to be produced in the last 30 years. There is no pressure group that supports gunning down peaceful people at prayer time.
- erentz 8y ago> If they can ban this video, could they also ban videos of police or military abuses of power produced by a private citizen? In theory no. The censor operates independently under strict legislation and decisions can (I believe based on memory of previous instances) be challenged in court. So such an example as above wouldn't be censored because it wouldn't be injurious to the public good. Quite the opposite, such a video would be for the public good. Banning it would require some kind of authoritarian capture of both the censor's office and the the judicial system to enforce. Certainly if somehow NZ became an authoritarian state then the censor could be used to those ends, but by that point authoritarian states don't exactly care about law or process or political interference when it comes to censorship anyway.
- tathougies 8y ago> The censor operates independently under strict legislation and decisions can (I believe based on memory of previous instances) be challenged in court Meaningless political theater. This is like trying to divorce the king in a country with lese majeste. If you cannot know what's in the video, how could you possibly ask for it in court, without admitting that you illegally watched the video? The best word to describe New Zealand right now is Kafka-esque.
- erentz 8y ago> you illegally watched the video You're confusing having seen objectionable material with distributing that objectionable material. It's the distribution that is an offense.
- Taniwha 8y agowell did you make a copy of the film when you watched it? (remember the law includes having a copy of the film, not just distribution or publishing)
- tathougies 8y agoDistinction without a difference. Only a lawyer will stand a chance to argue in front of a court competently. Thus, they or their client or someone will have had to have distributed the video to them in order to successfully argue the case. Like I said, kafka-esque.
- frio 8y agoI think there's a real cultural clash between NZ and the US style of politics that is readily visible in this thread. Our censors have most visibly banned a few videogames in their time, but as an office, I think most kiwis accept the role they have in society and are happy for them to do their job. The political fearmongering about Government overreach that the US seems to have hasn't fully infected us yet; we still kinda like our Government and aren't particularly afraid of them. I hope that stays true, it seems like a happier and more relaxed way to live. That said, possession, distribution and (I believe!) consumption of objectionable material are all considered an offence. The cops and the courts exercise discretion here.
- tathougies 8y ago> The political fearmongering about Government overreach that the US seems to have hasn't fully infected us yet; we still kinda like our Government and aren't particularly afraid of them. I hope that stays true, it seems like a happier and more relaxed way to live. Nah. The most relaxed way to live is knowing your government won't arrest you because you watched a video before it was declared illegal.