3 ms·

It's less about them killing products and more about them following the same frustrating sequence of steps (for products that people actually liked): 1. Releas

It's less about them killing products and more about them following the same frustrating sequence of steps (for products that people actually liked): 1. Release a product, make it decently good. 2. Kill it in a few years after it has gotten widely adopted. 3. Release an alternative product that does the same thing, but, a lot of times, worse than the original and/or with missing functionality from the old one that people actually care about. 4. Bonus step: make it really confusing (looking at you, Hangouts => Allo/Duo). 5. Repeat the cycle. Notable examples of it that come to mind: * Messaging: GChat => Hangouts => Allo/Duo => I got tired of keeping up with that they are pushing now * Music streaming: Google Music => Google Play Music [just a rename, I think] => YouTube Remix => YouTube Music * First party Android experience: Google Play Edition => [I feel like I am missing something in-between here] => Android One + Android Go

pjmlp 8y ago
From developers point of view each Android release feels like a platform reboot.
scep12 8y ago
Agree messaging was bad, but music is still in progress so let's reserve judgement on whether or not that ends up being an OK transition or not. GPE -> Android Go does not fit the mold of the "cycle" you're talking about. Further, Android Go is substantially better than Android One. Do you have any other examples?
- filoleg 8y ago
  See, that's part of the problem. As an end-user, to me all those sound kinda samey and fill the same niche, but technically are different products. As for others, I personally stopped using non-essential google products (i.e., the ones I believe that Google is unlikely to screw up without completely destroying faith in the company, like GMail or Maps), so I can't come up with anything. If you are curious, you can check out https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/ and see if there is anything there that might fit the bill. Disclaimer: I have zero affiliation with that website. I found it by trying to look up a list of killed off Google products, hoping it would bring up some memories. Then I realized that there are way too many products on the list for me to parse through, and the website has a nice and clean UI/UX that I am not ashamed to share here.

pjmlp 8y ago

From developers point of view each Android release feels like a platform reboot.

scep12 8y ago

Agree messaging was bad, but music is still in progress so let's reserve judgement on whether or not that ends up being an OK transition or not. GPE -> Android Go does not fit the mold of the "cycle" you're talking about. Further, Android Go is substantially better than Android One. Do you have any other examples?

filoleg 8y ago
See, that's part of the problem. As an end-user, to me all those sound kinda samey and fill the same niche, but technically are different products. As for others, I personally stopped using non-essential google products (i.e., the ones I believe that Google is unlikely to screw up without completely destroying faith in the company, like GMail or Maps), so I can't come up with anything. If you are curious, you can check out https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/ and see if there is anything there that might fit the bill. Disclaimer: I have zero affiliation with that website. I found it by trying to look up a list of killed off Google products, hoping it would bring up some memories. Then I realized that there are way too many products on the list for me to parse through, and the website has a nice and clean UI/UX that I am not ashamed to share here.