8 ms·
Danish researchers finally solve the obesity riddle
- usinglogin 16y agoThat is great for people with highly controllable dietary options (which is nobody). But, for the rest of us: Eat 1500-2000 calories a day, doesn't matter from what. I lost -32lbs in 3 months.
- hellrich 16y ago"randomly assigned to one of five different low-fat diet types" - so most combinations weren't tested at all?
- chairface 16y agoThey types of diets are specified in the article.
- Vivtek 16y agoWhy in the world is this being downvoted? All of the five combinations they tested were low-fat. This is actually the point I wanted to make, too.
- rubashov 16y agoYes, the absence of a high saturated fat diet leapt out right away. That's what wins the clinical trial equivalents of this.
- Evgeny 16y agoVery true, the fist thing I wanted to look for - "how did my favourite high-fat, low-carb diet rate in this study? Oops, how are the results of any use then ..."
- SirWart 16y agoMaybe it's just overzealous copywriting, but it seems like all they figured out is that a low GI, high protein diet is better than the other combinations they tested, and are far from solving anything rigorously.
- niels_olson 16y agoOverzealous copywriting?! By a "science" journalist?! NO!!!! Here's the original article. I wrote a partial defense in another comment. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1007137 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1007137
- chesser 16y agoThese studies are nutty. You can't separate diet from activity; you can't treat wide categories of food so indiscriminately; you can't use BMI or weight instead of body composition, and get definitive results. Just for example, raw foodists tend to have low-protein diets that may be low OR high-glycemic index, and tend to be very thin. Without a comprehensive listing of specific meals, I would guess that people in certain groups in this study would be much more likely to cheat on their diets. The selection of low-protein, low-GI foods for most people used to typical Western diets would lead to very disappointing meals and thus more cheating over a 6-month period. Further, gaining a pound of fat over a period of 6 months works out to less than 20 extra calories per day. This is essentially noise. Cheating with 150 extra calories once per week (e.g. a single sugary treat) could account for this. Keeping your blood sugar in check is a major factor in preventing binge eating and fat storage. There are various ways to do this, including low-GI foods, exercise, and eating small meals frequently. The recent standard for Hollywood stars and starlets is working with a personal trainer and eating every 2 hours. This helps keep blood sugar steady. On the flip side, people engaged in sustained cardiovascular exercise must eat high-GI foods or their performance drops. Riders in the Tour de France chow down on every sugary snack and drink known to man (not just "performance formulas" of energy bars and drinks), and Michael Phelps eats 12,000 calories a day while training. You don't need that level of Herculean effort before this becomes important. Even if you are completely sedentary, if you are engaged in a mentally taxing task, your brain is burning through a lot of glucose. Eating sucrose means half glucose and half fructose, and only the glucose can be metabolized immediately. Fructose can be stored by the liver and converted, but if the liver reserves are full (e.g. late in the day, as opposed to waking up from fasting during sleep), fructose will end up as fat. Fructose has a low glycemic index, so guess which sugar is more likely to be included in a low-GI diet. (Glucose is of course used by diabetics in order to raise their blood sugar quickly. It is also called Dextrose.) Finally, without body composition analysis, they haven't shown anything about fat loss. High protein diets require more water to process, and a difference of a pound or two on a human body can easily be down to differences in fluid retention. High protein diets can lead to slightly more dehydration.
- niels_olson 16y agoHere's the original article. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1007137 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1007137. The study is impressively well done, as are most articles in the New England Journal. Other researchers will be studying their methods as much as their results. > Without a comprehensive listing of specific meals Actually, they did better and developed local indexes for all foods for each center and had the patients keep food diaries. > Further, gaining a pound of fat over a period of 6 months works out to less than 20 extra calories per day. This is essentially noise. First, this is why we enroll more than one patient. The noise averages out. Two: the unit of measure was kilograms, the average arm gained more than 1 kg. Three, see figure 2B in the article: they quite nicely demonstrate sufficient granularity to appreciate signal. > Keeping your blood sugar in check is a major factor in preventing binge eating and fat storage > people engaged in sustained cardiovascular exercise must eat high-GI foods or their performance drops Your liver has glycogen stores on board that will keep your blood sugar rock steady for the first 20 miles of a marathon. Unless you are exercising at a heart rate of 160-180 for 2.5 or more hours, this is useless trivia. > Riders in the Tour de France chow down on every sugary snack and drink known > Michael Phelps eats 12,000 calories a day while training. Some of the most over-cited factoids on the Internet. I swam competitively for 7 years and raced bikes competitively for four, and still ride. I'm also a doctor who spent a fair amount of a surgical internship with the bariatrics unit. These facts about elite athletes do not bear on anyone who has a BMI of 34 (Patients are generally ineligible for bariatric surgery below a BMI of 35)), the average human, or, almost certainly, you. A far more useful factoid is that your glycogen stores are depleted overnight, so a 2-3 hour cardio session in the morning will force you to burn fat. The body has no other choice. (No, it won't burn muscle). > if you are completely sedentary, if you are engaged in a mentally taxing task, your brain is burning through a lot of glucose Normal adult human brain uses, 120 g to, maybe, 220 g of glucose per day. At the outside, that's 750 Calories. > sucrose means half glucose and half fructose, and only the glucose can be metabolized immediately. Fructose can be stored by the liver and converted, but if the liver reserves are full (e.g. late in the day, as opposed to waking up from fasting during sleep), fructose will end up as fat. Fructose has a low glycemic index, True. Unfortunately, your implicit conclusion . . . > guess which sugar is more likely to be included in a low-GI diet Is what? Are you saying they loaded these cats with fructose? If they did, then these results are even more impressive, because we would expect a high fructose diet to promote fat gain. Are you saying they loaded them with glucose? That would make no sense, because glycemic index measures "blood glucose". > Finally, without body composition analysis, they haven't shown anything about fat loss. See Table 2 of the study.
- rubashov 16y agoIs this site full of fatties? Why does every diet article shoot to the top? Gotta be careful if that's the case. Wouldn't want to catch the fat virus here or anything.
- sown 16y agoBodybuilders have been saying this for a while. There are always arguments about thermodynamics and what not, and there is good reason behind those, but everyone in a gym who builds up a lean body (sans steroids or not) follow a similar dietary pattern: lean meats, veggies, no flour/sugar/starchy veggies, etc for cutting and then eating more protein and some complex carbs (like from potatoes) to build lean mass.
- cmer 16y agoHoly cow. It's a small world! One of the main guys behind this is actually a great friend of mine. I've known him since kindergarten and he's now amongst the top researchers in the world. I wish I had something to do with it! He recently moved back to Canada from Copenhagen. He has no clue what Hacker News is, but I'll email him this thread, perhaps he'll chime in if any of you have questions.
- niels_olson 16y agoPlease ask him to do a IamA-AMAA
- drdo 16y agoCongratulations to these guys for finding out something people have known for decades.
- nowarninglabel 16y agoCalories in - Calories out = calories remaining How is that a riddle?
- fhars 16y agoIt is also completely irrelevant to the study at hand, as one of the conclusoins was that the right diet helps without counting calories.
- AndrewDucker 16y agoBecause your body is not a bunsen burner - it burns different kinds of foods differently.
- moo 16y agoI've thought the argument in "Sugar: The Bitter Truth" is very insightful. Viewable at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM. Pointing out that the Atkins diet (no carbs, fat okay) and the Japanese diet (mostly carbs, low fat intake) have in common that they eliminate sugar, the major cause of obesity.
- Mz 16y agoI have trouble taking such studies seriously. I have a life-threatening medical condition which typically causes people to be underweight and I was quite thin as a child but put on a lot of weight as an adult (probably in part due to being prescribed steroids for my health issues). After finally getting an appropriate diagnosis late in life, I did some research and changed my diet to address my health issues. I have lost several dress sizes, even though that was not my goal. I was getting plenty of positive male attention when I was a size 24-26 and my doctor was telling me to work on my health issues and not worry about my weight (because people like me are typically underweight, which is more immediately life-threatening than being overweight), so I had no goal of losing weight. I was just trying to get healthier because I was so sick, on a lot of medication and miserable. My experience tends to fly in the face of the pronouncements such studies make, so I just have a really hard time taking it seriously that you can come up with a generic suggestion for diet that will work equally well for 6 billion people.
- niels_olson 16y agoI applaud you for staying strong throughout your struggle. However, your exception proves the rule: people who don't have a reason shouldn't be overweight. Or underweight. Fight the good fight.
- Mz 16y agoI don't see how it proves that at all. Presumably everyone who is overweight (or underweight) is so for a reason. Given how many people wish they weighed less and can't seem to make it happen, often in spite of dieting, exercising, etc, I think something more complicated is going on than these studies assume.
- jpcha57 16y agoProf. Arne Astrup, a colleague of mine, was the principal investigator of this study when I was in Denmark. Interestingly, I will see him this weekend in Quebec City for the PhD defense of my wife. I agree with you guys that the title is too strong and we have to be careful when interpreting studies. Only few people fully realize that the obesity problem is complex and multifaceted. Nobody is immune. The causes and paths to weight gain are manifold and a narrow focus on the Big Two factors (unhealthy diet and physical inactivity) is not enough. For some people, factors such as short sleep duration, mental stress, socioeconomic status, drugs, etc. can cause weight gain and thereby should be included in the big picture. The main problem lies in the current 'obesogenic' environment that encourages overeating and sedentariness, and people are not able to swim upstream against those strong pressures. A change in the environment is more than needed at this point, because telling people to eat less and exercise more does not really work.