8 ms·
California also has fixed borders. And limited resources like water and crumbling infrastructure. Failing public education. 40 million people. How many more hom
by jelliclesfarm 8y ago
California also has fixed borders. And limited resources like water and crumbling infrastructure. Failing public education. 40 million people. How many more homes can we build? More homes = more infrastructure, shrinking land, loss of habitat and nature, strained water, over crowding, more schools, more support jobs(low pay), more cars on the same roads, more consumption, more pollution. 45 percent of the state budget goes to public education and it is one of the highest tax collecting states. If we don’t think of a way to hack this situation, California will become a failed state and bankrupt. Sooner than most of us fear.
- cheath 8y agoSF has a population density of 18,679 per square mile. NYC has 27,000. There is plenty of room, you'd just have to scale everything along with it. Also, for what it's worth, > population density = < net pollution. mass transit etc. are great optimizations of resources. these humans already exist - it's just a matter of where they exist.
- fuckyah 8y agoThe problem in SF is that nobody wants to live in the fog. I wonder what’s the density east of divisadero!?
- stcredzero 8y agoSF has a population density of 18,679 per square mile. NYC has 27,000. There is plenty of room, you'd just have to scale everything along with it. The problem isn't space. It's NIMBY. It's groupthink disconnected from reality.
- cheath 8y agowell, that I completely agree with. :)
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoReality is self interest.
- stcredzero 8y agoReality is self interest. When self interest cuts the next generation off at the knees, it's no longer so well connected to reality.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoHow does it cut the next generation off at the knees? You are asking those who work hard to avail a certain standard of life to be altruistic? How is this logical? Why do you think someone would work 10-12-14 hours a day? Spend 2 hours commuting..take no vacations..take enormous risks with low pay for a start up to maybe hit the big leagues? They are risk takers. Risk takers and A types are not altruistic. And yet..these are the people who made Bay Area desirable. And immigrants. These are people who were so unhappy with their native countries(not coincidentally, in the Bay Area..this is majority from high population countries) that they were willing to double down and work hard and deal with immigration and leave family, language and culture behind to start a new life in a strange country. You are asking these immigrants to say YES IN MY BACKYARD? Do you see the irony and/or the humour in that expectation? If one wants someone to unclench their fists and give up something, then there has to be an incentive for them to do it. You are looking for altruism amongst the crushed middle class. What do they get back in return? Convert NIMBYs with community benefits or better roads or recreational spots in the city or better schools or just about anything that would make their quality of life better. What kind of negotiation is it to ask someone to sacrifice their deeply held beliefs and fond desires for the promise of WORSENING quality of life? How will this tactic even work?
- stcredzero 8y agoHow does it cut the next generation off at the knees? Building new housing and modifying existing housing costs several orders of magnitude more than it did a half century ago. Why do you think someone would work 10-12-14 hours a day? My wife works like that. She's definitely a type A. She's also an immigrant. They are risk takers. Risk takers and A types are not altruistic. Calling leaving room for young people to make their way, "altruism?" Arranging society to allow for the next generation is "Altruism!?" Sorry, but that's just good governance. When a society transforms, such that about the only people who can gracefully afford being 20-something newlyweds are 40-something professionals, that society has become truly ossified. In most times and places throughout history, there are places where young lower and working class people can be thrifty and make their way. It's disappearing from a lot of California. You are asking these immigrants to say YES IN MY BACKYARD? Do you see the irony and/or the humour in that expectation? My parents are immigrants and my wife is an immigrant. If one cares about the next generation, if one cares about upward social mobility, then "yes in my backyard" is the answer. We went to a real estate meetup of my wife's alma mater. There was a young man who was with a project building shipping container mother-in-law units, with the goal of increasing density and reducing the cost of housing. Literally, "yes in my backyard" manifested in actual hardware.
- throwawaysea 8y agoNIMBY is a pejorative, and I think this sort of labeling is not conducive to honest conversation. The truth is that people have different wants/needs. Not everyone wants to live in a high-density megalopolis. Many want a smaller, slower-paced life, with more breathing room. And those who have that and prefer it, don't want to lose it in favor of accommodating others - which is a very rational viewpoint. As such I don't think it is fair to paint it as 'disconnected from reality'.
- stcredzero 8y agodon't want to lose it in favor of accommodating others - which is a very rational viewpoint. As such I don't think it is fair to paint it as 'disconnected from reality'. When one's "wanting things to be chill" is interfering with society's transferring the reins to the next generation, it is 'disconnected from reality'.
- throwawaysea 8y agoBut it's not interfering with a "transfer of the reins". The "next generation" that you're referring to has options - they can certainly make a life in numerous other locations. Instead they are coveting one of the most desirable places in the world, and want that location and its people to change in significant ways to accommodate them. I don't think that's the prior generation interfering as much as the next generation exhibiting entitlement - the entitlement of wanting scarce, highly-valued things, without creating the necessary value to earn it (that is, possessing the necessary wealth). Moreover, I don't know that your perspective is uniform across any generation.
- stcredzero 8y agoThe "next generation" that you're referring to has options - they can certainly make a life in numerous other locations. Hey that's just too bad you've been priced out of the place you grew up. That's just the market. That's the breaks. Hey, you have options in other places. Quit being entitled! Instead they are coveting one of the most desirable places in the world, and want that location and its people to change in significant ways to accommodate them. Instead techies moving there for the sweet, sweet high paying jobs are coveting the most desirable places in the world, and want that location and its people to change in significant ways to accommodate them. The big difference is that they have the money, so they're the ones that get their way. The golden rule: he who has the gold, writes the rules. Again, it's all well and good. It's all legal and within the letter of the law. In an overall view, is such an approach really that smart and benevolent? If you look at it a certain way, no, I don't think that's benevolent and wise. I don't think that's the prior generation interfering as much as the next generation exhibiting entitlement - the entitlement of wanting scarce, highly-valued things, without creating the necessary value to earn it Living where you grew up is now entitlement. If you want to live where you grew up, you're going to have to create the necessary value. What, are you entitled!? Again, that's the market reality. That's all technically legal, technically correct. It's still kinda crappy if you look at it from a different point of view. If it weren't for a certain California law, nearly all of the easily accessible beaches would be owned or indirectly access-controlled by rich people. If it weren't for a certain California law, that condition would be simply market reality. It would be technically legal. It would be technically correct. It would definitely be kinda crappy, though. It's in the long term interest of us techies to act in ways that are good and benevolent, and show some forbearance in certain matters, even though our market power and money allow us to do it anyways. Social unrest is caused by perceived relative inequality. Wouldn't being forced out of your childhood home by richer people feel quite "unequal?" That said, the answer isn't to try and legislate equality, as that is shown to have the opposite effect. The answer is a market which creates enough housing for all segments of society to live in the "desirable places in the world." That's how they become and stay the "desirable places in the world." Moreover, I don't know that your perspective is uniform across any generation. Fair enough.
- tathougies 8y agoWhat bubble are you living in to think California has no space. If there's one thing California has more than enough of, it's open space. I suggest driving on one of the myriad freeways for a few hundred miles and then tell me there's no open space. It's actually space that is the problem, because everyone wants the low-density SFH that the space affords. No one wants to invest in higher density housing.
- stcredzero 8y agoHe is right about the alarming ratio of public school funding to public school failure. California's problem isn't space. It's NIMBY. CA's gone so NIMBY that regulations stifle the younger generation's ability to build and buy their homes. My wife and I went to open houses this weekend. Young Berkeley professors can't afford to live where they work. Young teachers can't afford to live where they work. This sort of thing is a societal recipe for disaster. (Long, but consider this a documentary on how NIMBY has affected housing in California, from the POV of a cool landlord. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8x4CWBMsPg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8x4CWBMsPg )
- tathougies 8y agoI agree with him on the schooling. Notice my comment was solely about space, not school.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoDon’t you think it’s connected? Or are you suggesting that people build homes and don’t send their kids to school? I am ready for the assault of downvotes if it means the right questions are asked. One average home is 4 people. 2 cars. 2 kids. 2 incomes. 40% of it goes to various taxes. Dense over crowded cities. Overcrowded schools. Kids need tutoring because everyone wants their kids to succeed. 2 hour commutes. Baby sitting and child care. More water. More gas. More pollution. More public services. Same or smaller roads as bicycles and walkable roads become important. Less shopping as space is used for homes and people travel outside more and shopping dollars go out of the city. Less open spaces and nature. People start traveling for vacations and relaxation. More outflow without a balanced local economy. More service people needed for the high tech income earning population. But unaffordable for lower tiers for income. Break this down for me. How is high density sustainable? Seriously ..how? Having a house isn’t everything. Living involves many other things.
- timerol 8y agoCalifornia could build more homes in a way that generates more tax revenue than it costs. In most places, the best way to do this is to gradually increase density, which increases the tax base. SF could have significantly more tax revenue if 8 story residential buildings were allowed to be built. (https://reason.com/reasontv/2018/12/27/san-francisco-mission-housing-crisis https://reason.com/reasontv/2018/12/27/san-francisco-mission...) Similarly, many of the other neighborhoods in CA would only need to legalize duplexes and/or triplexes in order to have the gentle density increases necessary. Also, more homes != more cars and more driving. Seattle and Minneapolis have both added more residents and decreased vehicle miles traveled (VMT) by allowing infill development and increasing transit coverage. (https://usa.streetsblog.org/2019/02/08/minneapolis-and-seattle-have-achieved-the-holy-grail-for-sustainable-transportation/ https://usa.streetsblog.org/2019/02/08/minneapolis-and-seatt...)
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoWell. Then let’s see the public transport being built first.
- eloisant 8y agoIt's also bigger than Japan that has 130 million people. There is plenty of space in California, but people just cluster in the Bay Area and LA area.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoCalifornia has a very significant Ag economy. We have an income receipt of 45 billion per annum. We have pockets of density because most rural areas can be considered ‘open air factories’ that bring in a lot of money to the state. Japan on the other hand is smaller and has lesser immigrants, most ageing population. Also..New Zealand has 5 million people and it’s a country. Canada is 22 million people and it’s bigger than Japan. India is 1.3 billion people. What’s the point of comparisons? It’s not a race to be the most dense state. There is no prize at the end of the race.