3 ms·
I guess they trusted Boeing. After all they also don't want their planes to crash and have a long record of being reasonably responsible.
by tim333 8y ago
I guess they trusted Boeing. After all they also don't want their planes to crash and have a long record of being reasonably responsible.
- pintxo 8y agoThey also want to make a profit and therefore might make compromises in security. There is a reason we have independent inspections like everywhere we deem sensible enough to pay for it as a society.
- tim333 8y agoIt's tricky when it comes to software systems though. Imagine you had to inspect a new Boeing. It would be ok to look at the construction and see it was stuck together ok but hard to understand all the software systems unless you'd helped write them. Normally with software written by others you find the problems by using it and seeing it have bugs or crash, not by inspecting the code. In this case I imagine someone at Boeing knew moving the elevator jack 2.5 degrees based on one sensor was unsafe hence them selling an optional upgrade that made the system safe. That seems kind of criminal.
- pintxo 8y agoI'd agree if the problems is within the software "black box" (the software term, not the aircraft thingy). But to me it currently looks like it's largely a problem of how the different systems interact and how it's communicated to the users aka pilots. That's something one should be able to spot from the flowcharts/blueprints or whatever they have to document system integration.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoExcept for the fact that they really like to throw their customers and pilots under a bus if it's convenient to them. This was, in my opinion, one of the most disgusting aspects of this whole sordid story. They had to cut back after the Ethiopian crash, but blaming everybody else seems a big part of their DNA.
- huffmsa 8y agoAfter the Lion Air crash it wouldn't have been unreasonable to assume pilot error. Almost all recent accidents have been pilot error. I read somewhere that the sensor was misreading by 20° and Lion should have noticed. Should Boeing have shipped the system with a single point of failure by default? Probably not. Should the FAA have raised questions about that? Probably. Should Boeing have considered a test case where a pilot didn't know about MCAS? Probably. But we don't know that they didn't. Perhaps they did and their test pilots recovered the plane in time. That would make it a Lion Air training failure. There's no single point of blame here, but thankfully the airline industry reacts as a whole to incidents like this and takes as many steps as possible to make sure it doesn't happen any more.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoThat would make it a Lion Air training failure. Well, how could they train for it, when Boieing conveniently hushed over such a significant change, because it was commercially expedient? Until the Lion Air crash the airlines and their pilots didn't even know that such a system is in place. According to an AA pilot the entire training consisted of less than an hour presentation on an iPad, in which the new behavior wasn't mentioned at all. Add to that that Boeing offered a paid upgrade which at least would make pilots aware that the system malfunctions. This paid upgrade sounds a bit like "Nice plane you have here, would be a shame if it crashes" No matter how you look at it: Boeing displayed despicable behavior in this whole sorry mess. Behavior which comes back now to bite them badly. I don't disagree with your reasoning, for what it's worth. I just think there really should be a special place in hell for the Boeing executives who allowed this to happen. Especially after the first crash.
- huffmsa 8y agoAgain, unless I've missed a statement, we don't know if Boeing has tested for this case internally. This case being "pilots untrained and unfamiliar with the MCAS system recovering from a catastrophic systems failure / error". They are at fault no matter what though from straying from their long held principle that the pilot has the final say on control of the aircraft. Inputs from the yoke and throttle levers should always supercede the computer.