3 ms·
Sorry to differ, I think this is twisted by an era where liberal market was held as god like status. Take the rubber and metal out because for now. To draw a d
by agumonkey 8y ago
Sorry to differ, I think this is twisted by an era where liberal market was held as god like status.
Take the rubber and metal out because for now. To draw a dark line on a surface, you take the first bit of wood you find, grind it into a point and burn it. You have a pencil.
I really believe that the free market centuries made people believe it was the only or most efficient way to get an object done, just like people thought java ee was the only way to make a web application in early 2000s.
- todd8 8y agoYou’ve moved the goal posts. It’s not that the construction of some thing, anything, that can be used to write with is difficult. As you point out a piece of charcoal isn’t hard to make. Milton Friedman’s point is that even something as simple and inexpensive as a pencil involves people all over the world working together to create it. Some mine graphite, some run ships to move the graphite, some manufacture paint, some grow rubber trees, etc. All of this activity, coordinated and made efficient by the market is behind even a simple thing like a pencil.
- agumonkey 8y agoI agree on goalpost but still differ on Friedman's point. Culture shifts into thinking you need objects to the point of making you forget what you wanted in the first place. Friedman wants to marvel at the thought of his beloved market.
- EForEndeavour 8y agoFriedman does wax lyrical about his beloved market toward the end of that video, but the main point I drew from his quote about the pencil is that it's absolutely mind-blowing to stop and contemplate the incredible cooperation and pre-existing systems required to construct so many of the mundane, dirt-cheap objects of the modern world. The fact that someone could eschew mass-produced lead pencils in favour of a self-made writing implement doesn't diminish the fact that it's practically impossible for any one individual on the planet to ever actually build a pencil you can buy for the equivalent of a few seconds to minutes of labour. That pencil, and so many other mundane items like it, are artifacts beyond the crafting capabilities of any one human.
- agumonkey 8y agoAfter viewing primitive technology and crafting videos I'm convinced of the opposite. Culture makes you think that only mass market can do that.
- EForEndeavour 8y agoI feel that again misses the point. Sure, it's perfectly possible for a resourceful and knowledgable human to hand-engineer various tools from the environment. But to make something very much like an ordinary pencil made of wood, graphite, rubber, metal, and paint would be a monumental task, far beyond the cost of a pencil in our established society. The fact is that globalization and industrialization has democratized the construction of literal artifacts. Consider the single-use plastic bottle, with a precisely machined screw neck and matching lid. It's lightweight, transparent, and will last for years. It would be exceedingly difficult to find and process the raw material to craft such an artifact from scratch, yet millions of them per day are used once and discarded. Same goes for most office supplies, now that I think of it. And we haven't even touched integrated circuits yet.
- agumonkey 8y agoI kinda see, the value is in efficiency of delegation but IMO there are drawbacks that this 'efficient' perspective hides, namely people believe you can't do anything without the market.
- WanderPanda 8y agoYep because history has proven that believe to be correct.
- Retric 8y agoThe complexity of a modern economy is more about efficiency than anything else. If you want a pencil that uses graphite and an eraser, that’s actually fairly easy to construct with the correct raw materials. A single person in the right location and with the right knowledge could have made a single pencil 1,000 years ago, though the pencil would not have been worth the effort. Further, they could not have made 100,000 of them where I could actually buy 100,000 pencils by being part of the modern economy.
- syshum 8y agoThe thought experiment was not "how can I draw a dark line on a surface from scratch" but Making a Modern #2 pencil and no one ever thought java ee was the only way to make a web application, not even in the early 2000's
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I think this is twisted by an era where liberal market was held as god like status. The author more than the era, but sure. (To the extent it's also true of the era, the author was more of a cause than an effect, being one of the leading evangelists of the market of his generation.)
- kbutler 8y agoFriedman's example is more an illustration that when we want to design a replacement for a working system, there is often a lot more complexity than expected - reinvented wheels are often square. Your example ends up with a piece of charcoal that doesn't have an eraser, gives you slivers, gets charcoal all over, has to be burnt every time you need to sharpen it (with a market-produced lighter or matches), doesn't work with pencil sharpeners, and smells like smoke instead of that "freshly sharpened pencil" smell (yeah, that's a thing). Your re-invented wheel is square. Yes, Friedman wants us to examine how the market works - because it works better for these complex coordinations than any other system we've devised. The market has facilitated the discovery and communication of the user requirements, and the price mechanism has coordinated the work of all the producers/transporters/exchangers of all the raw ingredients and intermediate products as well as the final product, and has enabled an ecosystem that produces compatible pencil sharpeners, grips, etc. And did anyone ever think Java EE was the only way? That was much more an example of a designed system to replace the messy evolved world of CGI/Perl/PHP.
- agumonkey 8y agoyou don't need a lighter to make fire, and you don't need to sharpen, you regrind. j2ee is an example of mass mistook for an example of good. It was taught as the ultimate goal to marvel at the complexity of the remote objects.
- agumonkey 8y agoyou don't need a lighter to make fire, and you don't need to sharpen, you regrind. j2ee is an example of mass mistook for an example of good. It was taught as the ultimate goal to marvel at the complexity of the remote objects. ps: if I had to glorify something it's globalization incentives to improve metrology. Precision is what gives you modern things.