4 ms·
In this conversation, it seems like people ignore the fact that there's a societal benefit to leaving buildings empty, at least in economic theory. Which is th
by crazygringo 8y ago
In this conversation, it seems like people ignore the fact that there's a societal benefit to leaving buildings empty, at least in economic theory.
Which is that it's keeping the space open for more productive use in the long term.
Suppose you own a storefront or apartment that could fetch $5K/month right now, but you think it will fetch $10K/month in 3 years, and that leases are 10 years long.
Well, the people/businesses who can afford $10K/month are by definition more economically productive: the people must have higher-paying jobs, and the businesses must be more productive economically.
If economic trends are such that you expect them to show up in 3 years ago but not right now, it's overall more productive for society to keep the properties empty for 3 years, and then get 7 years of the doubled rent.
Otherwise, if you were forced into 10-year leases now, then in 3 years' time, all those people and businesses won't have locations they can move into. Because of supply and demand, the small remaining inventory will be pushed up to, say, $20K/month, which will be unaffordable, and the city will be left with less economically productive people/business locked in, and economic growth will happen in other locations instead.
Now, certain laws/zoning/factors can distort this in possibly undesirable ways, and if you don't like gentrification then you won't like that either. And all this depends on where the market thinks the economy is going -- landlords are taking a bet, and there's no guarantee they'll be right, but that's the case with any investment.
But as a general rule, landlords letting properties sit vacant are actually providing an economic service, by ensuring future availability when it's even more valuable. Yet articles about vacant properties rarely seem to mention this. I'm not sure why.
- kabacha 8y agoYour anecdote covers business leasing when the article discusses housing. Surely having a flat sit empty for years while people don't have any place to live in is a problem, right? Obviously there's an economic incentive here (why else would anyone leave the apartments empty?) but it just doesn't mean it's not a problem for the cities and their citizens.
- okr 8y agoI like the future availability argument. It's a good function. But i also can see, why citizens (if we talk about housing) might object, if there is no affordable housing right now, if everyone were betting. But then again, if i look at prizing over the last 100 years, and if citizens back then would have to look at prizes today, they would be outraged or at least be worried about their offspring. While, when one is working today and does not have to live in popular areas, in my anecdotal experience, many do pretty ok.
- crazygringo 8y ago> Surely having a flat sit empty for years while people don't have any place to live in is a problem, right? If there were literally more people in Spain than there were housing units to hold them, then yes of course that would be a problem. But it certainly doesn't appear to be the case here. This is mainly about small price differences -- forcing a small increase of short-term availability that will have the cumulative effect over lowering prices in one segment of the market slightly in the present. It's not about finding physical space to house the homeless, for example, in a city bursting at its limits. That would be a legitimate moral problem, of course.
- AbrahamParangi 8y agoHmm. Maybe I'm missing something. I don't understand how more efficient rent-collection (and literal rent-collection at that) is productive. I mean, isn't it definitionally not "productive"? I mean you can make the argument that by being more efficient at rent collection over some time horizon you funnel more money to yourself and other local industries but isn't this basically just a cost to everyone else at every other scale of time and space?
- noobermin 8y agoWhenever this argument is made, there seems to be this conflation of "economically good" and "x made me money." Just because you make money (or make more money) doing something doesn't mean it's a net good for society.
- crazygringo 8y agoOf course, but that's a much deeper issue. Today, we generally accept that in a free market without externalities, private profit = public good. If you disagree, you can take that up with Adam Smith and the invisible hand. ;)
- kgwgk 8y ago“the people/businesses who can afford $10K/month are by definition more economically productive” The idea is that letting the space empty now makes it available for “more productive” activities later.
- noobermin 8y ago>Well, the people/businesses who can afford $10K/month are by definition more economically productive: the people must have higher-paying jobs, and the businesses must be more productive economically. This is one hell of an assumption. Wealthy people hold onto wealth, that's why they're wealthy. That isn't a societal benefit to anyone.
- barry-cotter 8y agoMoney that is not being spent is almost always being invested. If cash is literally being hoarded under a mattress it’s neither being spend nor invested but that means that the value of everyone else’s money goes up by some infinitesimal amount. If Bill Gates turned his entire fortune into cash and then set it on fire the assets that that cash used to represent would not disappear. Bill Gates would just have made all other holders of dollars a bit richer.
- conanbatt 8y agoThis is a bonkers line of argumentation. Speculation is not a productive activity. It is also potentially very destructive. A different argument would be to say that the seller of the property is putting the money to better use, but nevertheless speculation of land, particularly in big cities, is purely a legal issue and regulatory capture. Change taxes to LVT and watch them dissapear.
- okr 8y agoI am surprised to read on YC news, that speculation is not a productive activity. Is not the whole venturing idea an organized risk minimizing speculation adventure? I do not think anyone willingly spends part of their wealth into something, that they don't think, it's worth investing in. And i also think it is worth noting, that if there was then a future gain, that it had produced something, that others were willing to spend money on. So it must have been useful?
- conanbatt 8y agoInvestment is not speculation. Its of course a game of definitions, but generally speaking both economists and financial literature separate them on their usefulness and advice. > And i also think it is worth noting, that if there was then a future gain, that it had produced something, that others were willing to spend money on. So it must have been useful? Starting by the conclusion here. People also willingly spend money on the lottery, or betting, and although it has some entertaining value, it would be to the detriment of society as a whole if investment were diverted into the speculation of games of chance.
- ende 8y agoThis line of reasoning is right up there with the devestation of war creating economic activity.
- robocat 8y agoNo one is forcing the landlord to have a 10 year lease. They can lower the lease and have a short notice period. Now they get 3 years of some rent followed by 7 years of double rent.
- crazygringo 8y agoGenerally, no. Most businesses won't sign a lease unless it's for much longer than 3 years -- they need to lock in a known rate long-term to plan a business around. And with apartments, there are often rent regulations that prevent rent going up by more than x% per year, and you can be sure that if annual increases are 5% but the market doubles, those tenants are going to stay for as many decades as they possibly can. If landlords could get a profitable tenant for 3 years and then be guaranteed they'd leave, then there wouldn't be the "problem" of vacant properties in the first place. In fact, that's one of the motivations behind the "pop-up stores" that have recently become a thing in places like NYC -- a business takes over an empty storefront for just a summer or something like that, so the landlord makes a little $, but the tenant is guaranteed to leave. The problem is, there just aren't that many viable pop-up store businesses.
- collyw 8y ago"the people/businesses who can afford $10K/month are by definition more economically productive" They are richer, not necessarily more economically productive. Making money by hoarding assets isn't my definition of economically productive.