3 ms·
Vilifying "big" whatever is an addictive activity by itself. Humans are predisposed to believing in and fighting against a conspiring enemy in the same was a c
by colechristensen 8y ago
Vilifying "big" whatever is an addictive activity by itself. Humans are predisposed to believing in and fighting against a conspiring enemy in the same was a children are predisposed to want sugar and to find cartoon characters selling things appealing.
People have weaknesses and people try to exploit weaknesses. Philosophically you have to decide how your society manages these two things pitting personal responsibility against business regulation. Pieces like this do not do enough to keep that balance, instead blaming problems on big bad X.
- deogeo 8y ago> Humans are predisposed to believing in and fighting against a conspiring enemy And in the case of tobacco, sugary drinks, and many other products and shady business practices, that belief is absolutely correct.
- gowld 8y agoIt's not "Big", though. "Big" just means that the "Small" was successful. If you just swipe at the current big, a new big will grow to replace it.
- intopieces 8y agoExploiting people’s well know psychological weaknesses and then calling it a failure of personal responsibility is exactly how ad execs managed to sleep at night after getting kids hooked on a substance that shattered millions of lives and cost the US alone hundreds of billions of dollars in healthcare costs and lost productivity.
- colechristensen 8y agoThis is why I was talking about it being a balance. How do you pick that balance? When do you say something is exploitation and when do you say something is personal responsibility or choice? One logical extreme is only being able to eat government approved meals. Obviously that is ridiculous but you have to know the extremes to pick a reasonable moderate choice. My position involves maximizing personal choice as long as the truth is accurately represented.
- deogeo 8y agoThings can be called out as exploitation without being made illegal.
- intopieces 8y ago> When do you say something is exploitation and when do you say something is personal responsibility or choice? This is not difficult. When one group is disproportionately impacted by a net-negative outcome due to a product’s overuse, it’s obvious there is exploitation. We can measure health outcomes. We can model when children’s brains have developed sufficiently to make choices. We can look at the documents the companies themselves drew up and understand very clearly their intentions to exploit people and leave them to die. Accurately representing the truth is not enough. Humans are a mess of impulses and biases, not logical thinkers who act out of reason at every step.
- colechristensen 8y agoAt what proportion is an impact "disproportionate"?
- whatshisface 8y agoYou don't have to tease out the exact line that separates self-defense from murder to call Hannibal Lecter a murderer.
- colechristensen 8y agoIf it is obvious it does not need discussion, what about where it isn't obvious? You can't legislate what's obvious and ignore the middle.
- whatshisface 8y ago>You can't legislate what's obvious and ignore the middle. That is done successfully all the time. It's nice to have the legal boundary match the line exactly all the time, but if the line isn't known then there's no harm in placing the legal boundary on the conservative side as an interim solution while you work the details out.