3 ms·
So, right now, most university Elsevier customers use "IP address authentication" to get through the paywall. And have a byzantine "proxy" system for affiliates
by jrochkind1 8y ago
So, right now, most university Elsevier customers use "IP address authentication" to get through the paywall. And have a byzantine "proxy" system for affiliates not on campus to still get access -- appearing to a vendor like Elsevier like they are coming from a recognized university IP.
There are a whole bunch of problems with this system, that you can imagine.
But ONE is that it makes it a lot easier for things like sci-hub to automatically batch ingest articles with credentials from someone affiliated with a university (Elsevier customer), but without Elsevier actually knowing _what_ account was used. Elsevier's access logs end up giving them nothing but at best a university-affiliated IP address, with easy no way to know (because of proxy use) even what downloads were associated with distinct "users".
For THAT reason, academic content vendors have been trying to move to a system where there are individual identity accounts, so they can track who is downloading what (and try to block or worse accounts being used to sci-hub). You know, for "security".
I think this incident shows that trusting Elsevier with any kind of identity accounts is not in fact "security".
- munk-a 8y agoThere is no part of this (except the possibility of shutting it down) that I don't love. Elsevier is just such a wonderful company to detest, they're like the final boss of free-market driven anti-intellectualism.