51 ms·
Any reasonable government needs to have a small outlet for things that seem crazy. In other words, you need X Files. Not because you believe everything, most
by colechristensen 8y ago
Any reasonable government needs to have a small outlet for things that seem crazy. In other words, you need X Files.
Not because you believe everything, most things, or even any thing in them, but because having an open mind is important. If you think you know everything, you will miss a lot. Being open minded means spending some time at the tail edges investigating things that look like utter garbage woo, even if the result is that they are invariably utter garbage woo.
Also, it is not complete nonsense.
Altering conscious states is absolutely real and there are many avenues to it. Altered consciousness is also solidly in the interests of an intelligence agency and research is only natural.
There is definitely a flavor of pseudoscientific nonsense that comes along with altered consciousness experiences, but you can look past that.
Reports like this look to me very similar into pre-flight experiments. There were a whole lot of people making patently ridiculous flying contraptions but with hindsight many of them had some important ideas right.
See also: alchemy as a precursor to chemistry
Studying and treating the brain by developing methods to alter conscious states is, I think, going to be a major achievement of the 21st century, and things like this are precursors.
- ChristHamster 8y agoThis is a great point, having an open mind to these sort of things is very important. You never know what sort of things could come of experiments if they aren't done or pushed aside. Especially with the more widespread knowledge of the capability of psychedelics to change your mind. To ignore this avenue of very new and oft-misunderstood science would just be, to put it bluntly, ignorant.
- ataturk 8y agoExcept our tax dollars pay for these flights of fancy! Also, the CIA's credibility, were it a bond, would be rated junk. They flew cocaine into the US by the cargo-plane-load. They're a rogue organization, the deep state, and they don't follow any laws anywhere.
- everdev 8y ago> Studying and treating the brain by developing methods to alter conscious states is, I think, going to be a major achievement of the 21st century There's a great book called "Stealing Fire" by Steven Kotler & Jamie Wheal about this very subject.
- fsloth 8y agoI think the only actionable advice I got from the book was that well meshed teams can deliver an output that exceeds the sum of the individual contributions. Which totally makes sense. My atoms can't write HN comments but when they work as a team they sure can. Which really shouldn't be news but still it was a fun read.
- ElFitz 8y agoThat's one of the main takeaways from the cellular automata models lecture in Coursera's Model Thinking course (https://www.coursera.org/learn/model-thinking https://www.coursera.org/learn/model-thinking) "It from bit"
- mikekchar 8y ago> If you think you know everything, you will miss a lot. However, searching for low probability events in a large search space is not necessarily going to be a fruitful experience. For example, imagine that there is non-zero probability of a 20 karat diamond being on the beach somewhere, buried in the sand. You can look for it as much as you want, but you will still probably miss it. Having a small outlet for things that seem crazy because they might turn out to be true is the same kind of logic as buying a lottery ticket because you can't win if you don't play. Yes, you will miss things, but you will almost certainly miss them anyway unless you expend more resources than they are worth -- and then you still aren't guaranteed to make progress. On the other hand low probability risks that are likely to happen sometime are often worth investigating. For example, if there is a 1 in 1000 year earthquake event, it's highly unlikely to affect you in your life. But it will eventually affect someone so it may be work the effort to study what might happen. To get more esoteric, perhaps we can talk about large meteorites hitting the planet. Do we need a contingency plan for it? To me, that's the main question you need to ask before you start: are we building up an understanding of something that will almost certainly affect us one day, or are we simply sifting through grains of sand on the beach hoping to find a diamond?
- colechristensen 8y ago>low probability risks that are likely to happen sometime are often worth investigating. >buying a lottery ticket because you can't win if you don't play These are the same situation
- nmca 8y agoWhat? Expectation or risk-adjusted expectation are specified in neither case, they are the defining characteristics and you can't make statements about either of the cases without knowing or estimating them.
- FeepingCreature 8y agoI think the point is you know that beaches don't have diamonds in them in reachable range because people frequent beaches. But it's plausible to me that the CIA is sitting in unique operational territory, and their informational "obviously worthless" periphery is not well frequented. It's not about finding diamonds on the beach, it's about finding beaches with diamonds.
- simonh 8y agoThere’s also the issue that a lot of otherwise reasonable, educated people believe in the supernatural and woo science, or at least some of it. That means in a large organisation like the CIA, with dozens of senior officials over many decades, some of them will too and might act on it. Heck even as a doubter,I can accept it might be worthwhile investigating, just to prove it wrong.
- cm2187 8y agoFrench president Mitterrand was known to consult a fortune teller... [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89lizabeth_Teissier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89lizabeth_Teissier
- coldtea 8y agoWell, judging from his career, he didn't do bad doing so. (We don't know whether he would have done just as good without consulting one of course. But it didn't seem to hurt).
- simonh 8y agoThe fact is human beings are both rational and emotional beings. It's even possible for someone to 'rationally' know that it's bunk, but still receive and appreciate emotional benefits from something like that. It’s funny how people can profess they believe something, but persist in acting as though they don’t.
- cm2187 8y agoInvestors are the poster child of that behavior. No one knows the future, no one can really predict the market, particularly short term. So traders follow all sorts of superstitions like chartism, market proverbs and oracles (talking heads in financial news channels).
- short_sells_poo 8y ago