3 ms·
This has been going on since long, long before p-hacking and the replication crisis. And I honestly find these to be very different issues. It was common for
by mywittyname 8y ago
This has been going on since long, long before p-hacking and the replication crisis. And I honestly find these to be very different issues.
It was common for people in the US to reject the idea of smoking as a cause of lung cancer until like the 1980s. Scientific consensus on this fact was reached in the 60s and was suspected for a while before that. Yet, it took like 40 years for the public to agree.
Think about what's happening now with climate change. Scientists aren't undermining their own position, their authority and credibility is under direct attack; originally by moneyed interest, but today mostly through political indoctrinates. People view scientists as left-wingers out to undermine conservative policies and seek to undermine their authority and influence. Today, these people have much more reach and influence than in times past.
- brandonmenc 8y ago> It was common for people in the US to reject the idea of smoking as a cause of lung cancer until like the 1980s. Scientific consensus on this fact was reached in the 60s and was suspected for a while before that. Yet, it took like 40 years for the public to agree. You're exaggerating. It did not take until after the year 2000 for the public to believe that smoking causes cancer.
- mywittyname 8y agoNo I'm not... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3894634/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3894634/ > The public relations campaign -- which would extend for over 40 years -- was designed with the goal of reassuring the public, especially current smokers, that the question of whether smoking caused harm was an “open controversy” (1, 4, 14). > A poll conducted in 1966 found only 40% of Americans recognizing smoking as a major cause of cancer, while 27% said it was a minor cause and one-third said the science was not yet able to tell (2). In 2001 Gallup re-asked this same question and found 71% of Americans naming smoking as a major cause of cancer, with 11% saying it was a minor cause and 16% unsure (26).
- brandonmenc 8y agoWow. Yikes!
- alan-crowe 8y agoThere is a lot of social baggage around tobacco smoking that has faded from living memory. I read about the [Torches of Freedom](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torches_of_Freedom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torches_of_Freedom) advertising campaign and am amazed. Those young women, puffing their liberation in the 1930s, would turn into the old smokers of the 1970s. I guess that they would disbelieve that smoking caused lung cancer out of loyalty to the version of feminism that was current in their youth. If so, then the reluctance to accept the authority of science about tobacco is an idiosyncratic tale, specific to a powerful, pre-existing social meaning.