5 ms·
>in this house, we believe science is real Or maybe those people, even if they don't have much of a grasp on the scientific method, see the material progress a
by Barrin92 8y ago
>in this house, we believe science is real
Or maybe those people, even if they don't have much of a grasp on the scientific method, see the material progress and results of scientific work and conclude that they're going to place trust in scientific authority?
This is an entirely false equivalence. One can trust scientists even without understanding science, on the fact alone that research produces results that everyone can observe.
To suggest that we have too uncritical of an opinion of scientific research in an age were medieval diseases make a comeback because people aren't getting vaccinated, climate change is routinely ignored, and an atheistic scientist would likely not be able to run for high office based on that fact alone, is a joke to be honest.
- yters 8y agoIsn't trusting authority contrary to trusting science? The point of science is that we can verify truths for ourselves without relying on authority. Hence, if any authority, 'scientific' or otherwise, asserts their authority instead of providing individually verifiable evidence of its claims, then we can say they are being unscientific, regardless of title.
- Barrin92 8y agoI don't think that's the point of science at all to be honest. The point of scientific endeavour is to discover facts about the world. That's a really hard job, and the majority of people are not scientists, and even a trained scientist cannot verify the overwhelming majority of existing science by themselves, which means that science, like any other sufficiently large human collaboration, requires institutions, trust and authority. The difference between scientific and religious institutions is not that the former functions without authority or trust, it's that the success of the former is measured against observable and replicable results and material progress and not based on infallible spiritual promise. So if someone understands nothing about science at all, and worships it like a religion, at least they had the good sense of picking a religion that puts food on their table, makes their planes stay in the sky and makes them healthy again when they fall sick.
- xyhopguy 8y agois trusting scientific authority the same thing really? Believing the theory of evolution is different than trusting that the $100 genome is around the corner... And unlike religious institutions, scientific institutions typically reflect that difference in their rhetoric.
- sintaxi 8y agoThe goal of science is to acquire knowledge while mitigating human bias. No science ever eliminates bias completely. A good science teacher drills this point home constantly.
- roenxi 8y ago> So if someone understands nothing about science at all, and worships it like a religion, at least they had the good sense of picking a religion that puts food on their table, makes their planes stay in the sky and makes them healthy again when they fall sick. Religion has proven capable of welding large communities together, and that sort of shared belief system wins wars. If you ignore the fact that the doctrine is more allegorical than factual, religion has a lot of utility when resources are scarce. Being part of a large group is frequently more important than being part of a technically correct group. I think the last 200 years of history has demonstrated that science is a superior strategy, but it isn't obvious enough to be hand-waved. There is some evidence that to successfully abandon religion societies have to first have an ungodly surplus of resources. The new trend towards no religion hasn't been tested in a war yet either; back in WWII religious/nationalistic sentiment was famously high.
- yters 8y agoThen there is the fact that science was created by religious societies, Christianity in particular. Many of the fundamental discoveries came about due to religious motivations and religious principles: the world is orderly and understandable because it was created by a transcendent mind. Take away religion and we would not have science.
- pvaldes 8y ago
- MockObject 8y ago> Hence, if any authority, 'scientific' or otherwise, asserts their authority instead of providing individually verifiable evidence of its claims, then we can say they are being unscientific, regardless of title. Indeed, the motto of the Royal Society is "Take nobody's word for it". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nullius_in_verba https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nullius_in_verba
- bookofjoe 8y ago"The Strange Case of Francis Collins" https://samharris.org/the-strange-case-of-francis-collins/ https://samharris.org/the-strange-case-of-francis-collins/
- icelancer 8y ago> trust in scientific authority The very nature of science means that there should be no such thing as "scientific authority." (I say this as a person with published papers.)
- solipsism 8y agoJust goes to show you you can have "published papers" and be wrong. Nothing about science precludes the existence of authorities.