8 ms·
“In two years, this type of piracy will be over. After a ruling like this and all the pioneers start to get older and have children and families, piracy won’t
by kevingadd 16y ago
“In two years, this type of piracy will be over. After a ruling like this and all the pioneers start to get older and have children and families, piracy won’t occur to this extent.”
The only way I can see this type of piracy being over in two years is if the media industries up and die so there's nothing left to steal.
I wonder how much this case actually cost the media industries to litigate. The actual fines involved are relatively small, so it would be interesting to know whether the record companies will be able to use the fines to cover their legal fees.
- praptak 16y agoAs far as I remember these guys declared never to pay the fines. So no, the fines themselves will not cover anything.
- roel_v 16y ago"As far as I remember these guys declared never to pay the fines." Not quite sure what you mean by this, but once the collector comes, he'll just take whatever you have. I don't know about Swedish personal bankruptcy law but even in the best case if debts like this can be discharged by bankruptcy, going to jail for half a year, being flat-out broke for something like 5 years after that, having all your wages and possessions confiscated, and then having to re-build your life at 40 doesn't seem like a sacrifice the 'intellectual property is evil' cause is worth. Does anyone know something about these guys? Do they have families, companies, jobs? Eventually something like this had to happen of course, but still, I'm sure these guys were 100% convinced they were the Good Guys and Good Guys Prevail In The End, so this must be devastating...
- mzl 16y agoOne of them, Carl Lundström, has quite some money. For the other guys, I think they don't have very much in terms of personal means (unless the prosecutions version where they earned lots of money is true).
- tomjen3 16y agoWho said this is the end? Tomorrow new places to download stuff will appear, the content industry is still going down. But whomever things good guys always win are just fucking naive.
- roel_v 16y ago"Tomorrow new places to download stuff will appear, the content industry is still going down." May be, but these guys paid a big price for their part in it, if there is one at all, and I don't see anyone picking up the bill for them...
- tomjen3 16y agoNot really, they simply converted their monetary holdings into fame and high social standing; its a trade many people do small-scale when they by expensive dresses and designer-furniture in the hope of impressing others. These guys simply went all in. The prison-sentences are short, and will only get them even more respect and higher-social standing within their peer group, broadly defined. Since girls tend to like such people, they can expect to be able to get young and pretty girlfriends and will have no problem becoming writers for various blogs/magazines.
- roel_v 16y agoI can't tell if you're serious or being facetious?
- tomjen3 16y agoI am quite serious - Scott Peterson got a marriage proposal an hour after he was sent to death row, and while they haven't committed any murders, lots of girls fall for "bad boys" and they will have some reputation.
- roel_v 16y agoA couple of nerds are going to get laid for going to jail over file sharing, in a case most famous only on slashdot and a few other niche websites? Their 'social standing' with a couple of visitors of said websites, most of whom they never met, never will meet and don't even know the names of, is going up, and this is beneficial to them how? They have (as far as I can tell) no demonstrated writing skills, no recognizable name to speak off, and they're going to get jobs based on that? And even if they get a job, anything they'll make will still be confiscated! The reality distortion field is strong on this one. Just going to jail doesn't make one a 'bad boy'. I happen to remotely know a couple of people who did jail time over fraud charges (which is the 'crime class' there guys fall in, and the group they'll hang out with inside), and let me tell you, they really haven't turned into women magnets all of a sudden just because they've been in jail.
- dagw 16y agoI'm pretty sure I've read that they don't actually have any assets in Sweden to collect. Two of them don't even live in Sweden. I think the prosecutor even admitted in an interview that they don't expect to ever see any money.
- rtp 16y agoAFAIK, every one of them lives in Thailand/Cambodia except for Carl Lundström. I think they were all aware (except Carl Lundström) that luck would run out sooner or later, and from what I've seen, they had the plans all laid out on how to skip jail and fine. I would be surprised if any one of them except Lundström would serve any of their prison times, or pay any sum of money to pay for their fines.
- Tyrannosaurs 16y agoSo the punishment is that they basically can't return to their homeland (or likely Europe) without being declared bankrupt? That's still a fairly hefty penalty. Even if I chose to live elsewhere the idea of never being able to return home without a fairly major sanction would be a bummer.
- roel_v 16y agoGreat, so now they are basically exiled out of Europe to a third-world country where they can only legally stay for 6 months (with a few possibilities of extensions but still), and will have to restrict themselves to the ever-shrinking list of countries that do not have automatic flag systems set up for signaling people that are wanted on international warrants. This includes not being able to visit family for the rest of your life and not being able to visit your parents' funerals. Furthermore, any social security or pension entitlements they may have had will automatically be confiscated so they will have to provide for themselves, in fore-mentioned third-world country, presumably without a sizable starting capital, and without being able to take on any consulting jobs that require them to travel to Europe, and potentially other Western countries (I'm not familiar with international agreements on this matter, but most countries have no problems extraditing foreign nationals, especially not when they're convicted in criminal cases). Sounds like a great "plan to skip jail and fine". This ain't Prison Break. There's no way to escape from convictions that don't require profound sacrifices for the rest of your life. I can't understand why everybody is so dismissive - "oh they'll be fine". No they won't, they're fucked for the rest of their lives.
- rtp 16y agoSounds like a great "plan to skip jail and fine". Well, I didn't say it was a good plan. ;) I was merely pointing out that I thought they were anticipating that this was how things would turn out. I would like to add: The statute of limitations here in Sweden for a jail time of <1 year is max 10 years or so (according to Swedish Wikipedia it's 2 years, but I'm not sure if the fines complicate the matter).
- FrankenTan 16y agoOne of them (Peter Sunde) made flattr, the micro-payment service, unless I'm mistaken. http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/FlattrBlog/~3/Uxur-7Ouz0M/ http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/FlattrBlog/~3/Uxur-7Ouz0M/ Their involvement with the pirate bay were well known, and I suspect known by their respective employers. They are also rather well-known within the Swedish Pirate movement. I suspect the people who won't hire them after the verdict wouldn't have hired them even before it since their involvement with the pirate bay was no secret. The pirate movement in Sweden is one of the most vocal movements about civil rights and against host of laws that are considered to be in dispute with civil rights, so for this movement they're more or less martyrs rather than just some nerds who built a tracker and a trademark. Recent laws (mass-surveillance, corporations being given more investigative rights than the police, etc) and events in Sweden have in a way bridged current civil rights and rule-of-law issues with the pirate movement. It'll be interesting to see wheter this connection remains now that Sweden has a new liberal party which tackle many of the same issues the pirate party does, or wheter they'll become more separated with time. [Edit: Rephrased section into 'considered to be in dispute with civil rights']
- sophacles 16y agoCopyright infringement is not stealing. Stealing happens when I take resource from you in a way that denies you that resource, e.g. taking money or property, using your time without paying an agreed price. Copyright infringement happens when I don't follow your artificial scarcity rules. You aren't denied any resource you had before my infringement. Please stop calling copyright infringement stealing. It is not. Doing so is an oversimplification of the issue designed to induce unwarranted feelings of guilt in people (due to western notions of Stealing is Wrong).
- DrJokepu 16y agoYes it is, in my opinion. It's up to the owner of the intellectual property to decide who can have access to his or her property, not you. If you refuse to accept the conditions that's fair enough, but in that case still accessing the copyrighted material is taking something that you're not entitled to. I don't agree with the behaviour of the recording industry or with criminalizing the general public but simply taking something that's not yours is not the right solution, in my opinion.
- lt 16y agoHe's not saying that piracy isn't wrong. He's saying that the act is called copyright infringement, not theft.
- DrJokepu 16y agoI know, that's what I was talking about in the first part of my post. I had to add the the second part just to make sure that I'm not misunderstood.
- axod 16y ago> " but simply taking something that's not yours is not the right solution, in my opinion." I think that was his point - you're not taking something that's not yours. Say I take a photo of your cup, then feed the 3d image into a 3d printer, so that I have an exact replica of your cup, I haven't stolen your cup have I.
- ique 16y agoI just had a small vision when I read this article. In two years time Voddler (or something like it) will be big for movies, Spotify will be big for music and people will stop purchasing things entirely. The "Pirate movement" will see this as progress and smart people going around the old geezers in charge, because we don't have to pay outrageous amounts of money for a piece of plastic we don't even want. The media industry will call it a success in their anti-piracy harshness and will cite cases like this as the reason for the new ways to crop up. Both parties will think they're right, and in the end the only thing that has changed is the distribution-system. The 2 year timescale is probably off, but i'm pretty sure everything will end with those idiots saying "It's a good thing we put kids in jail because otherwise we wouldn't live in the wonderful world we do today."