2 ms·
Really science shouldn't operate on authority in the first place ideally - it should speak for itself. In practice however there are limits to both time and abi
by Nasrudith 8y ago
Really science shouldn't operate on authority in the first place ideally - it should speak for itself. In practice however there are limits to both time and ability to understand. It should be listened to for being more right as opposed to position.
The most disturbing part isn't not trusting scientist but not trusting evidence, even that gathered by themselves.
It is one thing to say believe light has infinite speed but after playing around with a laser and a receiver noticing the reflection time varies. It is another to insist it has it even after doing research and experimentation.
I suspect Sophism is the main culprit really - arguing based on feelings as opposed to facts. Now feelings have their place but their role is to guide goals. Not wanting to take another part time job on top of a full time one for more money is fair. Denying that taking an extra job would boost total income is delusionals (the sustainability of doing so is another topic).
- ben509 8y ago> In practice however there are limits to both time and ability to understand. It does seem that for some big ticket items like global warming the way to go would be have an open sourced app people can download and play with the simulations themselves. The scientists working on this stuff do make efforts to put this material together in a comprehensible form, so it's all out there. But it's very hard to trace anything back to the original data, and it seems like we're getting to the point where enough tools to do this are becoming ubiquitous. > I suspect Sophism is the main culprit really - arguing based on feelings as opposed to facts. I think that's very much our default behavior. When I've seen policy discussions it seems overwhelmingly that people look at it through a personal lens, and then they've set themselves up so criticism of their position is criticism of them. And then it's bloody difficult to deescalate without seeming condescending.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y ago> It does seem that for some big ticket items like global warming the way to go would be have an open sourced app people can download and play with the simulations themselves. It all depends on who writes the simulation. Tweak a few parameters and you have a balmy, lush green paradise in the Midwest without any winter snow.