7 ms·
You say "that's not true either", but really, it was never true in the first place. Traditional taxonomy is bad at determining how related species are. If you w
by klodolph 8y ago
You say "that's not true either", but really, it was never true in the first place. Traditional taxonomy is bad at determining how related species are. If you want that, you look for evidences of common ancestors, or do DNA analysis.
I tried digging through Wikipedia articles on taxonomy, but it seems to be a bit of a mess, with different articles in the hierarchy using different, incompatible sources. It looks like rodents and primates are both members of clade Euarchontoglires, with common ancestors 85-95 mya.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euarchontoglires https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euarchontoglires
Clade Laurasiatheria is a sibling containing pigs, cats, whales, bats, and many others. Common ancestor with primates is listed as ~80-100 mya (yes, this number doesn't match the other one).
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> Traditional taxonomy is bad at determining how related species are. If you want that, you look for evidences of common ancestors, or do DNA analysis. "Evidence of common ancestors" is precisely what traditional taxonomy looks for. Clades at levels between the traditional taxa were developed by exactly that method. DNA analysis is the same strategy with new technology. > It looks like rodents and primates are both members of clade Euarchontoglires, with common ancestors 85-95 mya. > Clade Laurasiatheria is a sibling containing pigs, cats, whales, bats, and many others. Common ancestor with primates is listed as ~80-100 mya (yes, this number doesn't match the other one). This sure looks like the approximation "primates are equally related to all non-primate mammals" isn't bad...
- mirimir 8y ago> Evidence of common ancestors" is precisely what traditional taxonomy looks for. Clades at levels between the traditional taxa were developed by exactly that method. DNA analysis is the same strategy with new technology. Yes, it's partly based on the fossil record. But the fossil record is very thin. Only a small percentage of stuff gets fossilized. And it's a very subjective approach. There's also morphology and embryology. But those are also very subjective. It's rather like using phrenology in psychiatry and psychology. With molecular generics, we have objective measures for identifying common ancestors and building phylogenetic trees.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoBy "evidence of common ancestors", I'm referring to (shared) morphology, not the fossil record.
- mirimir 8y agoThat's a very weak approach. Or at least, it's very subjective.
- mirimir 8y agoI clearly recall reading that DNA-based phylogenetic analysis indicated that primates and rodents have common ancestors that are more recent than common ancestors with other mammals. So in that sense, rodents are more closely related than, for example, dogs, cats, cattle, etc. Pigs I may be wrong about. They're clearly more similar than dogs, cats and cattle. In embryonic development, for sure, and I remember that from dissecting a fetal pig. And there is the saying that embryology recapitulates phylogeny. But a quick search didn't come up with any DNA-based phylogenetics. As you say, "traditional taxonomy is bad at determining how related species are". It's largely based on morphology, embryology and fossil evidence. But that can be irffy, given the thin fossil record, and the common occurrence of independent selection. DNA-based classification is really the only way to get objective phylogenetic trees. And as we get them, we learn that lots of classical taxonomy is just wrong. And that's why reading about taxonomy online is so confusing. It's a mix of old and new, with lots of more-or-less uninformed speculation.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> Pigs I may be wrong about. They're clearly more similar than dogs, cats and cattle. In embryonic development, for sure, and I remember that from dissecting a fetal pig. And there is the saying that embryology recapitulates phylogeny. But a quick search didn't come up with any DNA-based phylogenetics. The saying exists, but it is not based in anything other than wishful thinking. Ontogeny does not recapitulate phylogeny; that saying is the tongue map of evolutionary analysis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recapitulation_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recapitulation_theory > the shortcomings of the theory had been recognized by the early 20th century, and it had been relegated to "biological mythology" by the mid-20th century. This did not prevent its propagation into the 21st century in a variety of biology textbooks. If you believe the page on euarchontoglires, you can see that pigs cannot be more closely related to humans than dogs, cats, and cattle, because all four of those human-other pairings have exactly the same common ancestor, the common ancestor of the euarchontoglires (the tree branch containing humans) and the laurasiatheria (the branch containing pigs, cattle, cats, and dogs). Any closer "similarity" between pigs and humans in specific is not driven by their evolutionary relationship. > DNA-based classification is really the only way to get objective phylogenetic trees. And as we get them, we learn that lots of classical taxonomy is just wrong. DNA-based classification is not conceptually different from morphology-based classification. They are both directly premised on the model of "descent with modification". DNA-based classification is generally superior because there is more information in the DNA than in the morphology. (Or at least, we recognize more information in the DNA than we do in the morphology.) But morphology-based classification did nearly 100% of the work of establishing modern taxonomy, and overwhelmingly DNA-based analyses confirm the existing morphology-based conclusions. > traditional taxonomy is bad at determining how related species are This is true in the sense of assigning a cardinal number to the relationship. ("Diverged 80mya.") It is false if your goal is only to assign an ordinal number. ("Humans are closely related to baboons, distantly related to rabbits, and remotely related to elephants.") The same objection applies to DNA-based taxonomy; we get cardinal numbers by assuming a particular constant-rate molecular clock, but the raw conclusions of DNA analysis are entirely ordinal. > as we get them, we learn that lots of classical taxonomy is just wrong. (quoting again to respond along another topic) Notwithstanding the overall massive success of traditional taxonomy, there are some obvious weak points. They tend to derive from philosophical beliefs of the biologists rather than from failures of the morphology-comparing model. Two major biases that I'm aware of are the historical belief that taxa at the same level should include roughly the same number of extant species -- this was featured in a "teach the controversy" sidebar in a college biology textbook of my mother's -- and the stronger view that genera should contain more than a single species. Since the groupings prompted by these beliefs were not even intended to "cleave reality at the joints", it's not so surprising that they suffered under more objective analysis.