5 ms·
Reads more like "Hands over control to any customer that will pay for it."[1] I wonder if the UI shows the employees that their employers have the keys. [1] E
by tyingq 8y ago
Reads more like "Hands over control to any customer that will pay for it."[1]
I wonder if the UI shows the employees that their employers have the keys.
[1] Edit: as opposed to only regulated customers. Also, there's an upcharge...you don't automatically get control.
- AnaniasAnanas 8y agoI am pretty sure that this was already true anyway - after all anyone with enough money could just buy the company. Yet another reason to use e2e encryption and authentication.
- tener 8y agoThere are industries where you have no expectation of privacy at work because all comms are required to be monitored and stored due to the law. So this new feature really enables them to serve these customers who operate under such laws.
- tyingq 8y agoSure but being that it's a distinct change some sort of indicator in the UI seems reasonable.
- avip 8y agoThis change does not affect the normal user at all.
- gregoriol 8y agoMatrix allows encryption with only access by people in the room, and even since they joined.
- geofft 8y agoRight, and Matrix cannot be legally used by such customers. (I was the person who set up Slack compliance logging at my previous employer, which was SEC- and FINRA-regulated, moving from internal IRC. We weren't legally allowed to use even the chat window on the side of Google Docs etc.) If the privacy of your work chats is important to you, there are lots of other jobs you can take. And of course nothing prohibited private chats between employees as long as they were not about work. I absolutely used Signal with friends who happened to be coworkers, but it was for things like planning our next D&D session and not planning out next trade.
- numbsafari 8y agoEven if it isn't the law, most companies make you sign away your ownership of any and all communications made using company provided systems or materials as part of the employment contract. Be sure to read your employment agreement. And never, ever, use work related systems for anything personal or private or inappropriate. "NSFW" means something. Heck, apply this level of thinking to any system you don't own or control. Unless privacy is baked into the protocol, you have none. Period.
- black-tea 8y agoWhat is your expectation if the UI does not show that? That your communication is private? Why would you expect private communication when using your employer's infrastructure or, worse, a third party infrastructure like Slack? If you don't own the keys, it's not your data.
- tyingq 8y ago"That your communication is private?" No. Just feel like who owns the keys is relevant. I can see, for example, if my employer is using a self-signed cert within my browser. Though I understand they have other ways to see what I'm doing in a browser even if there is no MITM cert.
- jerf 8y agoAre you saying you had some sort of presumption of privacy on a corporate Slack account? If you did, you had it in error. If I am reading this right, this actually reduces your exposure as an employee. Instead of your employer and Slack having full access to everything you do on that account, now your employer has full access but Slack's access is reduced substantially. (If the setup is working as I expect, Slack will still get metadata.)
- tyingq 8y agoI don't know slack internals. but I assume the employer having the key means that they now have a way to rewrite history in a way that looks cryptographically correct.
- bastawhiz 8y agoThat's not how it works. Just because you have the keys doesn't mean you have direct filesystem or database access to change what you please.
- eitland 8y agoOk, lets just make this clear: Slack is not the tool you'd want to use for anything but the most innocent work-related messages. For that it is kind of usable, not good but one of the better that will get approved by management.
- tyingq 8y agoI didn't suggest it was. Again, I don't know the internals. But generally, an entity that has keys can forge messages. There's an incremental difference between the ability to snoop and the ability to forge. There's docs on the slack API, but none for the protocol, and not much is said about the new functionality. It's certainly possible that was already there via other means, but a change in key control seems significant enough to warrant a UI indicator to me.
- jerf 8y ago
- lallysingh 8y agoHands over control of a customer's account to .. the customer?
- tyingq 8y agoAs opposed to the headline, which implies it might be available to only regulated entities, yes.
- lallysingh 8y agoit actually says "regulated customers"
- tyingq 8y agoYes. It says: "hands over control...to regulated customers" It hands over control to ANY customer, not just regulated ones. And only to those that pay the upcharge. Just seems oddly worded.
- lallysingh 8y agoOk, I understand what you mean now. Yes it's strictly an unnecessary qualifier, but does make the intent of the move clearer.
- wglb 8y agoMost acceptable use policies (or information security policy or employee handbook) point out that employees must presume that the company does monitoring of the employee's communications. Further, some readings of the ECPA (Electronic Communications Privacy Act) indicate an obligation on the part of the company to monitor.