3 ms·
This seems: 1 - not to have been published in any peer-reviewed journals 2 - a study on rats 3 - the rats were injected with MSG intravenously 4 - the amoun
by pmoriarty 8y ago
This seems:
1 - not to have been published in any peer-reviewed journals
2 - a study on rats
3 - the rats were injected with MSG intravenously
4 - the amount of MSG injected intravenously was 50mg/kg, which would be equivalent to 2.5 grams of MSG for a 50kg person
Because of all of the above, it's not clear whether it's good science, and not clear if any of this research applies to humans, who normally don't inject gigantic amounts of MSG in to their veins.
- kazinator 8y ago> 2.5 grams of msg for a 50kg person MSG is slightly more dense than sugar, with a specific gravity of 1.6 and comes in a crystalline form that resembles sugar. 4 grams of sugar is about a teaspoon, and the same can be expected of MSG. They can easily dump half a teaspoon of the stuff into your soup or sauce in a restaurant, treating it like salt or sugar. This amazing paper is valuable not just for its work on rats, but for its references. It's also noteworthy that the researcher basically considers it a settled question that MSG causes headaches. In this work, she isn't trying to answer the question "do rats get a headache from MSG".
- pmoriarty 8y agoIf it truly is a settled question that MSG causes headaches in humans, when the MSG is ingested (not injected) in amounts humans normally eat, then it should be easy to find studies in reputable journals to this effect. Do you have a link to such studies? The injection/ingestion distinction is important, because when one ingests something, the entire quantity is not instantly dumped in to the bloodstream as it is when injected. The food MSG is ingested with might also have an effect on its rate of absorption and its effects. It might also undergo some changes in the digestive tract before it gets in to the blood stream.
- kazinator 8y agoBecause this particular researcher is looking for very specific effects, that she's trying to measure accurately. She's shaved an area of the rat's skulls down to a thin window through which she's able to observe blood flow changes. > Do you have a link to such studies? This paper has a bunch of these types of references; for that alone it's useful. See section 2.4.
- kazinator 8y agoBy the way, injection would be a good way to double-blind an MSG experiment with humans properly: you can't taste an injection. Nobody can tell whether they are being injected saline or MSG. And nobody is claiming that the effects of MSG are not dose-dependent; that there is no consumption threshold below which sufferers feel no ill effects. Those who believe that any amount of MSG, no matter how miniscule, can cause them discomfort are deranged. If it were so, they would get these effects from all sorts of common foods that naturally contain glutamate.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- technocratius 8y agoHow about...putting it in a capsule?
- MertsA 8y agoYou'd have to be crazy to add 2.5 grams worth of MSG to a single meal. Accent calls for using like 1/10th that amount in soup. That's no different than using 10x as much salt as a recipe calls for, it's not going to turn out so great.
- kazinator 8y agoIn the paper I cited there is a reference to another one by Shimada, et al. 2013. Those researchers estimate the daily intake of MSG in industrialized countries to be between 50 mg/kg and 200 mg/kg. (That reference is given in section 2.4.1, p. 76). So you're saying that MSG doesn't cause headaches, because nobody would be crazy enough to put 2.5 grams of it into the meal consumed by a 50 kg person? Or what is the logic here? The paper cites at least two other studies which found that 150 mg/kg daily doses caused headaches: to 100% of the subjects in one of the studies, and more than 50% in the other.
- MertsA 8y agoThe paper you cited references three other papers. The first paper just throws out an estimate with no source or data for it, just a figure. That figure is also not in mg/kg just total dietary intake. Honestly the figure itself is believable as it claims 0.3g to 1.0g per day which works out to 4.3mg/kg to 14.3 mg/kg for a 70 kg person. The second paper isn't listing MSG or even just free glutamate, it's listing all glutamate content which as you pointed out in another comment, is not comparable. The third paper cited appears to be where they got their wildly wrong claim of 50 mg/kg to 200 mg/kg from but this literally just cites the first two papers. I'm assuming they just converted the glutamate figures in the second paper and assumed all of that was MSG. Either way the claim that average daily intake of MSG is between 50 mg/kg and 200 mg/kg is just flat out unfounded and wrong. The very first source they cite lists a figure less than 1/10th that amount and obviously does not support their claim. And keep in mind, a 150 mg/kg dose for an average person is 10.5 g, that's over 20x the recommended serving size. [1] https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/130/4/1058S/4686672 https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/130/4/1058S/4686672 [2] https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/9f51/b5f34954560f02b0c01eb9749a78cbf4536e.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/9f51/b5f34954560f02b0c01eb9... [3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3606962/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3606962/