4 ms·
Two thoughts: 1. They really are no sugar in aboriginal societies? No fruit or carbs? 2. I know a handful of people who eat Western diets who have zero too
by refurb 8y ago
Two thoughts:
1. They really are no sugar in aboriginal societies? No fruit or carbs?
2. I know a handful of people who eat Western diets who have zero tooth decay.
Doesn’t seem like a great way to tell the age of a skull.
- thoughtstheseus 8y ago1. Significantly less. 2. That's great to hear.
- smallnamespace 8y agoTo expand on (1.), modern cultivated fruit varieties are quite different from what wild fruits are seasonally available—for one thing, you're always competing with wild animals for a sugary, tasty snack. Here's a somewhat fascinating article looking at both sides of this debate: https://deniseminger.com/2011/05/31/wild-and-ancient-fruit/ https://deniseminger.com/2011/05/31/wild-and-ancient-fruit/ The conclusion to me seems to be that unless you're in the tropics, you almost certainly be eating less fruit, and the fruit you'll eat will be much more varied and seasonal. A lot of the wild fruit you eat may have specific defenses (tannins, alkaloids, etc.) that discourage you from eating too much (the fruit's job is to make you spread and excrete its seeds, after all).
- SteveCoast 8y ago"Doesn’t seem like a great way to tell the age of a skull." The confidence of people far away at a different time without any relevant knowledge to dismiss an experienced local on the ground based on flawed high-level logic never ceases to surprise.
- intertextuality 8y agoIt's the epitome of hacker news. Reddit also has this "armchair quarterbacking" effect, but it's significantly worse on HN, in my opinion. A lot of the people here are knowledgeable—in specific domains. I think people forget that being an expert in one thing doesn't make you qualified to judge, understand, or discuss another domain in depth. Case in point, the recent "tech that reduces sound by 94%" post that got upvoted here.
- imjustsaying 8y agoOne of the most common instances of generalized experts weighing in on topics they're not actually experts in happens in politically-related posts here, although it usually only comes in the form of downvotes. You can cite science and demographic facts while leaving out your own overt normative opinions, yet you will still get downvoted from both 'sides' who think they are being slighted if you don't give a clear opinion. Unfortunately this is the way scientific method-driven experts talk (and generally anyone who's into political science rather than political opinion) - but in this domain it really sets non-experts off for some reason. The thing is, most people are taught at a young age that their political opinion matters a lot, which probably has something to do with generalized experts walking into this domain thinking they're already experts and getting quickly frustrated when they realize they're not, lashing out at the source of that frustration via downvotes. Back in the day the responses to these kinds of topics used to be via comments, now it's almost always via drive-by downvotes. I used to bemoan the inane buzzword replies back in the forum days because they were typically boring and predictable, but they were still infinitely better than the downvote without comment that is the norm for this site (and even more common on reddit).
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoTry saying anything with a hard truth at its core that goes against what people want to believe. And instead of engaging with discussion and rebuttal, they do so with -1s and rate-limiting. 1. Cognitive impairment is likely already happening in office rooms 2. Rich people "donating" to semi-non-profit orgs and universities are doing so for non-altruistic reasons. 3. When you use a free service, you are paying primarily with your data. 4. FAANG has engaged in criminal conspiracies. 5. News agencies that bemoan Facebook also bend over to Facebook and Google's tracking. 6. Cell phones don't cause cancer. 7. "Sharing Economy" is just a scam to evict employees from workforce to something less than employees. 8. The USA is primarily at "One Dollar = One Vote". 9. There's something else going on with meditation and mind, that we can't adequately explain with science at this moment. This place used to be a lot better, with discussions and rebuttals and refutations with sources and links. Now it's "who can '1 more". And hiding the current score does little to no good, other than obfuscate the real problem. Edit: Why am I not surprised a mod collapsed this, and likely flag-killed the response to me? This is what happens with little to no transparency, and when a VC firm "controls" the narrative.
- abrookewood 8y agoI don't actually read his comment as dismissive or confident, but more surprised and curious. There's nothing wrong with questioning other people's statements when they don't marry up with your own opinions.
- refurb 8y agoIndeed. It was more intellectual curiosity.
- greglindahl 8y agoYou called the story bullshit in another comment, that’s not what most people say when they are intellectually curious.
- refurb 8y agoIt’s because the story sounds like bullshit. I have no doubt that you can tell the age of a skull with a close inspection of the teeth. This story was an anthropologist looking at remains from several feet away and claiming that it’s aboriginal from the lack of dental decay. I proposed a few exceptions to that rule. Certainly not a quip about the expertise of the anthropologist, but rather the accuracy of the story.
- cyberferret 8y agoOne of the benefits of being an expert in a particular field, is that you can take small parcels of evidence and formulate an accurate picture of a situation much faster than a layman with no prior experience in that field. I don't know the anthropologist in question, but I am sure she used a series of supporting evidence that was obvious to her trained eye as well as the teeth condition. Ask any doctor or midwife who can look at an ultrasound image and tell you the sex of the baby while you are still staring at a smudgy grey moving image. Ask any accident investigator who can estimate the speed and trajectory of the vehicles while you are still looking for the skid marks. I personally have spent over 25 years interacting on public message boards, and I am a domain expert enough that I can pick an armchair expert who has lots of perceived theoretical knowledge, but little or no real world knowledge, but still feels the need to espouse their opinion in order to get their dopamine hit of the day - all just from a quick glance at their post.
- therealdrag0 8y agoI agree it sounds like bullshit. However, I have listened to a talk by a lady (she consults on murdered cadavers) who can tell which season a body died in by analyzing the teeth! Apparently there is a lot there.
- Baeocystin 8y agoThat I can believe, assuming a detailed analysis in a lab. But snap judging from a distance? Cavities are more common in modern populations than before, but hardly omnipresent. I do find it an amusing thought that apparently my skeleton would be assigned a more distant past simply because I am filling free. :D
- WA 8y agoSince when does an anecdote provide any proof? I thought exactly the same things as your parent poster. Carbs are sugar, especially if you chew long enough. This affects teeth. Combine this with a lack of toothbrushes and a lack of fluoride and it sounds like a recipe for tooth decay. Also, people didn’t live as long as they do now. So less chance to have your teeth rotten. Furthermore: the skeletons might have been of people in their twenties with arguably better teeth than old people. Lots of questions that this anecdote doesn’t answer and you dismiss critique as pretentious.
- andrei_says_ 8y agoHe most likely meant refined sugars. Sugar is being added to most foods nowadays. The timeline of cheap refined sugar is the timeline of sugar addiction and tooth decay.
- refurb 8y agohttps://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/01/06/tooth-decay-archaeology/4307319/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/01/06/tooth-... Scientists examined the remains of 52 adults who had lived between roughly 12,000 and 13,000 B.C. and were buried in the cave. An astonishing 49 of them, or 94%, had cavities, which affected more than half of the surviving teeth.
- richcollins 8y agoBy analyzing plant remains in the cave, Humphrey's team found that residents ate lots of a particularly sweet type of acorn, which becomes soft and sticky when cooked. They also ate wild oats and legumes. Such foods can lead to serious decay,
- refurb 8y agoYes, and wild oats and legumes don’t exactly seem like the exception in ancient diets. Plus another link in this thread claims ancient fruits have different sugars that don’t cause decay.
- andrei_says_ 8y agoAre you trying to imply that refined sugars do not cause an increase in tooth decay? Or that fruit sugar is similar to refined sugars? Any ties with the sugar lobbby famous for lobbying the US government into blackmailing the WHO in increasing the amounts “healthy” sugar in their dietary guidelines?
- Mirioron 8y ago"Refined sugar" is sugar in fruit. It is literally the same thing. That's how we get sugar in the first place - from plants. You are dealing with glucose, fructose, and sucrose in both cases.
- ajdlinux 8y ago> Doesn’t seem like a great way to tell the age of a skull. Going to take a guess and say that a brief glance at the teeth is probably not the _only_ age determination method they applied before determining their course of action.
- refurb 8y agoand asked her how she could tell even from afar that these were not more current remains
- ajdlinux 8y agoRight, and then after making that initial assessment, I'm going to guess they didn't just stop walking, write out and sign the incident report and pull out the radio to let the station know that they were pretty much done here and there's nothing to worry about. No, I assume they walked up to it and got a more conclusive look at the body first.
- skrebbel 8y agoI'm not sure I've ever seen a better example of classic HN-style "middlebrow dismissal" than this comment. I want to print it and frame it.