5 ms·
This video is fascist propaganda. It isn't neutral. It also isn't "purged from the internet".
by UncleMeat 8y ago
This video is fascist propaganda. It isn't neutral.
It also isn't "purged from the internet".
- huffmsa 8y agoIt's purged from the parts of internet the majority of people consider "the internet". But here's 65+ people vaporizing from 18 different angles. On YouTube. These are not different. They are footage of a terrorist attack. https://youtu.be/7YLm3pkAiJQ https://youtu.be/7YLm3pkAiJQ
- peteradio 8y agoSo are you advocating these be taken down? Or you think that if the rule isn't applied equally everywhere then it shouldn't be applied at all? Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. I think its pretty fucked up to think that shoving this guys murder vid into peoples faces is somehow for the greater good.
- huffmsa 8y agoI don't see these two pieces of footage as functional different. They are documentation of terrorist attacks. If one is allowed, then yes, all should be.
- arrrg 8y agoThe video of the NZ attacks is not documentation. It is purposefully created propaganda by the terrorist himself. It’s not neutral. (Not that even something set up explicitly as merely documentation could ever be completely neutral itself, I’m just saying that this footage is extremely far removed from having any claim to neutrality.) It does document the attacks, that much is true. And in that regard it is the same as footage of 9/11 – but beyond that there is a distinction here. Don’t be confused by simplification. Do take into account context, intent and author. (That said, I do think that you can question whether it was wise to play video of the planes flying into WTC basically on repeat during those days.)
- huffmsa 8y agoBut we still make Nazi filmed footage from their concentration camps available. There's no other way to truly understand what happened unless you see it. Regardless of who filmed it.
- arrrg 8y agoWith proper context, sure, I’m all in favour of that. I’m not suggesting every last copy of this video being deleted. However, I do question the need for everyone to watch the video to understand what happened. That doesn’t really seem to follow for me.
- huffmsa 8y agoAnd I don't think it should be forced in people's faces either. But it should be available for those who want to view it.
- 1rkd 8y agoI don't think this can really be considered propaganda. It functions more to shock, insult, and potentially "brag". I think it is almost impossible that this video can garner support for white supremacist causes in anyone other than an already deeply racist and violent person. Seeing this unfold only portrays the shooter as a cowardly psychopath.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bjowen 8y ago... to you and luckily most people. I think the concern is twofold: the number of individuals who will take the footage as some sort of incitement is non-negligible - as this cowardly psychopath has apparently done with the Norwegian attack some years ago. There is also the concern that it will be disseminated amongst those whose inclination is towards revenge as anti-Western propaganda.