3 ms·
I don't necessarily see a problem with locked down devices because if I have a right to control what runs on my computer, then so does Apple or Nintendo on thei
by Spivak 8y ago
I don't necessarily see a problem with locked down devices because if I have a right to control what runs on my computer, then so does Apple or Nintendo on theirs.
One might counter, saying something like "but you 'own' your iPhone, you should be able to do whatever you want with it." But I think such an argument is more to do with not having a common word to describe this kind of transaction -- we understand things like leasing and renting but we still describe 'buying' managed devices with the same terminology that we do a toaster. IT people get close to this model with managed on-prem appliances but it's not quite the same.
The same problem exists with copyrighted works because when you buy a DVD you don't own the movie, you own a single transferrable non-commercial personal-use license losely attached to the physical medium.
We would do well to make these business relationships more explicit and better defined but I wouldn't expect the relationships themselves to change.