3 ms·
Google looks at the web and tries to make money. A phisher or scammer looks at the web and tries to make money. Does that make them equivalent? You can be moti
by gojomo 19y ago
Google looks at the web and tries to make money. A phisher or scammer looks at the web and tries to make money. Does that make them equivalent?
You can be motivated by money but still be engaged in a noble pursuit.
Newspapers are published by for-profit companies in a constant and noble battle to report the truth, even though many other entities work hard to get falsehoods reported.
Pharmaceuticals are developed by for-profit companies in a constant and noble battle against disease.
The point of my grandparent comment is that the brainpower Google uses for its core service -- improving search -- is engaged in an honorable, beneficial activity. It's a hard problem, they're working against other profit-motivated malicious actors, and we all get a throwoff benefit from Google's work, even if we never click an ad.
That the activity also makes them money, or even was primarily motivated by making money, doesn't change that.
- Tichy 19y agoYour examples only prove the point: newspapers in a noble battle for the truth? Pharmaceutical companies in a noble battle against disease? No offence, but I think you need some reality checks. Not saying that newspapers don't hit upon the truth occasionally, or that pharmaceuticals don't cure the odd disease. But to quote a physician I once talked to: "I wouldn't be surprised if the cure against HIV is already lying in some drawer and not being published, because it has no benefits for the pharmaceutical companies". Or try reading an actual newspaper (not Hacker News) for a couple of days, then reconsider your opinion. It's very obvious that all they care about is making money, and perhaps they get the odd ego boost out of manipulating public opinion to their whims. I didn't mean this as a hardcore left wing or whatever paranoid comment (at least I don't consider myself any of those things). Maybe it is just because I am a foreign speaker that "noble" simply doesn't sound right to me. Noble is more than just beneficial in my book, I guess it also involves making sacrifices and stuff. Again I want to stress that I have nothing whatsoever against people reaping benefits of their work. I just took issue with the label "noble", that's all. Edit: if you could point me to a newspaper that is really fighting a noble battle for the truth, I would be delighted to hear about it. I might actually start reading it.
- gojomo 19y agoI thought it might be a word-choice and cultural issue; I suspect in Europe 'noble' has different connotations because there are actual aristocracy doing things, occasionally altruistically. (Americans mainly think of aristocracy as a source of camp entertainment.) I meant 'noble' as 'deservedly outstanding; moral; admirable; honorable; generous'. The journalists working for profit-making papers I have met do believe their work a noble calling, even when they feel cynical or compromised by the economic realities of their market. Though each has internalized biases one should be aware of, the NYTimes and WSJ are both great papers whose staff is usually fighting hard to arrive at the truth.
- Tichy 19y agoI think individual journalists are doing a good job and might have the right motivation, I just have never seen the actual newspapers to operate on that basis.
- LPTS 19y agoUm...you're going with...um...newspapers and pharmaceuticals as examples of noble corporations? Um... OK. I hate to break this too you, but newspapers haven't had shit to do with the truth since ownership rules relaxed enough to turn them into propaganda tools for whatever rich asshole with old money buys. Newspapers are mostly against the truth. When they do report whats true (about things the old money rulers don't care about), it's only so they can lie later, when the money does care. And there is a special place in hell for the scum fucks who set up pharmaceutical pricing and patenting schemes where AIDS patients all over the world are dying because they can't get access to medications factories in their own countries could make. And most work in pharmaceuticals is in reformulating drugs where the patent is about to expire and manipulating studies to claim a slight benefit over the previous generation, and then aggressively advertising it to consumers who are completely uneducated about medications while unethically pushing doctors to use it. Those are really really bad examples of corporations that do noble work.