4 ms·
I would love to see a cashless society because carrying around dirty bills and heavy coins is just a nuisance, and adds real overhead for stores as well... ...
by crazygringo 8y ago
I would love to see a cashless society because carrying around dirty bills and heavy coins is just a nuisance, and adds real overhead for stores as well...
...BUT, for privacy and the unbanked, I suspect this necessarily needs to go along with credit-card-compatible "cash cards" that would have to be:
1) Anonymous (e.g. buy a card for $1 from any drugstore, swap them with friends, buy in bulk and give away, whatever -- don't need to show an ID)
2) Secure and robust (value stored on-card without the ability for the government to deactivate etc., or for transactions to be cancelled after-the-fact)
3) All ATM's and banks required by law to support transferring any reasonable value (e.g. <$10K) from one card to another anonymously (so if I need to pay you, the two of us can walk into any bank). Ideally be able to do this at any convenience store, etc.
For whatever reason, I rarely see the idea of anonymous cash cards discussed in these types of conversations.
- joncp 8y ago> For whatever reason, I rarely see the idea of anonymous cash cards discussed in these types of conversations. Because it's really really hard to prevent forgery. Maybe impossible.
- Nextgrid 8y agoIt's impossible to prevent forgery just like physical cash, but it's definitely a lot harder to crack a properly designed cryptosystem than make a counterfeit note.
- def_true_false 8y agoAnonymous prepaid cards are a thing, very useful for e.g. people with debt problems.
- hakfoo 8y agoA prepaid card isn't "self-hosted". They're just front end for a bank account that can be closed or restricted by external forces. The right people in law enforcement could probably make a few calls and shut down an arbitrary prepaid card (or group of them). There's also a strong paper trail that can be used for that-- they could reasonably say "any card that was used at this suspicious merchant should be shut down". They can't demonetize a few random $100 notes with anywhere near the same degree of ease or specificity. Nor does the logging infrastructure exist to find every note which touched a suspicious individual.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- crooked-v 8y ago> Secure and robust > value stored on-card These two things don't go together.
- Nextgrid 8y agoIt could work as a sort of cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrencies are functionally equivalent to "stored value" and yet they remain secure. Plus, since we're talking about a government-issued currency, a lot of the drawbacks of a typical cryptocurrency wouldn't apply (the government can be considered the central source of trust, so no need for a proof of work system or anything).
- theamk 8y agoThe cryptocurrencies only remain as secure as your PC (or hardware wallet) is. And those things are only secure because they have the right software/firmware installed on them. And the reason you know you have the right firmware is because you trust the manufactures to put the right one in, and trust store/postal service not to tamper with it. Once you are in the domain of "Anonymous $1 cards which people swap with each other", you no longer have this option. The obvious thing is to have corresponding entry in online database, but then anyone who wants to verify the card value will have to access this database -- so your privacy disappears. I am not saying that it's impossible -- people are smart, something can likely be figured out -- but it is not obvious to me those cards can be made harder to forge than cash.
- xg15 8y agoA side effect would be that the three points taken together would effectively make the cards a new form of cash. As in, if people decide to simply exchange the physical cards instead of charging/discharging them, the cards effectively become a plain old traditional currency.
- lozenge 8y agoLarge denominations get removed from circulation because they are used to enable crime.