3 ms·
> While collecting data on users is nearly inevitable in today’s corporate world, secret, undisclosed, or unpredictable data collection—or data collection abili
by xg15 8y ago
> While collecting data on users is nearly inevitable in today’s corporate world, secret, undisclosed, or unpredictable data collection—or data collection abilities—is another problem.
A smart-home speaker shouldn’t be secretly hiding a video camera. A secure messaging platform shouldn’t have a government-operated backdoor. And a home security hub that controls an alarm, keypad, and motion detector shouldn’t include a clandestine microphone feature—especially one that was never announced to customers.
This sounds too much like trying to move the overton window for me. If the next generation of smart devices is advertised as "no hidden cameras and microphones! (we'll just spy on you with the visible cameras and microphones)", I don't think this would be a win.
- benj111 8y agoAgreed, but I would say the Overton Window was already way over there somewhere anyway. The fact that they need to lay out why this might be wrong is mildly depressing.
- renholder 8y ago>If the next generation of smart devices is advertised as "no hidden cameras and microphones! (we'll just spy on you with the visible cameras and microphones)", I don't think this would be a win. Agreed but we have to consider that it's entirely plausible that we're in the minority in this line of thinking.
- xg15 8y agoTrue of course, but what specifically makes you think that?