13 ms·
The main issue is that Apple doesn't allow you to use any other payment method - even via linking to a website - to use in-app purchases. Take this analogy: Ap
by judge2020 8y ago
The main issue is that Apple doesn't allow you to use any other payment method - even via linking to a website - to use in-app purchases.
Take this analogy: Apple is a city and has exclusive say over whether or not you can build a brick-and-mortar store on their land. Apple here exclusively owns all of the land, and won't let anyone else build on it without their permission (required distribution via app store).
In the current situation, Apple is saying "you can rent the land here for free, as long as you give us 30% of your sales". As per their press release, A bunch of game apps take advantage of the free property and make money via ads, which don't give Apple any cut of the revenue.
Spotify is complaining that, in order to build on Apple's land, they have to pay this 30%. They say "fine. we'll pass the cost on to the consumer." and institute a $13/month charge instead of $10.
Now that Apple sees music streaming is a profitable market, they build a store right across the street from the established Spotify store. Since Apple is both the city (who takes a 30% cut) and the store itself, they can decide to make the consumer price $10/month without actually losing any profit as Spotify would. This makes a bunch of iOS (iOS-only) Spotify customers cancel Spotify and switch to the cheaper Apple Music.
Now Spotify is angry, and is taking it up with the state government (EU).
- sjwright 8y agoA great analogy. Apple have done all the work building the city—maintaining the water and power, keeping the roads repaired, building ample car parking and sidewalks, keeping out the criminals, watering the plants, ensuring that none of the vendors are scammers, and generally making the city a really nice place. They even provide all the construction equipment for anyone who wants to build their store. Then they spent a lot of money marketing this city and over time have built a strong reputation for the city as a great place to be, the result being the city is full of customers. Not only that, they're renting store space to the vendors for free, in exchange for a flat and non-discriminatory sales tax. Seems fair. Despite all that convenience, Spotify still doesn't have to sell you their service from within stores in Apple City. They could have put a store just outside the city limits in the wild, wild west (aka the WWW). In return for making it slightly more inconvenient for their customers, they wouldn't have to pay the city's sales taxes, even when their customers enjoy the product inside Apple City. But if Spotify want to sell within Apple City, they benefit from the immense conveniences that Apple have put in place, from the marketing and reputation that Apple has cultivated. And it's not like Apple deceived anyone—the 30% sales tax was never concealed.
- Benjammer 8y ago>they can decide to make the consumer price $10/month without actually losing any profit as Spotify would What in the world does this really mean though? What do you mean "without losing any profit"? How do you know what Spotify vs. Apple Music operating costs are? Why should they have equal operating costs? I just don't get this exact part of the whole argument. So what if they undercut Spotify, maybe Spotify should take 30% less profit when they sell using Apple channels?
- je42 8y agoit is not only operating cost but also costs for licensing.
- berbec 8y agoLet's assume neither Spotify or Apple have a crazy price advantage in the licensing of music. Spotify and Apple Music get to keep $6.99 of the $9.99 they charge users. They are both forced to pay $3.00 to Apple App Store. See how this helps Apple out a huge amount? One side has a 30% cut taken, the other has to deal with having their accounting made more complicated.
- Benjammer 8y agoI am in no way trying to deny that an advantage exists for Apple & Apple Music. Can you explain why that's a legal problem for them though?
- judge2020 8y agoThe only legal problem I can see is because of the monopoly they have on their own hardware, but at that point, it's an antitrust case. I can't seem to find whatever Spotify is sending to the EU (from the bottom of the timeline [1]), but to me, it just seems like Spotify is whining throughout the whole website. The only thing I think Spotify could go with, if true, is this: > the rules are not applied evenly across the board. Does Uber pay it? No. Deliveroo? No. Does Apple Music pay it? No. So Apple gives the advantage to its own services. Disregarding "apple gives the advantage to its own services" while Uber and Deliveroo are not Apple-owned services, Apple not charging the commission for PassKit (Apple Pay) transactions may be the only thing Spotify has on Apple. 1: https://timetoplayfair.com/the-case/ https://timetoplayfair.com/the-case/