2 ms·
This is a good argument, but isn't privacy all about keeping secrets from the public? Incentives are tricky and I'm not sure we can clearly distinguish between
by skybrian 8y ago
This is a good argument, but isn't privacy all about keeping secrets from the public?
Incentives are tricky and I'm not sure we can clearly distinguish between "good" privacy and "bad" privacy. There are clear-cut cases but also a lot of grey.
But I guess that's why it's better to avoid incentives and hope for good judgement.
- landryraccoon 8y ago> But I guess that's why it's better to avoid incentives and hope for good judgement. You don’t like incentives because they’re too grey, yet relying on “good judgement” is clear cut? I have to disagree. Even if incentives are murky, untangling them is way easier to get consensus on than “good judgement”.
- skybrian 8y agoOn second thought, I'm not sure they're opposing alternatives. "How will this look in court" is a combination of incentives and judgement. It seems hard to simplify. I'm more wary of automatic incentives that are more easily gamed.