3 ms·
>More than a dozen mass murderers in the past few years took 4chan and 8chan seriously enough to murder hundreds of people. If I understand correctly, you're m
by snvzz 8y ago
>More than a dozen mass murderers in the past few years took 4chan and 8chan seriously enough to murder hundreds of people.
If I understand correctly, you're making an argument that goes around this: Exposure to freedom of speech is dangerous to society.
From this, you're proposing: All online discussion should be curated.
I don't want to live in such a world, so I kindly disagree with your proposal. Adults should be able to talk about whatever they want, and no third party should decide what they can or cannot read.
For this to be possible, communities with a very light handed approach to moderation should be allowed to continue to exist. This includes those that allow anonymous posting, as there's enough precedent in human history on perfectly fine ideas that are now generally accepted have been met with hostility. If posting safely is not an option, many will choose to not post at all. Thus ideas would get repressed.
- gamblor956 8y agoIf I understand correctly, you're making an argument that goes around this: Exposure to freedom of speech is dangerous to society. If I understand you correctly, you're making the argument that inciting someone to commit violent acts of murder is freedom of speech which is good for society. I believe in freedom of speech. I've defended it in court. What happens on 4chan and 8chan isn't free speech. It's acts of incitement that just happen to take the form of text. Adults should be able to talk about whatever they want, and no third party should decide what they can or cannot read. You don't understand that free speech relates to the words and ideas. Free speech means that the people on 4chan and 8chan can use whatever words they want, and spread whatever ideas they want. So long as they aren't committing criminal acts such as incitement. The words and ideas are protected, not the acts they represent. For this to be possible, communities with a very light handed approach to moderation should be allowed to continue to exist. This includes those that allow anonymous posting, as there's enough precedent in human history on perfectly fine ideas that are now generally accepted have been met with hostility. If posting safely is not an option, many will choose to not post at all. Thus ideas would get repressed. I agree. And if 4chan and 8chan were solely about the sharing of ideas, I would be opposed to banning them...in the US, where the law would protect such speech, however abhorrent it is. But 4chan and 8chan long ago crossed over the line into being more than just sharing ideas...they're now websites where people incite and plan violent crimes.
- ozzyman700 8y agoAny website could be a place where it is "more than just sharing ideas...they're now websites where people incite and plan violent crimes." There are many SFW boards on 4chan related to specific hobbies. I have learned a lot from diy, fa, mu, g, and ck. There are many NSFW boards on 4chan that do contain posts inciting violence. The same situation is present on reddit, but due to advertiser interest, subs get banned. There were crazy people before 4chan and there will be crazy people after. Removing a site does less than helping those in need before they become radicals.
- LinuxBender 8y agoAgreed. Plus when 4chan, a heavily moderated site gets blocked, people will just move to one of the less popular sites that may be less moderated. I used to run one of them and any time 4chan would change their rules, I would get a flood of new people.
- snvzz 8y ago>But 4chan and 8chan long ago crossed over the line into being more than just sharing ideas...they're now websites where people incite and plan violent crimes. This is a quite excessive claim. While posting in these communities is extremely easy, they are also extremely moderated. I'm somewhat familiar with the sites, and I know that while hateful posts do happen, they do get removed and posters do get banned fairly quickly. Often, within seconds. What could pass legally as actual incitement is extremely rare. Most communities and regular threads in these places are extremely friendly. Ultimately, freedom of speech isn't about being able to say whatever you want, but about others being able to say that which you don't like. Few people understand that.
- gridlockd 8y ago> ...they're now websites where people incite and plan violent crimes. Can you cite any evidence that people are planning crimes on a public-only anonymous forum that has no vetting of its members? Again, there are Nazi forums that are public, there are also Nazi networks that are certainly not public and where such attacks may have been planned, but 4chan? That would be a pretty absurd place to plan anything. As for incitement, at least in the legal sense in the US, the bar for that is quite high: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imminent_lawless_action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imminent_lawless_action