3 ms·
> Regardless of what one believes, posting specifically to inflame or upset people is a form of aggression. Serious question: is it possible to play devil's ad
by mistermann 8y ago
> Regardless of what one believes, posting specifically to inflame or upset people is a form of aggression.
Serious question: is it possible to play devil's advocate without insincere motivations? For example, say someone holds a strong but simplistic belief on a complex topic, if asking a legitimate question in a straightforward and non-offensive manner upsets the person holding the belief, is it necessarily (and always) a form of aggression?
- anigbrowl 8y agoOf course it is, but one has to have some sort of agreed frame with other discussants. Suppose we were discussing suicide cults and the question arose of why people join them; that's well worth discussing, and even debating if there are conflicting views, but discussions of how cults recruit people should be easily distinguishable from actual attempts at recruitment.
- mistermann 8y ago> but discussions of how cults recruit people should be easily distinguishable from actual attempts at recruitment Hmmmm....can you think of an example of a case where "asking a legitimate question in a straightforward and non-offensive manner" about suicide cults would not be easily distinguishable from an attempt at recruitment?
- anigbrowl 8y agoYes, I can think of many such examples because misunderstandings can and do occur. However, we are now far away from the behavior I labeled as a form of aggression, to wit 'posting specifically to inflame or upset people,' so I don't plan to proceed any further down this path of semantic possibilities.
- mistermann 8y ago> we are now far away from the behavior I labeled as a form of aggression So, it is necessarily (and always) a form of aggression then?