3 ms·
Incitement is not, nor has it ever, been protected speech. Even in the US, which originated the concept of free speech as a fundamental human right.
by gamblor956 8y ago
Incitement is not, nor has it ever, been protected speech. Even in the US, which originated the concept of free speech as a fundamental human right.
- deogeo 8y agoIn the US, incitement is a very narrow exception. According to a first-amendment lawyer: > In America, under the First Amendment, I can say something like "if Donald Trump gets elected, someone should assassinate him for the good of the nation." That statement may be immoral, and destructive of the very American values it purports to defend, but unless it calls for imminent action or expresses an objectively credible intent to do harm, it's protected speech. Source: https://www.popehat.com/2016/08/09/lawsplainer-no-donald-trumps-second-amendment-comment-isnt-criminal/ https://www.popehat.com/2016/08/09/lawsplainer-no-donald-tru...
- gamblor956 8y agoYour example is not incitement... Incitement is a specific call to action, not a general, broad-based statement. In the US, it must further be for "imminent" unlawful acts, though the "imminence" required varies based on the act incited. If Michael Cohen were to say to Roger Stone, "kill Donald Trump by poisoning his Big Mac tomorrow" that could be incitement if Cohen had previously or afterwards tried to convince stone to actually do it. (Alternatively, it could also be seen as conspiracy, and frequently prosecutors charge conspiracy instead of or in addition to incitement because they usually both apply and it's much easier to prove conspiracy.)
- deogeo 8y ago> Your example is not incitement... I know - I gave it to illustrate how narrow incitement is, if even that doesn't qualify. And it's not really mine, but given by popehat.
- icebraining 8y agoIn the US, only incitement to imminent lawless action can be made illegal. I don't see how it applies now that the perpetrator is in custody.
- gamblor956 8y agoThe US didn't ban 4chan or 8chan...New Zealand did, and it does not appear that imminence is a requirement over there. Also, imminent doesn't mean immediate. It depends on the circumstances of the crime...if a crime takes a long time to plan and carry out, "imminent" can actually mean weeks before the actual commission of the crime.