2 ms·
A large proportion of internet advertising is automatically served with no direct contact between advertiser and content provider anyway. User-generated and mos
by notahacker 16y ago
A large proportion of internet advertising is automatically served with no direct contact between advertiser and content provider anyway. User-generated and mostly user-moderated content for a non-profit organisation leaves very little room for people to make credible claims of conflict of interest. I don't think any of the Wikipedia content clones are any the less impartial for choosing Adwords over the begging bowl; their written content is literally identical.
Sure, maybe it dilutes the "brand power" of Wikipedia, but I'm not sure the "brand power" of Wikipedia is a particularly worthy cause for my donation dollars anyway.
- lwhi 16y agoWould people contribute as much if the site was supported by advertising? Would people use and trust the content as much if the site was supported by advertising? I think the answer to both of these questions is 'no'. When I talk about the Wikipedia brand losing power, this is what I'm thinking about.
- notahacker 16y agoAs I pointed out, exactly the same content with exactly the same contributors is syndicated by profit-making entities like Answers.com anyway. There's certainly no shortage of content on Jimmy Wales' own openly-commercial and frequently-interfering Wikia (arguably Wikia making it's reputation off Wikipedia association is a far bigger conflict of any interest than any conceivable advertiser could manage...) I'm sure most people use Wikipedia because they've heard of the site and/or it's almost invariably within the top three Google results of a search on any given topic and usually the most informative page. Maybe lack of ads helps maintain the illusion that it's "more neutral" than other user moderated communities, but I'm still not convinced that's an illusion worth paying for.
- lwhi 16y agoWell, I disagree. The fact other commercial sites syndicate Wikipedia's content is beside the point. I believe Wikipedia _is_ more neutral than other user moderated communities; it's not perfect, but it serves a very good purpose. I think it's worth paying for, which is why I donated.