4 ms·
I feel like that is accurate to a point, but really doesn't accurately portray the /r/KotakuinAction and similar groups views. There's a very strong undercurr
by duxup 8y ago
I feel like that is accurate to a point, but really doesn't accurately portray the /r/KotakuinAction and similar groups views. There's a very strong undercurrent of sexism and strange politics that played into it all from the very start. The "ethics" questions very much took a back seat as far as their actions as group in favor of a sort of reactionary response to social justice moments, women in staring roles in a game or movie, just about anything they could grab onto. Even things like a game not receiving a "score" that they disagreed with... They were big on memes about women with colored hair, harassment campaigns on twitter (and awkward / faked claims they were harassed), and so on, entirely disconnected from any "ethics" concern.
The fact that it was rooted in claims about a woman cheating on a man is no coincidence.
I appreciate that sites effort to remain neutral but I think at some point if a group's actions and behavior don't match their claims... then just reporting their stated motivation is actually inaccurate.
- aisengard 8y agoThe "ethics in game journalism" was basically a weaselword for what they really wanted - women out of gaming. It's a lot like how "economic anxiety" elected Trump - it's a way to excuse people's inexcusable attitudes towards others.
- duxup 8y agoYeah it grew very fast, and pivoted really fast to be a sort of identity thing. What is strange is that even for a while on their main gathering forums ... they denied even the source of the moment being the post about Zoe Quinn. It was a very fluid movement from the start, hate, us vs them, and other identity moments allow for that.
- dangerface 8y ago> harassment campaigns on twitter (and awkward / faked claims they were harassed) That /r/kotakuinaction organised harassment campaigns and that they faked harassment claims is a pretty harmful accusation, care to back it up with some evidence?
- duxup 8y agoNo I don't care to. It is a fact, they even organized it on that subreddit... it was out in the open at the time it occurred. Anyone who read that sub at that time had a chance to see them explicitly discuss and organize it. Gamergate is really a topic that folks who want to belive are going to belive, and no amount of linking is going to change anyone's mind. You literally had folks posting their tweets from their account(s) and then if things went bad that same user would claim that same twitter account was a fake account someone else made to make them look bad. It's just one of those things that I found not to be worth getting into a googling / link fight about, just as a personal policy. People can make of that what they will / not belive me, but it not worth linking to it as I find folks will belive what they're going to belive anyway.
- DuskStar 8y agoAlso as personal policy, when someone asserts something, is asked for evidence, and then comes back with "it's really well known and I'm not going to provide evidence for it", I assume that means they looked for evidence and couldn't find any. Lots of things are commonly known in a subgroup despite having no primary sources. That may not be the case here, but it's a better policy than taking things on faith in my opinion.
- duxup 8y agoI understand and respect that.
- dangerface 8y agoIf you can't or wont back up your claim then its unsubstantiated not fact. > Gamergate is really a topic that folks who want to belive are going to belive, and no amount of linking is going to change anyone's mind. Another opinion I don't share. I would rather give people the opportunity to prove me wrong so that I can have the benefit of changing my mind and being right. I hope you enjoy your beliefs.
- 8y ago
- belorn 8y agoThe one thing I am missing from that summary is a mentioning of what happen when John Bain died of cancer several years later. Several anti-GG people celebrated the death days after it was announced, which in the context of all that was said and done around GG was to me one of the worst behavior anyone committed. The only good thing is that companies has been less acceptable for such behavior. One developer from bioware got fired for it, and it likely contributed when an other developer at Anet got fired.
- duxup 8y agoI'm gonna say something that everyone uses to dismiss extremist views... and say I'm not going to try to do that. I think that behavior was terrible, but also not really generally the views of folks who might be associated with "anti-GG". Having said that... One of the catches is that there wasn't an organized "anti-GG" side in the same sense there was a "GG" core group. To some extent the "GG" folks were the ones who defined who the "anti-GG" people were, and they strongly believed that there was an "anti-GG" group that behaved in the exact same way they did, but I don't think that really added up. Sometimes they defined an "anti-gg" person as just someone who gave a poor review to a game they liked, a woman who had a visible role working for a gaming company, or just liked having a female protagonist, or something pretty disconnected. Most people that GG folks associated with "aniti-GG", really was more of an amalgam of various people and personalities who had various views .... but weren't centralized on a "anti-GG" identity, they were usually people associated with other things that had nothing to do with "video game journalism ethics". There effectively wasn't really an equivalent ying to the yang as far as groups and opposing views went. Certainly people "against" GG, but usually they were tied to other things too. What was "anti-GG" didn't even have anything to do with "video game journalism ethics" and to some extent GG found these folks views or what have you unacceptable and sort formed that concept. "Anti-GG" was often a case of who "GG" thought they were and at times simply sought them out. Like I said no doubt some folks associated themselves with "anti-GG" but it wasn't quite a ying and yang. Many of the people initially identified as "anti-GG" by "GG" folks often talked about being against online harassment, and really had no clue what GG was until things grew quickly. I feel like this process of taking an issue, expanding into an identity and tacking on ideas, then seeking out those views and people deemed unacceptable, and in some way trying to pick a sort of social media fight, is a very common thing with identity politics type behavior, and GG certainly fit that pattern. What was or wasn't "anti-GG" largely was defined by that process.
- baud147258 8y ago> The fact that it was rooted in claims about a woman cheating on a man A woman cheating with a game journalist in exchange for positive coverage on her game. GG 'supporters' will also point to collusion/cooperation (perceived or real) between many game journalists pushing a progressive agenda
- jakelazaroff 8y ago> A woman cheating with a game journalist in exchange for positive coverage on her game. Which was false: he never covered that game. https://kotaku.com/in-recent-days-ive-been-asked-several-times-about-a-pos-1624707346 https://kotaku.com/in-recent-days-ive-been-asked-several-tim...
- baud147258 8y ago:roll_eyes:
- baud147258 8y ago:rolleyes: