7 ms·
There’s a thread of truth in what you’re saying, but it unravels on close inspection. Proprietary cables are hardly new, and to be fair those cables and connec
by simonh 8y ago
There’s a thread of truth in what you’re saying, but it unravels on close inspection.
Proprietary cables are hardly new, and to be fair those cables and connectors are usually way better than the standard stuff. Firewire and thunderbolt were actually released as open standards and saw decent adoption. Lightning is far superior to Micro-USB. Just listen to the wailing and gnashing of teeth by Macbook owners having to give up proprietary MagSafe for USB-C charging on their laptops.
XCode is free and has been for ages. To this day you can develop whatever you like for the Mac and not pay Apple a penny. You don’t even have to use XCode to do it. It’s even free for iPhone development for your own device now, though you have to pay a fee to publish stuff. I’m not sure what you comment about emulators is about to be honest, The iOS emulator for the Mac is free.
Yes they want their cut from Spotify. I don’t understand the Apple exceptionalism about this though. Nobody rages on HN about Sony’s monopoly over games development for the PlayStation, or Microsoft for XBOX, or Nintendo for the Switch, but for some reason Apple which came to this business model two generations late is the root of all evil. It really is kind of weird how that works. Maybe if their iconic image was a cute little plumber instead of a half eaten fruit, everyone would say 'Aww how cute' and give them a pass.
- therockhead 8y agoHistorically the console manufacturers sold their consoles at a loss and only made profit on games sales. This might have influenced our perspective on the sales model.
- simonh 8y agoNot always. Nintendo was making a profit in each Wii sold, as a unit, from day one.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- robert_foss 8y agoXCode may cost you 0$, but you have to buy a Mac to use it. And those things are >0$ in most cases.
- Aaargh20318 8y agoYou need a Mac anyway, and the costs of a Mac is peanuts compared to the costs of a developer.
- jessemillar 8y agoWhile I understand your point, I would gently argue that to develop a truly great macOS or iOS app, you somewhat need to live in the Apple ecosystem to understand the design guidelines and quality that Apple customers have come to expect.
- asdff 8y agoI bet the most downloaded apps these days are ground up cross platform and identical on every platform, e.g. steam, spotify, and web browsers. Relying on proprietary apple features that you have to clumsily port over to another OS would waste a lot of your time as a dev. You'd probably do your best troubleshooting on a cheap, under powered hackintosh than a model year macbook pro, to be honest.
- jessemillar 8y agoFair point. I tend to not like those cross-platform apps because of their generally-degraded performance so my previous comment showed a bit of my underlying bias.
- virtualritz 8y agoYes. But parent didn't contest that. They rather made the point that you have to pay to "live" in that ecosystem. MacOS is officially only supported on Apple hardware ... So it's not free and the fact that XCode is is therefore a moot point to that line of reasoning.
- philistine 8y agoInstead of having Xcode be available on PCs, which we all know are free to own. Yeah, right.
- rhodysurf 8y agoXCode is free and has been for ages. To this day you can develop whatever you like for the Mac and not pay Apple a penny. You don’t even have to use XCode to do it. It’s even free for iPhone development for your own device now, though you have to pay a fee to publish stuff. I’m not sure what you comment about emulators is about to be honest, The iOS emulator for the Mac is free. True it is all free except the whole having the purchase a 1000 dollar computer part.
- HenryBemis 8y agoAnd there is the Apple dev annual subscription. By the way, I have (in the past) managed to run macOS on Vmware successfully, but one needs a pretty strong PC to make this work without having the fans lifting the PC off the groud.
- dev_north_east 8y ago> And there is the Apple dev annual subscription. Only if you're publishing.
- Phillips126 8y agoWe had to pay $299 for the enterprise license to distribute iOS applications internally to just our staff[1]. This circumvented the App Store entirely and we used MDM tools (AirWatch) to distribute. Was this avoidable? I'm genuinely curious as I am not specifically an iOS/Mac dev. [1] https://developer.apple.com/programs/enterprise/ https://developer.apple.com/programs/enterprise/
- larkost 8y agoNo. In order to publish (even just within your organization) you need to establish a trusted relationship, and Apple charges for that. There is plenty of room for argument about how much Apple should be charging for this, but the process does have some costs to Apple, so it is only right that they charge something.
- 8y ago
- umanwizard 8y agoApple publishes an iOS simulator, not an emulator, which is a totally different thing.
- larkost 8y agoYes, it is different. But how is that important in this conversation. Here the important bit is: have a tool that enables you to test your iOS code on your development machine. Emulation vs. simulation is not generally important in that. Side note undercutting my point: there are places, like OpenGL where the underlying hardware is significantly better/different and the iOS simulation is not representative of the real environment. Mostly these only matter to high-end games, and there you better be checking regularly on a list of hardware.
- umanwizard 8y agoYou’re absolutely right that it’s not important to the conversation; I’m just being pedantic and going on a tangent :) But I have seen enough real bugs due to people not understanding the limitations of iOS simulator realism that I would really like it if more people understood the issue. It also matters in more than high-performance GPU rendering. It’s easy to miss bog-standard CPU performance or memory leak bugs when you’re running software designed for a 1GB Ram, dual core CPU machine on a 32GB, 8 core machine
- vinceguidry 8y ago> Yes they want their cut from Spotify. I don’t understand the Apple exceptionalism about this though. No Spotify's letter put it very clearly, they want to take their 30% cut from Spotify while putting their own music service on the market undercutting their prices. This is blatantly anticompetitive and is rightly being slammed by Congress. Apple's response to this has been shrug. I don't think Apple shouldn't be allowed to offer their own music service but they shouldn't use anti-competitive practices in order to stifle competition.
- graeme 8y agoDid apple music price below spotify/ not familiar with the pricing history.
- vinceguidry 8y agoThey used shady tactics to force them to bill through the Apple's marketplace so they could get the 30% cut, forcing Spotify to raise prices by 30% so they could maintain their revenue position. Then they released Apple Music at the $9.99 price point that Spotify was at previously. The shady tactics resumed when Spotify stopped using the App Store to bill and reduced the price to compete with Apple Music. Apple isn't interested in competing with Spotify, only with freezing them out of the market.
- Benjammer 8y agoWhy does the value of Apple's App Store infrastructure and network effects always get zeroed out in the equation here? Spotify is welcome to build their own app distribution infrastructure on their own mobile hardware and charge whoever whatever they want for it and keep all the profits themselves.
- vinceguidry 8y agoApple does not offer a legitimate way for developers to release apps for their hardware other than the App Store. I suppose you could go even further and say that Spotify should make and market their own phones, but luckily American commerce doesn't work that way.
- VectorLock 8y ago>Just listen to the wailing and gnashing of teeth by Macbook owners having to give up proprietary MagSafe for USB-C charging on their laptops. For me personally and I think for a lot of people that is less about a love for MagSafe than it is an aversion to USB-C.
- vesrah 8y agoThe difference in the way the USB-C cable and Magsafe handle an off angle tug seals the debate for me.
- VectorLock 8y agoFor every time MagSafe saved me from an errant tug there were 100,000 times it inconvenienced me by disconnecting with the slightest movement.
- jonahb 8y agoNobody rages on HN about Sony’s monopoly over games development for the PlayStation Might be because the App Store is the sole channel. Also, apps are easier to substitute than games, making anti-competitive behavior possible.
- scarface74 8y agoAnd even if you buy a physical game for the Playststion, the game still has to be approved by Sony.