7 ms·
Model Y will have Full Self-Driving capability, enabling automatic driving on city streets and highways pending regulatory approval, as well as the ability to c
by Rebelgecko 8y ago
Model Y will have Full Self-Driving capability, enabling automatic driving on city streets and highways pending regulatory approval, as well as the ability to come find you anywhere in a parking lot.
Pending regulatory approval, and also they need figure out how to make it work first.
Off the top of my head I remember similar claims being made about the summoning feature of the model S. Has it lived up to the marketing promises?
- x38iq84n 8y agoNope, Tesla is still blatantly lying.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y agoThat we don't know. And we know that you don't know either. So who's a liar?
- x38iq84n 8y agoCoast-to-coast AP demo was promised before Eo2017. Still waiting. Meanwhile, the AP cannot handle traffic lights, city traffic, conditions of bad weather, sections of road with poor or temporary lanes, it crashes to high-vis large stationary objects directly in line of sight and travel, yada yada. They don't seem to have anything solid to back up the promises with, so claiming that "enabling automatic driving on city streets and highways pending regulatory approval" is very deceptive and insincere with potential customers.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 8y agoSo you admit it was not a lie. The coast-to-coast demo for EoY 2017 was not a promise either, but a goal. Elon Musk, 2017: >Our goal is — I feel pretty good about this goal — is that we’ll be able to do a demonstration drive of full autonomy, all the way from L.A. to New York — so, basically, from a home in L.A. to, let’s say, dropping you off in Times Square, in New York, then having the car go and park itself by the end of next year — without the need for a single touch, including the charging. Elon Musk, 2018: >I’ve been meaning to address this, because obviously I missed the mark on that front. I mean, focus was very much on Model 3 production so everything else kind of took a second place to that. We could have done the coast-to-coast drive but it would have required too much specialized code to effectively game it, or make it somewhat brittle in that it would work for one particular route but not be a general solution. Who's hyping things up here? >They don't seem to have anything solid to back up the promises (...) So now you say "they don't seem to", because you don't know? Okay.
- unityByFreedom 8y agoRidiculous amounts of pedantry here. Apparently companies can't lie because they have goals, according to a two year old account, 1/3 of whose comments are about Tesla.
- jfoster 8y agoIt's a funny concept. People who haven't even purchased the product feel that the company has promised them things and feel aggravated if those "promises" go unfulfilled. In reality, Tesla is a company with such ambitious goals that they often fail only to later succeed. The fact that so many people want to tear them down for that is very sad.
- iainmerrick 8y ago“Lying” is strong, but it’s over-promising and under-delivering. It’s reasonable to take their current goals with a large pinch of salt.
- jfoster 8y agoThey're not promising. They're sharing their ambitious goals. If you only have goals that you already know you can meet or if you always attain your goals, you're aiming too low.
- iainmerrick 8y agoFrom earlier in this thread: ”Our goal is — I feel pretty good about this goal — is that we’ll be able to do a demonstration drive of full autonomy, all the way from L.A. to New York” I guess it depends whether you interpret that “I feel good about this goal” means “I think we have a good chance of achieving this” or just “having this goal makes me feel good.” I think we’re at least partly agreeing. Tesla just has a very different approach here than, say, Apple. That’s not inherently bad but I personally don’t like it. I see it as excessive hype.
- 8y ago
- cmsonger 8y ago> So who's a liar? "Liar" is a stronger word than I would use, but given the claims (including dates) that Tesla made when I purchased an S100D in early 2017 -- seems like the answer is Tesla. If not "liar", at least incredibly dramatically wrong about what they actually delivered for EAP and FSD. I'd say the burden of proof is now firmly on Tesla as they've made and missed a number of claims about the performance of their automation features.
- jeremyjh 8y agoThey are implying that AP is complete and it works, and they are just waiting on approval. This is not true.
- leesec 8y agoThey are implying that it WILL be complete. The Model Y doesn't ship until end of 2020.
- FireBeyond 8y agoHe said not two weeks ago that you will be able to self drive coast to coast, "this year", apropos of any shipping date for the Y.
- paulcole 8y agoAgreed. I'll give the benefit of the doubt to Elon Musk who has an unparalleled track record of honesty...
- deegles 8y agoSomeone can say they've home-built a rocket and flown to the moon, and I don't have to be an aerospace expert to call BS.
- Rooster61 8y agoBut Musk never lies. I mean, I've never seen him say things that were utterly untrue to drive stoc- sees SEC crackdowns on twitter posts .....Ohhhhh, right
- sandworm101 8y agoWhat if i get that regulatory approval? There is plenty of privately owned land where i could tesla all day, some with traffic lights and everything. Or perhaps this feature is "pending" far more than regulatory approval.
- mikejb 8y agoTesla is using the "we're just waiting for regulatory approval"-line for years on their Autopilot page. It's there to hide how far (behind?) development on this tech is. Seeing how many videos exist of incidents where AP misbehaves (or even actively steers the car into barriers), it seems reasonable to assume that "regulatory approval" isn't the blocking issue for releasing full self-driving. (Could they release this feature with the traditional AP requirements of human oversight?)
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoI call BS on this. EVERY autonomous driving expert agrees that Tesla is years away from Waymo or GM, and years away from their own claims.
- leesec 8y agoWaymo maybe but not GM. Also not EVERY autonomous driving expert. Also they're different approaches.
- disease 8y agoGM is way ahead of Tesla in this field. https://arstechnica.com/cars/2018/10/tesla-autopilot-loses-to-gms-super-cruise-in-consumer-reports-ratings/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2018/10/tesla-autopilot-loses-t...
- mhermher 8y agoYes, but they're so much less willing to put people's safety at risk, so really, they're way behind.
- beering 8y agoThe review put Super Cruise higher than Tesla Autopilot because of better driver monitoring and geofencing. It doesn't speak much to how far ahead each company is on self-driving technology. Both Super Cruise and Autopilot are bad representations of where GM/Cruise and Tesla's cutting edge is at.
- Domenic_S 8y agoThe context is different between the two. Super Cruise got high marks because of its focus on driver engagement/awareness, it's very clearly an "assist" feature. Autopilot is intended to become autonomous, so driver monitoring is so much lower on the list.
- tim333 8y agoFor what it's worth Musk says he's confident: >I think we will be feature complete full self-driving this year meaning the car will be able to find you in a parking lot pick you up take you all the way to your destination without an intervention. This year. I would say that I am certain of that, that is not a question mark. >However people sometimes will extrapolate that to mean now it works with one hundred percent certainty we're requiring no observation perfectly. This is not the case. Once it is feature complete then you're sort of kind of the march of nines like how many nines of reliability do you want to be and then when do regulators agree that it is that that is that reliable so this feature complete post full self-driving this year with certainty. >This is something that we control and I managed autopilot engineering directly every week in detail so I'm certain to this. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8dEYm8hzLo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8dEYm8hzLo 10 mins in or so) And that you can probably sleep while it drives around end 2020
- unethical_ban 8y agoI assume they mean they have equipped it with the sensor and computational capacity, and motor control, required (in their analysis) to implement self-driving when the software and regulators are ready.
- mikejb 8y agoThey should then really say "technology readiness and regulatory approval pending".