3 ms·
Who spends more money on art/entertainment than groceries?
by colechristensen 8y ago
Who spends more money on art/entertainment than groceries?
- meruru 8y agoI would be interested in a breakdown of spending by different demographics. Personally, my grocery spending is pretty low, but art/media spending is almost nonexistent, unless you count my ISP bill.
- rch 8y agoIt seems like they would indeed count at least a portion of your ISP bill, as it relates to media streaming services.
- benj111 8y agoThey mention agriculture, not groceries. Farmers don't get paid anywhere near the retail price. And that's excluding all the processed food where the farmers get even less as a proportion.
- colechristensen 8y agoThey mention broadcasting, art-related retail, and several other things associated with facilitating trade instead of creation. If you include art galleries and bookstores, you should include restaurants and grocery stores right? The USDA has a chart of household expenditures: food=13%, transportation=16%, entertainment+alcohol=6.2% https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/Charts/58275/agfood-sector_fig02-002-fw_350px.png?v=8130.7 https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/Charts/58275/agfood-sector_... Looks like the NEA and the USDA are making reports that make their own sector shine. One talking about household expenditures, the other GDP "contribution". I know I could not convince anyone (or myself) of the significance of the different measurements, but when it comes to "X is bigger than Y", the takeaway for the average reader, the headline and report ring false.
- benj111 8y ago"Looks like the NEA and the USDA are making reports that make their own sector shine" Probably, you didn't point to a conflicting source, so I was just going from the article. One thing you didn't account for is balance of trade. Art in the NEA definition is probably a net exporter. Food probably not? (you can export raw materials, and you can export the brand. As a non American though, my big mac has never seen America, so I really don't know how that would feed through to those figures). Agriculture also attracts subsidies, that could account for the disparity, although it could increase the disparity so I don't know. Long story short, the figures don't necessarily contradict each other.
- Jedi72 8y agoI live in the inner city, eat out a lot and its not unusual for me to drop a hundred bucks on tickets in a week. I eat at a restaurant for my lunch break, I probably spend ~$30/week on groceries. People like me are the reason for the article I guess.
- ProblemFactory 8y agoMost of the world population spends more on American-made movies, music and video games than they spend on American-made food.
- negamax 8y agoNetflix + Prime + (1-2 Apple Movies) + Books + Movies in Theatre + Games.. I say it's reasonable to assume people spend a lot on entertainment. May be without realizing. Different reward centers?