2 ms·
> I think posing the question as a ROI calculation Posing it as brain dead ROI calculation like an academic economist would just misses pretty much everything
by Gibbon1 8y ago
> I think posing the question as a ROI calculation
Posing it as brain dead ROI calculation like an academic economist would just misses pretty much everything about bringing a new design to market and why companies do things.
The conundrum is. You never make money on a new blue printed design. You make money reselling tweaks of old stuff. But the reality that you need to innovate or eventually go out of business.
Never innovating and eventually going out of business is a valid strategy. That's basically the hedge fund strategy.
But companies that aren't controlled by capitalists never do that because there is nothing in it for the people that run the company. Since that's VW they'll they chose to lose money innovating. So the company stays in business and they keep their jobs and status.
- dv_dt 8y ago> But companies that aren't controlled by capitalists never do that I would say that there are a range of companies that are to different mixes of being ruled by accounting vs ruled by innovation. Ironically, I would say the companies most ruled by accounting are the ones with the best foundational resources to make targeted innovation bets (but don't because the ROI doesn't pencil out...).
- Misdicorl 8y agoEVs are tweaks though. Nobody buys ICE vehicles. They buy sedans, trucks, SUVs, etc. What the engine uses as an energy input doesn't matter and won't for another decade.
- Gibbon1 8y agoYou're thinking of classes of vehicles. Where what I'm referring to is major components, engines, transmissions, suspension, structural design. Those designs tend to be very long lived on the order of 15 to 30 years. Designing from scratch takes a long time and results in teething issues as the design flaws get worked out. The expense and time it takes stretches the ROI out. Tweaks involve modifying already well understood systems. Risk is limited, return on investment is quick. Allows you to keep making money.