3 ms·
The UBI of $1K a month is insane. This would be 320 million Americans receiving $1K a month per person? That's $320B a month...$3.8 Trillion a year. That's DOUB
by chrisco255 8y ago
The UBI of $1K a month is insane. This would be 320 million Americans receiving $1K a month per person? That's $320B a month...$3.8 Trillion a year. That's DOUBLE the current Federal government's annual expenditures. He argues, with hand-wavey logic, that this will solve our problems and we can tax tech companies and all of this...but no, there's not enough annual revenue at the big tech companies to cover this enormous welfare program.
- r00fus 8y agoIs the UBI taxable income? Perhaps UBI would generate enough revenue to be cost neutral or even cost positive. Exasmple: food stamps generate $1.73 in tax revenue for each $1 handed out. It's just good policy - to a point.
- chillacy 8y agoFrom his interviews the UBI is not taxed, but the money comes from: 1. Consolidating existing welfare programs with large bureaucracies (500-600BN) 2. 10% VAT on companies which report 0 profits (800BN) 3. Projected economic growth leading to sales taxes (this is like the foot stamp example you shared) 4. Healthcare, prisons, etc (100-200BN)
- chrisco255 8y ago1. What prevents the UBI from generating its own large bureaucracy? 2. VAT taxes come in the form of higher prices on everything. No such thing as a free lunch. 4. Healthcare, prisons is handwavey logic. Again, we already provide free healthcare to the poor via Medicaid. So there are no gains to be had there. He makes the wild guess that welfare payments would reduce crime, even though we saw the highest crime rates in the 80s and 90s prior to welfare reform (which reduced the number of people on welfare). So no, I don't buy any of it. There is no experiment of this being tried in the wild, at the city, county, or state level. Why would you take an epic proposal and immediately propose a huge shift of resources in the economy without any evidence to back it up?
- chillacy 8y ago1. "The government is bad at a lot of things but it's great at writing checks to people on time", because there's no income cutoff or other eligibility requirements it becomes a lot easier to manage than existing welfare programs. 2. VAT is designed to capture value from companies which employ few people, generate a lot of value, but report little in profits, which are a lot of tech companies today. 4. We spend more on healthcare to worse results than other developed countries, a lot is institutional inefficiency. There's definitely evidence out there to support that people are suffering more even though GDP goes up, look at the labor participation rate of working-age men in these swing states. Epic proposal? Alaska has been running a UBI from the 60s, instituted by a Republican governor and it's wildly popular. A UBI almost passed under Nixon as well, passing the house and getting killed in the senate twice because democrats wanted the amounts to be bigger. The way I see it, we either do this now or we continue to keep our heads in the sand while the country rots from the center.
- chrisco255 8y agoApple earned $60B in taxable income in 2018. Amazon $2.8B. Amazon has a business model where they continue to reinvest profits in the business. Amazon employs 500,000+ people at minimum wage of $15 an hour. They do plenty for the economy as a whole. And if you tax them with VATs, they'll just increase prices on goods. There is no way around it. If you tax with VATs and extract value out of Amazon, you get less capital investment from companies like Amazon, which are highly efficient at capital allocation. That's the reason our economy grows in the first place. Redistributing capital to consumers only incentivizes and subsidizes consumption. To some extent consumption is good, but too much consumption and not enough production leads to a stale and stagnant economy. Alaska has a budget crisis right now, and they owe back pay to their citizens on the PFD. Besides that obvious disaster, it's a variable payout based on oil money. How sustainable do you think that will be once, say, electric cars become a thing? The variable payout has been as high as $2,000 a person per year...to as low as $800 a year. Alaska has benefited, like many oil-rich nations (including Norway), from a relatively small population with relatively large oil reserves and huge markets to sell those reserves to. Alaska has a population of about 750,000. Smaller than most large U.S. metropolitan areas. If they had the population of Texas (28 million)...that oil dividend would amount to $54 a year (in its highest amount ever). The U.S. is almost three orders of magnitude larger than Alaska in terms of population. A LOT changes at that scale. Especially when the U.S. is THE largest market on the planet. We are the market other industries strive to sell to. Wreck that market, and you'll wreck the world economy. (https://www.newsminer.com/news/alaska_news/dunleavy-embraces-full-pfd-back-pay/article_c88cd77a-157b-11e9-b353-7716eacba0aa.html https://www.newsminer.com/news/alaska_news/dunleavy-embraces...)
- beat 8y agoYou don't know anything about his "hand-wavey logic", or you'd know right away that it's not "320 million Americans". It's only adults from age 18-65 (or whenever they choose to retire to Social Security, presumably).
- chrisco255 8y agoIt would be whatever bastardized form of it Congress passes and by the way, Social Security is already on the path to insolvency. It's still a multi-trillion dollar proposal, a huge economic experiment that could easily end in catastrophe and not be easily reversible (as people would come to depend on payments, try taking that away from them). It's batshit crazy.
- beat 8y agoIn his book, Andrew Yang points out that one of the major factors damaging Social Security right now is a sharp rise (like a doubling) in disability cases. And the amount of people on disability maps directly to areas of economic depression and underemployment. Basically, it's become an alternative form of long-term unemployment for people who are unable to find work. And worse, since getting a job will likely lead to losing benefits, it actively discourages employment and makes people think of themselves as broken failures. That all said, what is your alternative? Let huge swaths of the country degenerate into poverty and despair? Wait for them to vote an actual fascist into office? Or riot? Given a choice between higher taxes and civil war, I will gladly choose higher taxes.
- chrisco255 8y agoSensationalize much? Taxes wouldn't just be a little bit higher under this proposal they'd be double what they are today...in the name of social welfare. And when that ruins the economy, you'll be dealing with another Venezuela. Social security isn't on its way to insolvency because of disability expansion...it's on its way to insolvency because it was designed in an age when we had an average of three children per female and life expectancy was shorter. Now that we're down to two and possibly dropping...there's less workers per retiree.