4 ms·
Internal Combustion only vehicles are likely to be banned by 2030 and forecourt plug-in hybrids by 2035. Several member countries are aiming to eliminate combus
by simonh 8y ago
Internal Combustion only vehicles are likely to be banned by 2030 and forecourt plug-in hybrids by 2035. Several member countries are aiming to eliminate combustion engine vehicles from the roads by the mid 2040s. These are mostly stated goals at this stage rather than legislation.
I can't see Germany being happy signing off on rules that would kill their own auto industry.
- sandworm101 8y agoNor commit to the massive electrical infrastructure improvements such a policy would necessitate. Charging ever car, truck and digger across a country isnt as simple a few charge points in parking lots. The power has to come from something. That something has to be biult by someone somewhere. Nimby means that will take decades.
- Brakenshire 8y agoThe majority of charging in Western Europe will happen overnight and at home, combine that with 'smart chargers', which are technologically trivial, appropriate tariffs giving a discount in exchange for flexible demand overnight, and a thirty year period to make the transition (even if all new cars were electric from 2035), and I doubt the impact on the grid will be that dramatic. You will actually likely have improved utilization of existing assets, coupled with a lot of extra revenue going to power companies, away from oil companies. Motorway charging systems, which will be a small minority of total charging, will need ongoing grid upgrades, but spikes in demand can be buffered by trickle charging batteries, and dealing with increased electricity demand can scale gradually and incrementally as the transition occurs over that 30 year period. The infrastructure improvements will likely come under national infrastructure provisions which limit planning objections. I actually think the grid transition will mostly happen without people realizing.
- sandworm101 8y agoOf cars. But cars are not anywhere near the bulk of IC engine capacity. Between trucks, trains, ships and construction equipment, there is a huge amount of power that will have to come from somewhere. Those devices don't just commute twice a day then sit in a garage charging. They basically run all day, in some cases 24/7 (trucks/trains). They will need a steady supply from some sort of power plant/grid.
- stefanfisk 8y agoAren’t most European trains already electric?
- sandworm101 8y agoCommuter trains, yes. "Most european trains" also probably yes as that would include the commuters. But if we are talking about replacing one engine system with another, the real measure is horsepower. Diesel is still a norm for long-haul freight, the real heavy lifting. In total amount of horsepower being used, diesel is still king. There are many reasons for this, the big one being a lack of standardization among European countries re overhead power supplies. A diesel can drive across boarders without worry about voltage or current changes. And I do laugh a little when they talk about removing the internal combustion trains. Nobody is talking about the external combustion trains, the steam trains. They are carbon nightmares but we keep them for nostalgic rides and movies about wizards. Will we do the same with diesels?
- Brakenshire 8y agoIt seems that you’re arguing with a straw man because these bans which are being talked about are for road transport, no government is proposing to ban IC ships, trains, and farm and construction equipment over that time frame, although it will likely be the case that a programme of electrification will be continued and stepped up. Similarly I don’t know why you’re talking about steam engines, they are totally insignificant.
- adrianN 8y agoNobody is talking about external combustion trains because you can count them on your fingers. The amount of coal they use is minuscule in the grand scheme of things. They also don't tend to run through inner cities.
- otto-mate 8y agoYes there's work to do, but it's not insurmountable. The National Grid in the UK has already said it would support"a more ambitious target” than the UK Government has set for the end to ICE vehicles.
- CydeWeys 8y agoThere's lots of spare capacity in the electrical grid. It's built to handle peak load (late afternoon/early evening). This can be solved with simple economic incentives to charge more for electricity at peak times. The cars are already smart enough to be programmed to charge themselves over night. Plug them in when you get home, and then they start charging once peak is over, with plenty of time to finish topping up by morning (especially considering most people won't drive close to a full battery's worth on the average day).
- billbrown 8y agoIf all the country's cars are charging overnight, do you think that that might come to be considered "peak" or become otherwise more expensive electricity?
- benj111 8y agoIn that case all you need is dynamic time of day pricing and a feedback mechanism to the cars. Or you could give control of the car batteries to the power companies, and let them charge them by X oclock, this has already been suggested as part of a virtual power station type setup.
- CydeWeys 8y agoThe point is that you'd charge them off-peak, whenever that might be. The ideal scenario would be no more peaks or troughs at all, yielding a perfectly level baseline at all times, moderated by all the grid-attached batteries in vehicles and buildings that are smartly choosing when to draw (or even feed back) power. And the majority of the nation's electricity usage will never be for automobile transportation, even if 100% of vehicles were electric. There's simply too many other big consumers of electricity.
- skriticos2 8y agoYep. That's the current problem. They have built a ton of wind-farms out in the north sea and have industry in the very south of the country. So they want to build a set of power-lines that connects these places called SuedLink. They started sometime around 2014 and are still only a fraction of the way there. So charging in the north will be fine, not so much in the middle or south. Nobody wants a giant power-line around them and they faced stiff protests against the routes. If I recall correctly, they now want to bury the power-lines underground to avoid some of the public opposition. In the meantime Germany is switching off its nuclear infrastructure (because people hate that too) so that they can buy nuclear power from France (which is perfectly fine?). Also Germany spent billions on the green energy initiative in the past decade and is still hooked ~35% on lignite, one of the most polluting sorts of coal out there. Without the power-lines that bring green energy from the sea, the e-car revolution will be difficult (unless we want to burn coal of course). Established modern society is so dysfunctional when it comes to big projects that aim to change an existing system.
- jdietrich 8y agoI might suggest doing a little research on vehicle-to-grid and demand side response technology. Millions of EVs plugged into chargers equates to many gigawatthours of instant on-demand storage capacity. EVs are primarily charged overnight when supply outweighs demand, and their charge controllers can dynamically alter the charge rate in response to grid load. The transition to EVs and the transition to renewable energy goes hand-in-hand; relatively modest investments in local power distribution infrastructure combined with intelligent control systems could have a vastly positive impact on the stability of a grid with predominantly renewable generation capacity.
- sandworm101 8y agoIn theory. I haven't seen any actual implementation whereby road vehicles would be discharged onto the grid during peak demand. The EV drivers I've talked to, every one of them, are simply not open to the idea of discharging their vehicles back onto the grid. It isn't about money. They don't want the hassle of a discharged car, nor the wear on their batteries. The potential money involved (a few dollars at most) is totally irrelevant to them. Dedicated deep-cycle bats, lead acid cells, are the better option for grid tied storage.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoInfrastructure isn't a big challenge, and plenty of utilities have some out stating this. The biggest change will probably time-of-use pricing for the places that don't have it. EVs can be charged overnight very easily, when the grid is underutilized. If you encourage this with pricing, you actually even out grid demand and make it easier to manage.